3 ms·
Before we make a report on how our costs differ from other G20 countries, how about a report on how our costs differ from ourselves 100 years ago. In 1900 it t
by jedberg 7y ago
Before we make a report on how our costs differ from other G20 countries, how about a report on how our costs differ from ourselves 100 years ago.
In 1900 it took four years to lay nine miles of subway in NYC. The second ave tunnel was just a couple miles and under construction for 12 years.
That's just an example. It also took longer to build the new Eastern span of the Bay Bridge than it took to build the whole bridge.
I think we should start by figuring out why these things happen.
- jakewins 7y agoAs I understand it, most of the NYC subway was built by basically just closing of major chunks of streets and excavating them, sticking the subway in and then covering it back up. Compared to boring underground tunnels, you can imagine how much less involved it is to simply dig a hole from above. I'm not sure why they don't do that anymore, though I can imagine it's some combination of where the new routes are (maybe they aren't following the street grid?) and higher impact of year-long closures of streets. The NYP has a good article comparing the methods of construction then and now: https://www.nypl.org/blog/2015/05/04/subway-construction-then-now https://www.nypl.org/blog/2015/05/04/subway-construction-the...
- sagarm 7y agoI think what you are describing it's called cut and cover. Presumably, the idea of inconveniencing motorists for that long "just" for transit is no longer acceptable.
- thehappypm 7y agoIn 1900 the population of New York City was a fraction of its population today and probably more importantly, cars were not widespread as the Model T had not even hit the market yet. It's bizarre to try to compare different eras.
- cestith 7y agoHow many people died building the Brooklyn Bridge? Nobody knows for sure, but it was around 20 to 30. Could you imagine putting that many human lives into a bridge in 1967 or 2019? I don't know death stats at all for the subway. I do know that it was three different systems operating at least partially independently of one another until about 1940 when they came together under city control.