4 ms·
Far enough away that even if there are no issues with scaling, we're going to face a climate change catastrophe, before we can replace fossil fuels with fusion.
by vkou 7y ago
Far enough away that even if there are no issues with scaling, we're going to face a climate change catastrophe, before we can replace fossil fuels with fusion.
We need to take drastic action on power generation in the next decade. There isn't a snowball's chance in hell that fusion will make it in time. I can't over-emphasize how dire our current situation is - and that's with us currently living in a world where 3 cent/kwh solar power exists.
If we're gambling on fusion, at this point, the best-case outcome for it would be that it could be brought online sometime between us hitting 'drastic climate catastrophe' and 'civilization ending climate catastrophe'. To me, that doesn't sound like a great situation to be in.
- epicureanideal 7y agoAlthough some research out of Finland indicates otherwise. http://www.helsinkitimes.fi/finland/finland-news/domestic/16562-finnish-scientists-effect-of-human-activity-on-climate-change-insignificant.html http://www.helsinkitimes.fi/finland/finland-news/domestic/16... https://arxiv.org/pdf/1907.00165.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1907.00165.pdf
- SiempreViernes 7y agoSo is this novel climate change denial argument, or some old debunked idea reheated in Turku?
- neuronexmachina 7y agoThis debunks Kauppinen & Malmi's (non-peer-reviewed) paper pretty thoroughly: https://climatefeedback.org/claimreview/non-peer-reviewed-manuscript-falsely-claims-natural-cloud-changes-can-explain-global-warming/ https://climatefeedback.org/claimreview/non-peer-reviewed-ma...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hueving 7y agoThere is no civilization ending climate catastrophy on the horizon. Wipe out 90% of the population and we're back to what, the 1800s? That level of death requires most people to just let the rising ocean drown them as they stand there plus a bunch more inland to walk in and drown themselves as well. Massively distruption to the status quo is what climate change will bring. Civilization ending? Not even close.
- adrianN 7y agoOne million refugees caused political crisis in Europe. What do you think will happen if half of Africa starts moving north because agriculture becomes impossible? And that's just the easy part. What happens when important ecological systems collapse? For example if phytoplankton dies off at a massive scale?
- socialdemocrat 7y agoI upvoted you for adding some perspective often lacking. However you are still kind of wrong. You are right that humans will continue to live and survive. But our civilization as we know it may very well collapse. Yes some sort of civilization will continue to exist. But this will be on par with the dark ages: not a complete destruction of human civilization but an enormous regression. We will most likely loose a lot of our technological know-how and abilities. Events like this don't simply cause a gradual decline in standards of living. Rather they tend to cause massive outbreaks of wars, unrest, migrations, refugees, destruction etc. Climate change in the bronze age caused nearly all major bronze age civilizations to collapse. But with this collapse we had major migration of people, wars, invasions, collapse of trade and many more things. What followed was large population declines as well as losing the ability to write and maintain organized rule, construct buildings etc. Did all humans disappear? Of course not, that is why civilization reappeared again eventually at a later time. The same will likely happen with us. But how long will the dark ages last? In many ways our resilience is weaker than theirs. Our trade networks are far more extensive and important than the ancient ones. What happens e.g. if the middle east, Africa and South America are turned into turmoil and we can no longer get resources extracted from either of those places? Our economies may suffer a lot too, causing the breakout of widespread riots and unrest, overthrow of governments. If modern trade breaks down, there will be widespread famines even in the west, because many countries simply are not self sufficient. And if they are, their food production depends on a large number of imports. If they don't get hold of artificial fertilizer, fuel etc food production will collapse. This is what we saw after the fall or Rome. Economies became far more regionalized/local. In a collapsing world economy, countries will become significantly poorer if forced to rely exclusively on local production of most essential things.
- Retric 7y agoFusion is not about climate change. It’s one of those things that enable sending spacecraft to other stars. D-T fusion is still baby steps on that path, but worthwhile none the less.
- dylan604 7y agoGreat, so we send our greatest energy generation tech out for some crazy alien teenager out for a joy ride bump into it rather than using at home?
- Ygg2 7y agoI don't think it's just about space travel. Unlocking fusion, allows us to tap into a near infinite source of fuel. On a planetary scale.
- vkou 7y agoI don't care one whit about travel to other stars, when we are facing an existential crisis with sustainably maintaining our ecosystem on Earth.
- de_watcher 7y agoOr maybe you're facing an existential crisis here because you don't care about travel to other stars.
- youareostriches 7y agoThis fantasy is almost more intellectually insulting than straight up climate denial. What kind of dream world do you inhabit where you think it’s easier to travel to other stars or terraform planets than simply not “shit where you eat” on this planet? Slow down our economic growth? Stop dumping trash? Nah, that’s too hard. Let’s build fucking rockets to other solar systems instead and invent entirely new life support systems to survive in places without any food, water, or air at all. Sure, that’s way easier than planting a garden. Even if this were possible, the technology almost certainly wouldn’t be ready by the time civilization fully collapsed at the end of the century.