3 ms·
> And people still think crypto isn't dangerous? Part of the problem is that most people who have to use it aren't mathematicians. And even those of us who ha
by Natsu 16y ago
> And people still think crypto isn't dangerous?
Part of the problem is that most people who have to use it aren't mathematicians. And even those of us who have math degrees may not realize every single one of the assumptions or requirements that go into each operation (especially if they change due to new attacks being discovered).
So just knowing that something is dangerous isn't the same as having everything you need to deal with the danger.
I'm surprised that I've never heard of a cryptography wiki somewhere where people try to list all the requirements for using each algorithm or technique securely in simple terms. E.G. a page on each technique or algorithm telling you which numbers must be random, unpredictable, never repeated, etc. Or telling you that if a person has these numbers, they can do X, Y & Z. Or that if you don't verify that this padding is right, people can forge messages. With citations linking to the attacks.
Incidentally, I'm hoping that I'm wrong and there really is such a thing out there, somewhere.
- ZoFreX 16y agoIf there isn't I would be very interested in creating one.
- tptacek 16y agoThat knowledge is spread out over a bunch of people who bill upwards of $500/hr. What's more likely to get built is a wiki that tells people just enough to feel comfortable while writing dangerously brittle crypto code --- to say nothing of the people who will get the recommendations on such a wiki wrong. It's also all downside. No one person has all these details. The primary contributor to such a wiki is inevitably going to miss horrible faults. If you're that guy, why bother?
- Natsu 16y ago> The primary contributor to such a wiki is inevitably going to miss horrible faults. If you're that guy, why bother? Even those $500/hr experts miss horrible faults from what I can see. I mean, you were telling me several months ago on HN how hypervisor secured game consoles were one of the few places where we see high-end security in the consumer space and that we can't just assume that the hackers will always win. But the way I see it, there aren't any magic bullets in the security world. Security is a Red Queen problem. In other words, you have to keep running as hard as you can just to avoid falling behind. If you stop running, someone will eventually catch up to you. > No one person has all these details. That sounds like an incentive to collaborate to me. One might expect that people should want to gather and organize important details like that. The fact that any such an endeavor would inevitably be incomplete and require updates should go without saying. The main problems would be starting with enough information for people to want to contribute to it and having moderators who were good enough to vet contributions for accuracy.
- tptacek 16y agoI agree with your sentiment. I don't think the thing you want to have happen is going to happen. I think what could happen is, for lack of a better term, a half-assed wiki that leads people to code broken e=3 RSA implementations and feel safe doing it.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- NateLawson 16y agoI can guarantee you that Sony did not have a cryptographer implement this signing tool, and they did not get an external $500/hr expert to review it.