5 ms·
Here in Germany you can anonymously call the police (using a pay phone or whatever), but it's not an issue because the police use the door bell and politely tak
by wongarsu 7y ago
Here in Germany you can anonymously call the police (using a pay phone or whatever), but it's not an issue because the police use the door bell and politely take a look instead of busting the door open and storming the place with drawn guns.
I understand police in the US has to adapt to the assumption that everyone has a gun, but even when you suspect a hostage situation what's the problem with politely knocking and waiting if you get a friendly response?
- davidw 7y ago> I understand police in the US has to adapt to the assumption that everyone has a gun That might be a big part of the 'root cause' of this issue.
- Mirioron 7y agoBut many other countries have guns too, eg Switzerland. They don't seem to suffer from the same issue though.
- davidw 7y agoSwitzerland's regulations are far, far stricter than those in the US.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoMaybe they don't have enough criminals discharging those guns?
- microtherion 7y agoThis week an armed man was shot by police in Switzerland. One detail in the newspaper reports that stood out for me was that the investigation of the shooting was immediately transferred to an out of state police department, and that this is apparently standard practice for police use of weapons. In contrast to this, in the US, there appears to be practically no accountability for the police: https://www.forbes.com/sites/nicksibilla/2019/07/18/cop-who-accidentally-shot-10-year-old-when-aiming-for-family-dog-cant-be-sued-federal-court-rules/#53e280723987 https://www.forbes.com/sites/nicksibilla/2019/07/18/cop-who-...
- girvo 7y agoA man was shot dead this week in my city in Australia, after charging at officers with a samurai sword at the conclusion of a siege. The incident was immediately handed to an Ethics investigation; I have major issues with how the QPS and AFP are run, but this isn't one of them.
- donw 7y agoDoubtful. The United States has had a high level of gun ownership for several hundred years. The police response of "respond to anonymous tip by kicking down the door and opening fire" seems to be a mostly post-9/11 thing. I suspect that the root causes are multifold: (1) No-knock warrants became legal in 1995 to prevent the "destruction of evidence" during drug busts. (2) Americans got really paranoid after 9/11, and more tolerant of this sort of police activity. (3) Increasingly harsh prison conditions and unfair sentencing encourages suspects to fight back, rather than comply with law enforcement. (4) We have a number of well-funded and well-trained paramilitary criminal organizations in the United States, thanks largely to the War on Drugs and decades of poorly-thought-out immigration policy.
- whyaduck 7y agoHigh powered semi-automatic long and hand guns with high capacity magazines loaded with hollow-point or armor piercing rounds have not been common in the US for several hundred years.
- donw 7y agoWinchester repearting rifles were popular as of 1870. As they held 16 rounds, could be rapidly fired, and were easily reloaded, there is a strong argument that these were, in fact, the first assault rifles. Modern semi-automatic (double-action) revolvers were commonplace as of 1900. Both of the above fired highly lethal ammunition, with rates of fire and reload not that far from modern semi-automatics, which were themselves common by the 1920s. At which time you could mail-order a machine gun to your front door, which is So Not Even Remotely Close To Legal today. Body armor suitable for police wouldn't become commonplace until the 2000s. Ergo, for 130+ years, the police faced a populace armed with high-capacity assault weapons. And for most of that time, they did so with six-shot .38 revolvers and no bulletproof vests. And only in the past twenty-odd years has kicking in doors with guns blazing become, somehow, necessary. So, no, gun ownership, even of high-powered, high-capacity assault weapons, doesn't correlate at all to police violence.
- mirimir 7y ago
- stcredzero 7y agoeven when you suspect a hostage situation what's the problem with politely knocking and waiting if you get a friendly response? I once pulled over a few blocks from a friend's house, so I could call her and get a few final directions. A man from the house I had parked in front of instantly started talking ominously and yelling at me. I think that guy was a meth head crazed out of his mind. In the back of my mind was the possibility that he'd bring out a shotgun and start blazing away at me. (Yes, my friend didn't live in a great neighborhood.) The police here have to be prepared to deal with people like that. I think friendly looking police androids are going to be quite helpful.
- jonas21 7y agoBecause stuff like this happens (warning: graphic content): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SThUJTApA5I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SThUJTApA5I In this case, they smelled smoke coming from the unit, which is why the fire department broke down the door, and the officers didn't go in expecting to get shot at. It's easy to fault the police when they respond with guns drawn, but at the same time it's often impossible for them to know what they're about to walk into.
- MegaButts 7y ago> It's easy to fault the police when they respond with guns drawn, but at the same time it's often impossible for them to know what they're about to walk into. I'm not saying being a police officer is an easy job, but isn't that what they signed up for? "To protect and serve" (despite being legally challenged and rejected when actually taken to court where an officer refused to engage with shooters) seems to be their mantra, and they talk about putting their lives on the line for the public safety. I fear the problem is the police are more interested in protecting themselves than protecting the public, at least in the United States.
- tlear 7y agoFinding people who are willing to police some of the areas in US(it really is only certain places) without resorting to what they do now is VERY hard. Being a cop in an area like Japan, where you mostly drink tea and stand watch outside of the police box trying to fight boredom’s is one thing. Responding to a call in Baltimore is another. Cops are cops they are not Seal team, they collect paycheck and want to come back home alive and undamaged, expecting anything else from them is unrealistic.
- jplayer01 7y agoPolice are supposed to serve the public, not kill them indiscriminately without cause and without repercussions. If you can't handle getting shot at or any other risks involved, maybe you shouldn't be a cop with a loaded gun and power over others.
- 7y ago
- efitz 7y agoThis. The problem is the existence of so many SWAT teams and public tolerance for SWAT tactics like “no-knock warrants”.