4 ms·
I'm so tired of this unapologetic Tesla hand holding. > No other company has the infrastructure to be able to do that. Because they don't want it. They don't
by BoorishBears 7y ago
I'm so tired of this unapologetic Tesla hand holding.
> No other company has the infrastructure to be able to do that.
Because they don't want it. They don't want AP regressions we've already seen happen. They don't want engineers testing code out on real people's lives.
You really think other companies just don't know how to send OTA updates to an ECU or other car components?
I could literally put that together with scraps in my garage, my car's ECU can be flashed over OBD, it'd be trivial to write firmware for a microcontroller to repeat a set of OBD commands downloaded from a webserver.
Obviously an auto manufacturer would do more than that, but there is literally nothing but choice stopping other manufacturers from doing this.
Why is everything Tesla does always suddenly some sort of competitive advantage. Next people will be saying the fact they have cars that spell out "S3XY" is a competitive advantage.
- leesec 7y agoYou are giving big OEM's way too much credit, imo, haha. What you suggested would take at least a year for them to setup at all, let alone work the bugs and making it useful.
- snuze 7y agoAs someone in the industry (with domain knowledge), I can tell you that you are oversimplifying the problem and ignoring Tesla’s advantage and leadership in this space. Other manufacturers have to account for legacy systems/designs, it is not as trivial as you make it sound.
- gamblor956 7y agoTesla has to account for legacy systems and designs, since they refresh models all the time without even bothering with distinct ("set in stone") model identifiers (like year). For example, there is no such thing as a "2018 Model 3" as there were multiple variants released over the year with changes over the year, not including the range-based option packages. In fact, Tesla's legacy systems are actually a disadvantage perspective, since they have to account for a much larger range of hardware configurations than do legacy automakers.
- BoorishBears 7y agoI even state that I'm oversimplifying the problem. Other manufacturers do have to account for legacy systems, you don't need to be in the industry to understand the relationships manufacturers have with companies like Bosch and know they're not in full control of their destiny. But their advantage is not a "let's ignore dumpster fire financials quarter of quarter to earn them a multi billion dollar market cap" big. Tesla is not worth 42B dollars because manufacturers can't figure out OTA updates, and the fact other manufacturers don't have OTA updates should be a rounding error when you list advantages that warrant that market cap. It doesn't take any insider knowledge to know that, just common sense, and for far too long people have been ignoring that in preference for TSLA hype. I got out last year during the 420 nonsense so honestly I don't know why I'm even bothering with all this, the fact anyone needs more than that to see TSLA is not worth your time is interesting. Anything from that point onward was just icing on the bear cake for me.
- mavhc 7y agoEveryone else not doing updates is the symptom of the larger issue, everyone else is a slow moving hardware company that outsources their software. Tesla is a software company first. And software beats hardware whenever you're doing something complex. Plus lack of legacy self competition, no one else wants to cannibalise their other sales, and no one else has really invested in batteries. Most other car companies can't make enough EV cars to fulfill demand. They're all out of stock until next year because they make so few of them.
- ReptileMan 7y agoThis is a glorified bumper car. Why does it needs updates at all? It should be KISS... instead they complicate for the sake of complication.
- mavhc 7y agoMostly because people ask for features. And to support new charging stuff. Everyone loves Sentry mode, automatic video recordings of people damaging your car while it's parked. Then there's "entertain people while charging" stuff. And then there's autopilot stuff. NoA, Stop light detection, emergency lane departure avoidance, automatic lane changing, conditional speed limits (eg slower in winter)
- icanhackit 7y agoRunning the latest neural net build in a shadow mode pitted against the real world driver and relaying back telemetry where the shadow NN took an opposing action is a little more sophisticated than pushing out an ECU update. I think you're being a little uncharitable or simply don't understand what Tesla are doing.
- BoorishBears 7y agoI say you're intentionally confusing two points. >Being able to test your code out in the real world and dark launch a feature gives Tesla a ridiculous advantage. Is the comment I'm responding to. You're intentionally dragging the rest of it into the conversation to make my point seem absurd. Par for the course for Tesla defenders.
- icanhackit 7y ago>> Being able to test your code out in the real world and dark launch a feature gives Tesla a ridiculous advantage. > Is the comment I'm responding to. And that dark launching includes sending the latest neural net builds to the fleet to safely shadow test the changes, collecting millions of hours of real-world telemetry and rapidly iterating without end users even needing to pick their nose. You either intentionally or through ignorance reduced OP's statement to being an OTA ECU update that you "could literally put that together with scraps in my garage". But feel free to keep shifting the goal posts.
- BoorishBears 7y agoI hate it when people say "keep shifting goal posts" in the most random contexts to sound pithy. I said no OEM wants their engineers to have a capability and you're fixating on the uses of the capability. My comment is saying it doesn't matter if they wanted to use it for something as trivial as ECU updates, They. Do. Not. Want. It. If you want a case study in why, AP regressions are a fine one. They don't want the liability when an updates goes wrong and kills people. They do not see people's lives as prod vs dev. They do not want to hotfix safety critical systems. They want to get it right the first time, and that's why they're conservative and by god, they get it right a lot more than they get it wrong. Because no matter how much spin TSLA fanboys put on these things, they are liabilities as much as, if not more, than they are strengths, especially combined with the flippant approach to valuing human life the company that called Adaptive Cruise Control + Lane Centering "Autopilot"
- mandeepj 7y agoRest of the car companies are like Boeing. I hope you are keeping up with that. If not here's the latest - https://www.cnn.com/2019/07/24/business/boeing-loss/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/07/24/business/boeing-loss/index.ht...
- jayd16 7y ago>Why is everything Tesla does always suddenly some sort of competitive advantage Because the difference between could do and did is massive.
- Fins 7y agoAnd difference between "did" and "should or should not do" is even more massive, although completely beyond Elon's (admittedly rather limited) powers of understanding.
- 693471 7y agoHave you considered that OTA updates undercut the dealership network and could be seen as servicing vehicles which in many states is illegal for the manufacturer to do so they could suffer consequences, maybe getting banned from selling in that state?
- tracer4201 7y agoSeems like those states should change their laws. There’s no law guaranteeing me a job. Why are dealers so special?
- tssva 7y agoCar dealers produce significant local employment and generate significant state and local tax dollars. What is the advantage to the state of favoring an out of state company over them?
- 693471 7y agoI agree they should change their laws. This is where Tesla has an advantage. People are importing the cars in states that don't allow it.
- daryas 7y ago> They don't want engineers testing code out on real people's lives. When Tesla pushes and runs code in the shadow mode, it is run in parallel to the "production" version of the software. The actual behavior of a car, even with the test code in, still relies on decisions made by the "production" version of the software[1]. The purpose of such testing is to compare decisions made by the updated code vs those made by the old version, and use this info for fine-tuning the next gen algorithms. [1] https://youtu.be/Ucp0TTmvqOE?t=6679 https://youtu.be/Ucp0TTmvqOE?t=6679
- BoorishBears 7y agoSo? Tesla is still changing the production mode code on their cars with forced updates and no oversight in addition to running code in "shadow mode" They've used this capability to introduce regressions in the safety of autopilot before. When a stinky old "traditional automaker" wants to update a safety critical component, they spend months developing and testing before slowly rolling out to dealers. They want to change as little as humanly possible to limit their liability if something goes wrong. Now some of you think this attitude is a bad thing, and that safety critical systems should be something you can update on a whim like you update your web server and keep iterating on. But knowing developers like I know developers, being one myself, slow-as-molasses processes for safety critical code is a feature, not a bug for me.