9 ms·
> While it's depressing, what alternative is there? For starters, how about, instead of 60% of the working age population working 40 hours to make ends meet, (
by vkou 7y ago
> While it's depressing, what alternative is there?
For starters, how about, instead of 60% of the working age population working 40 hours to make ends meet, (with the other 40% mooching off them, through welfare, family members supporting eachother, etc), how about 80% of the population working 30 hours a week?
It would create the same amount of wealth, but would distribute it a little differently.
- stickfigure 7y agoThis seems logical and tempting, but there obviously must be some reason societies haven't evolved to do this? My suspicion is that those remaining 40% are significantly less employable, and you can't just swap them in like a fungible good. I suspect also that as technical skills become more valuable - and our education system remains stagnant - that 40% number will grow.
- blueline 7y ago>with the other 40% mooching off them, through welfare, family members supporting eachother i'd implore you to compare regular people welfare spending to corporate welfare spending if this is the view you hold
- vkou 7y agoIt's not a viewpoint I personally hold, but it is a viewpoint ~half the citizenry holds. (Including the folks who, without a shred of irony, personally benefit from this state of affairs.)
- bartimus 7y agoBirthrate US: 1.8, China: 1.62, Japan: 1.44, EU: 1.6 Just allow the situation to resolve itself?
- core-questions 7y agoHow about that 80% working the full 40 hours? Have you looked around? There's no shortage of things that need to be done, fixed, maintained, repaired, overhauled. There's no dearth of resources to learn how to do this. I'd sooner see investment in apprenticeship programs and other efforts to reduce the "mooching" as you called it, than somehow thinking that having me work ten hours less a week is going to provide anything for anyone. How does me doing less work enable that? There's not a fixed supply of "work that can be done", by any stretch.
- vkou 7y agoWhy not 80 hours a week, then? Or 120? It's because I'm not trying to increase the amount of crap we produce. I simply postulate that we could get the same work done, by a better distribution of labour. Whether or not we need to produce more is another question entirely. > than somehow thinking that having me work ten hours less a week is going to provide anything for anyone. Take three people in your position, and you'll create a job for a fourth. And, after all, in our society, job creation is some holy grail that we need to bend over backwards on laws, regulations, and smart business sense for. Instead of compromising on those things, why not compromise on 'normal' working hours, instead?
- perl4ever 7y agoThere's no pool of 90+ million lazy people that could start working. I wasn't even aware this is a myth, but an old Politifact page addresses it, so it must be an old talking point. It says the "working age population" which is everybody over 16, was 243 million in 2013, while the labor force was 156 million, leaving 87 million or about 36%. Of those 87 million, - 9 million were probably in high school - 21 million were in college - 40 million were over 65 - 2+ million were incarcerated - ~20 million were disabled and cannot work (estimated 8% of the population) That adds up to 92 million; obviously some of those older and younger people are in fact working. See: https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2013/jul/30/blog-posting/are-90-million-americans-not-working-or-looking-wo/ https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2013/jul... and https://disabilitycompendium.org/sites/default/files/user-uploads/2017_AnnualReport_2017_FINAL.pdf https://disabilitycompendium.org/sites/default/files/user-up...
- vkou 7y agoThe labour force of non-disabled, non-student[1], non-over-65 is smaller than 156 million. You have to subtract those people (Of which there are a lot of) from that metric (Instead of just the unemployed metric), to get an apples-to-apples comparison of non-disabled, non-studying, non-senior workers/non-workers, which, alas, the article in question does not. You'll also find a lot of the remaining employed people to be significantly under-employed, compared to people doing 40+ hours/week. [1] 40% of undergraduate students, and 76% of graduate students have >30 hours of work/week. [2][3] [2] https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/10/at-universities-more-students-are-working-full-time/433245/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/10/at-univ... [3] So, instead of subtracting 20 million from the unemployed bucket, we need to subtract ~10 million from the employed bucket, and ~10 million from the unemployed bucket. Repeat this process for high school students, persons with disabilities (Some of whom do, in fact, work), and seniors, and you will get to something more resembling a 6:4 ratio.
- perl4ever 7y agoI think you have completely misunderstood. I wasn't talking about "employed" and "unemployed" buckets according to some arbitrary definitions, but the people who are employed at all vs. a naive figure for the labor force. Neither of those numbers are adjustable at whim. The issue is, who are the people that comprise the difference and are they just lazy? And the 20 million disabled people figure is not the total number of disabled people; it's the fraction that don't work multiplied by the fraction who are disabled multiplied by the workforce number. The second reference is where I got the fractions.