4 ms·
"People have had enough of experts" - Michael Gove God help us
by mhh__ 7y ago
"People have had enough of experts" - Michael Gove
God help us
- sremani 7y agoNo, God help the now unemployed experts.
- benj111 7y agoTo be fair Gove would say that. It's like BJ is unlikely to say that the people want a competent PM that makes well thought out decisions, and has tamed hair.
- Vinnl 7y agoI really dislike people bringing that quote up, because the full sentence was "People have had enough of experts (...) who are consistently getting it wrong". [1] It's still not necessarily true, but by taking just part of that quote is misrepresenting what he said. Just thought that'd be good to keep in mind next time you might consider digging it up. [1] https://youtu.be/GGgiGtJk7MA?t=71 https://youtu.be/GGgiGtJk7MA?t=71
- duxup 7y agoI wonder if for most folks that it matters. I'll give the speaker the benefit of the doubt just for the sake of argument, but I have my doubt most people voting for folks decrying "experts" or "the establishment" have paid the least bit attention to what experts actually say. The end results seems to be the same sort of "oh man those jokers" argument in favor of ... some folks who seem like bigger jokes / less knowledgeable.
- mhh__ 7y ago"People have had enough of (experts, who are consistently getting it wrong)" Or "People have had enough of experts, (who are consistently getting it wrong)." Regardless, his logic is completely wrong and unfounded but who cares anymore. Who are these experts? No idea. When are they right? Irrelevant. What constitutes being wrong? Doesn't matter. They clearly decided on the nuclear option, i.e. Campaigning with an incredibly vacuous overly-simplistic divisive message that has broken the United Kingdom. Some of the more abrasive untruths would have made Goebbels proud: Particularly the idea that this was them against the "establishment" e.g. Their mates, or the £350 million affair - Not because of the figure but because of the tax income from doing trade with the EU.
- philjohn 7y agoThe full quote is worse ... he's essentially saying to the base that all experts always get it wrong.
- username90 7y agoMany experts are just preachers in different attire. Honestly, should we really listen to scientist who gets labeled experts based non replicable studies? The problem is that all of them gets the same doctors titles but only some of them are doing honest research, and our current society has no good way to deal with this. As a result laymen notice that significant parts of science is pure bullshit, no wonder there are trust issues!
- mhh__ 7y agoReally? The point michael gove was making, if you're not aware, was to try and shun any attempt at "expert"-ing. Within the context of Brexit, the leavers had their own group of "experts" i.e. the ERG but any attempt at economic prediction was clearly shunned on the grounds of it being "Project Fear" despite no specific biases being demonstrated. Because that's the only way, along with blatant lies, to get people believe that leaving the largest trading block - possibly even with no replacement deal with anyone - could possibly be a good thing (At all costs being the current mantra i.e. No Deal) It's not the lack of listening to certain experts that bothers me, it's them clearing playing the card. Gove, and most of the others on the leave side, is very well educated and damn well knows that careful thought ("expert"ism) is important.
- nbabitskiy 7y agoAs it looked for a foreigner, reading almost exclusively mainstream media, when I happened to come by, not only were not pro-staying experts shunned, rather I was stunned for the outcome, because I never heard anything pro-leaving, or any expectation it would end this way. Surely Brexit guys mean it not like Erdogan (i.e. jail time), but more like "if media don't serve as a feedback channel, both voters and elites could as well turn tvs off"? It's very interesting to me, cause I observe experts in expertise everywhere in Russian media, and have been feeling lately, that they'll close themselves in no time, if they proceed that way, or turn into buzzfeeds.
- Chyzwar 7y agoMedia no longer try to represent the truth. Everyone lives in a bubble. People are being fed with carefully targeted bullshit. Your Russian propaganda machine is showing epic fail of the UK despite warnings from experts, highlighting that Putin navigates Russia with the more steady hand than these elected clowns. In the meantime in the US. Fox News is trying to persuade uneducated whites that Trump knows what he is doing. He clearly has no clue and just serves as a distraction.
- alan-crowe 7y agoIn context, Gove was talking about expert political judgment applied to making short term predictions: experts predicting prompt, dire consequences from Brexit. Such predictions have been the subject of academic study. One obtains gold-standard data on the accuracy of short term predictions merely by waiting. The classic book is Expert Political Judgment by Philip E. Tetlock https://press.princeton.edu/titles/11152.html https://press.princeton.edu/titles/11152.html His findings sent shocks waves through the intelligence community. What is going to happen next? Answering that question is raison d'être of the intelligence community. They depend on expert political judgment and Tetlock had found that it was rubbish. This prompted the Good Judgment Project https://www.iarpa.gov/index.php/newsroom/iarpa-in-the-news/2015/439-the-good-judgment-project https://www.iarpa.gov/index.php/newsroom/iarpa-in-the-news/2...
- taurath 7y agoI used to just be repulsed by talk like this, but I've started to find it interesting. Its useful to tease out what is meant here. Experts - when we think of them, we think of professionals with experience, people who've done research on the subjects, and in general just people who are better informed than the public. What I think the people who say things like "enough with the experts", I find it to be entirely within a political/media context - many of whom are paid lobbyists, industry representatives, people with a lot of paper qualifications with their own agenda, etc. AKA, bullshit artists. A call against them is a call against systemic corruption, since they are a primary tool the powerful use to keep the public's consent. The other side of that is a blanket callout against all experts obviously is just anti-intellectualism. This pessimistic worldview is that well since we can't tell which experts are telling the truth, I'm going to go with what I believe, and not listen to anything to the contrary. This is quite easy to criticize - however I think that those that criticize it aren't always taking into account that they do it as well, even if less often or on a less global scale.