3 ms·
> It would imply that other physical objects can interact with it. We see plenty of evidence of that, with victims of brain damage, or when using drugs. And ou
by MaxBarraclough 7y ago
> It would imply that other physical objects can interact with it. We see plenty of evidence of that, with victims of brain damage, or when using drugs.
And our senses. Another personal favourite example: being bludgeoned into temporary unconsciousness.
> to assume that consciousness is not physical, not only you need a mechanism for it to interact with our physical world (since it can order our bodies to do stuff) but also for the physical world to act on it
I've seen this argument before - a variation of it ties in the physical principle of conservation of energy - but I'm not sure it really holds. It assumes a pretty 'strong' dualistic model.
Even if we take the starting assumption that the mind arises from the physical world, we could say that the mind exists in a mind space, rather than a physical one. I believe David Chalmers' theory of mind takes a similar line (disclaimer: I haven't read it). [0]
If a dualistic model really does propose a suspension of the physical order, well, they've already lost.
Related: I like the way Dan Dennett answers the question of Is the mind physical?: it's physical the way a center of gravity is physical. It's not a particle, or something you can touch, but it arises from the physical world.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Chalmers#Philosophy_of_mind https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Chalmers#Philosophy_of_m...