3 ms·
Also, should we listen to scientists who are speaking outside of their area of expertise? "I'm a medical doctor, so let me tell you about meteorology." People
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
Also, should we listen to scientists who are speaking outside of their area of expertise? "I'm a medical doctor, so let me tell you about meteorology." People import authority from an area where they have it to use in areas where they don't.
Note well: This does not excuse purging intellectuals, in Turkey or anywhere else. Intellectuals aren't gods, but they aren't vermin, either.
- mhh__ 7y agoWe shouldn't really listen to anyone. Consider them first, sure, but we have to judge on a per-argument basis (David Irving was - as far as I know - a reasonably respected if unorthodox Historian early in his career - now he is not... for obvious reasons). Speaking of which, I recently saw a petition which was sold along the lines of "100s of scientists sign petition condemning 5G", where the vast majority of signatories were either scientists not working in a related field or physicians (Who are not scientists at all).