8 ms·
To all the naysayers saying, "I told you so!", keep in mind this is a perception problem, not a technology problem. I've been in a self-driving car -- it drove
by jedberg 7y ago
To all the naysayers saying, "I told you so!", keep in mind this is a perception problem, not a technology problem. I've been in a self-driving car -- it drove better than just about any Lyft or Uber I've ever been in. They're already safer than human drivers, with fewer accidents per mile than humans.
And if you eliminate Tesla from the category, since they aren't using LIDAR, you can also point out that a self-driving car has never killed a passenger.
The only reason they have to wait is because they know the public expects perfection. The public doesn't understand statistics. If a self-driver kills a person, it would set the entire industry back decades, even though humans kill people with cars every single day.
People just aren't ready to accept that self-driving cars are safer, even if they aren't perfect.
Edits to reply to comments:
To those saying "It wouldn't work in my climate", that's probably true, but they aren't trying to make it work in your climate. All the self-driving companies are trying to release taxi services that work in cities with good weather.
To those saying "But pedestrians are important too", yes I agree with you. I was trying to point out that the fears of being inside a self-driving car are unfounded, because they are very safe. I still think I'd rather be around a bunch of self-driving cars outside too, but yes, they have killed people outside the car.
And on a side note, this is my most controversial comment ever. I've watched the points on this post as I reply elsewhere go from +3 to -3 and everywhere in-between. I think this right here sums up the public perception issues self driving companies have ahead of them.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoThe industry could help with this if they provided a solution for liability questions. I definitely wouldn’t like to be run over by a self driving car and then having nobody to be held responsible.
- jedberg 7y agoThe owner of the vehicle would be responsible. Just like any other industrial accident. If you get killed by a garbage compactor that runs on a timer, the machine owner has to deal with that.
- navigatesol 7y ago>The owner of the vehicle would be responsible. I think you're misinformed. Why should I be? I've been informed, by you, that it's a better driver than me, and I have no control over the software. Let me say, these are not insurmountable problems, by any means. But the government moves slowly.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoIf I buy a self driving car now, can I buy insurance for it? I doubt it. Maybe the developers of self driving cars should fund such an insurance.
- mrep 7y agoTesla is planning on selling insurance and I'm guessing it is to cover their self driving features [0]. [0]: https://electrek.co/2019/05/02/details-of-teslas-new-insurance-program-start-to-leak/ https://electrek.co/2019/05/02/details-of-teslas-new-insuran...
- smt88 7y agoInsurance would be attached to the vehicle, and the insurer would know whether or not it's self-driving. What liability question do you think there is?
- navigatesol 7y agoAm I buying the insurance, or is the manufacturer/software company?
- jedberg 7y agoYou are because you own the machine.
- FireBeyond 7y agoYour analogy with industrial facilities falls apart. If I buy industrial equipment, it comes with a set of safety recommendations, and requirements. On top of those may also be Labor & Industries, or OSHA. If I fail to follow these, I as the owner am held responsible. How do I ensure that the SDC follows these? How much control do I have over that, short of "don't buy/drive it"? If I do follow these, I may also be hit with an insurance claim, but if I can show that the manufacturer didn't account for something I can probably also make a case against them to recoup some of my loss. Given Tesla, for one egregious example, and their already demonstrated trend of trying to buck any and all responsibility for Autopilot-related collisions, how likely you do you think they are to step up to the plate for "Yes, our car should have determined that there was a pedestrian in the road and stopped, but didn't"? Because I see it more that they will instead hide behind current software clauses, "not responsible for issues, errors, losses, defects".
- richk449 7y ago> I definitely wouldn’t like to be run over by a self driving car and then having nobody to be held responsible. If you upgrade to the special China style self driving package, the car will automatically back over any injuried pedestrians, ensuring that the pedestrian will not have to worry about the problem of who to hold responsible.
- PopePompus 7y agoI think the public will accept a small number of human fatalities, if they arise from things like people crossing the street at night away from an intersection. Most drivers have had close calls like that themselves. What I think will really set self-driving cars back is if they kill someone in a situation where a human driver clearly would not have. If a self-driving car runs over a six year old girl standing in a street because she's wearing an oddly striped dress that the car classifies as a sewer grate - that will be a disaster for the industry.
- jedberg 7y agoAgain, that's because humans are bad at statistics. Even if it has that odd behavior, what about all the accidents a self-driver avoids that humans can't, because it has 360 degree vision and much faster reflexes? You never hear about those, because they they happen all the time and don't make headlines. But clearly they avoid accidents humans don't, because their accident rate if far fewer per mile.
- gooseus 7y agoI'm really curious where you live or work such that your self-driving cars are better than your Uber/Lyft rides and you're observing all these near misses where a real human would have definitely had an accident? Also, I assume you are also considering all the times that humans entirely avoided dangerous situations that self-driving car wouldn't because they were able to anticipate the actions/movements of (possibly several) other actors/objects and even communicate with these other actors to negotiate intersections? Do you have a source for the data that says self-driving cars have fewer accidents per mile? Does that include miles driven on closed tracks or is it just orders of magnitude lower than the miles driven by humans and less statistically significant?
- jedberg 7y agoI live in Cupertino near Mt. View. I see Waymo and Apple self drivers daily as both a driver and pedestrian. And I see the Cruise and Zoox cars every time I go to SF. I'm interested in the space so I observe how they act.
- jsight 7y ago> And if you eliminate Tesla from the category, since they aren't using LIDAR, you can also point out that a self-driving car has never killed a passenger. I think the better reason to eliminate Tesla is that Tesla does not yet claim to have a feature complete self-driving car. > If a self-driver kills a person, it would set the entire industry back decades, even though humans kill people with cars every single day. In that case, we have already been set back decades by the Uber crash.
- jedberg 7y ago> In that case, we have already been set back decades by the Uber crash. I mean a self-driver without a human safety driver. Many people blame the safety driver for that crash, so it saved the perception (even though it was totally the car's fault).
- jsight 7y agoOh, I understand now and that is a completely fair point. The safety driver allowed them to shift blame in a way that will be more difficult without them. I still do not think that such an incident would cost decades, but undoubtedly the cost would be far higher than the Uber case.
- justapassenger 7y agoFeature complete is a BS term for self driving. Being able to, for example, make a turn on red light, while cool, is far far away from being able to make a red turn reliably in all situations. It’s like someone claiming they are feature complete to be a composer, because they finished learning music notes.
- jsight 7y agoFeature complete is a necessary but not sufficient precondition for self-driving. Tesla does not claim to have achieved this precondition.
- 7y ago
- slg 7y ago>They're already safer than human drivers, with fewer accidents per mile than humans. No one in the public has enough data to say this conclusively. >And if you eliminate Tesla from the category, since they aren't using LIDAR, you can also point out that a self-driving car has never killed a passenger. Not killing pedestrians is just as, if not more important than not killing passengers. After all a pedestrian has no choice in interacting with the self-driving car. The passenger at least made an active choice to put their life in the hands of the technology.
- jedberg 7y ago> Not killing pedestrians is just as, if not more important than not killing passengers. I agree, but my point was that risk of death in the vehicle should not even be a concern for anyone, yet many will say (including other in this very thread) "I would never get inside one of these things".
- jakear 7y agoI might say “I would never get inside one of these things” out of concern for pedestrians as well as myself.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>They're already safer than human drivers, with fewer accidents per mile than humans. The average driver-less car mile is a lot easier than the average human driven mile (driverless cars have far fewer miles handling inclement weather and rush hour traffic in non-grid cities than humans do) and the human average is dragged down by a small subset of the population that behaves badly. Driver-less cars are not yet safer than typical drivers and this is before you count all the fender benders the early ones caused by violating social norms by behaving too conservatively in traffic.
- hellllllllooo 7y agoThis. Driverless cars work on the easiest roads and the mistakes they make are ones that humans wouldn't make. They also currently have humans as a failsafe if they do behave strangely. The stats would be very different if we just sent all the self driving cars out tomorrow without safety drivers.
- mwsfc 7y ago>And if you eliminate Tesla from the category, since they aren't using LIDAR, you can also point out that a self-driving car has never killed a passenger. Umm, this is leaving out the very relevant fact that a pedestrian WAS killed near Phoenix by a self driving Uber.
- jedberg 7y agoThat person wasn't a passenger. My point was that people who are afraid to get in a self driver aren't looking at statistics correctly.
- majewsky 7y agoSo you're safe if you're inside a self-driving vehicle at all times? That's reassuring.
- jedberg 7y agoAnd also safer outside of one then outside one driven by a human.
- woofyman 7y ago>And also safer outside of one then outside one driven by a human. This is only a baseless opinion.
- behringer 7y agoThat's true of regular cars too. If you're on a road you're much safer in a car than outside one.
- Tiktaalik 7y agoMaybe the rest of us should ban cars.
- BurningFrog 7y ago
- mtgx 7y agoWhere did you drive it? On country roads? Roads in bad shape? > with fewer accidents per mile than humans This sort of stat is highly misleading. The data is for testing on very safe very good condition roads and/or highways. I highly suggest this source if you'd like a real look at self-driving car progress and not self-patting press releases from the carmakers or PR churns from the media: https://ideas.4brad.com/gmcruise-leaks-show-them-way-way-behind-waymo-its-time-better-metrics-everybody https://ideas.4brad.com/gmcruise-leaks-show-them-way-way-beh... My favorite was one he had on the security of self-driving cars (which is laughably inadequate): http://ideas.4brad.com/disconnected-car-right-security-plan-robocars http://ideas.4brad.com/disconnected-car-right-security-plan-... Brad Templeton is a former EFF chairman and a former adviser to Google's self-driving car project (from before it was called Waymo).
- navigatesol 7y ago>I've been in a self-driving car How many miles did you do? How many corner cases happened? What was the weather like? And based on this experience you conclude that it's better than humans? How many Uber/Lyft accidents have you been in? >The only reason they have to wait is because they know the public expects perfection. The public doesn't understand statistics. It's way more complicated than obtaining perfection. For example, who is liable when a self-driving car crashes?
- r-s 7y agoHas much thought been put into driving in poor road conditions? It seems in the cities self driving cars are pretty much ready, but I wonder about how they will be in bad snow/ice/hail/wind conditions. Humans are pretty bad at these conditions as well. I see a scenario that the self driving cars have X fatality rate which seems very high, while nobody believes the human fatality rate which is even higher.
- SilasX 7y agoI agree that we need to be careful about claiming vindication of our pre-existing beliefs on this issue (or any issue!), but your points aren't helpful either: >I've been in a self-driving car -- it drove better than just about any Lyft or Uber I've ever been in. Th Experience on an individual trip is not significant evidence on this topic. >They're already safer than human drivers, with fewer accidents per mile than humans. Safer in the specific environments they've exposed them too while rounding out the set of conditions, not a general sampling of typical driving. I definitely think they'll eventually get there, but that's a separate question from whether they're there now.
- jedberg 7y ago> Experience on an individual trip is not significant evidence on this topic. I agree, it was just an anecdote to color my commentary. > Safer in the specific environments they've exposed them too while rounding out the set of conditions, not a general sampling of typical driving. And when they are released for general use, they will only be in those specific conditions. Every company pursuing self-driving is looking to launch a taxi service, which would limit the operation to areas where it is safe to do so.
- BrendanD 7y agoNot everyone lives in a temperate climate with little precipitation, nor in modern cities with wide streets laid out on a regular grid. I seriously doubt self-driving cars are ready for some of the weather conditions where I live. Freezing rain. Snow storms. Roads increasingly narrowing in winter from huge snowbanks. They might be ready for your use case, but they ain't ready for mine.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoEvery sane self-driving company is looking to launch as a taxi service for this reason. That way they don't have to operate where they don't do well, and then they can steadily expand their region. Also, I believe that weather is a simpler problem than unpredictable behaviour from other cars, pedestrians, cyclists, delivery vehicles, emergency vehicles, construction, et cetera which occurs everywhere. Of course, it could turn out that both are insurmountable.
- ulfw 7y agoHow on earth would you know "they're already safer than human drivers, with fewer accidents per mile than humans"?
- mbesto 7y ago> They're already safer than human drivers, with fewer accidents per mile than humans. So are trains. What's your point? This is precisely why people say "I told you so!" - the level of non-exceptions required for them to get right is so numerous that this is exactly why it's a technology problem. Semantics here are important. This is classic SV think - it worked for me on my shiny paved road from Palo Alto to Redwood City so it must work for the rest of the world. smh
- jedberg 7y agoTrains don't drive on roads? And keep in mind that all of these self driving cars will only be in those specific pristine conditions. Every company pursuing self-driving is looking to launch a taxi service, which would limit the operation to areas where it is safe to do so.
- mbesto 7y ago> Trains don't drive on roads? And keep in mind that all of these self driving cars will only be in those specific pristine conditions. That's literally the point I'm trying to make. Trains only riding on set rails is synonymous with an autonomous vehicles ability to drive on a set level of pristine road. Semantics are important here - these companies keep saying "we've got AD coming!" and then keeping throwing an asterix next to it ("note - in select markets only"). Can you see why people roll their eyes?
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoAbsolutely, it's such an incredible bubble of self-delusion that becomes quickly evident to people who try to use SV-produced products outside of the prosperous, no-weather climate, highly connected world of the Bay Area. I mean, trivial things like Android Auto looks great, until you lose coverage, or your network gets really crappy -- then it starts to behave in ridiculous ways like: try to send a message, and instead of saying "I can't do that right now because X" or "I'll try later" it spins for a bit and then tells you that contact doesn't exist, etc. If I can't trust SV engineers to deal with common edge cases that result from a place without perfect Internet on a product like _that_ -- why should I trust them to build a car that can handle a climate like mine, a place that has intense and powerful winters that cover all markings on the road, leave black ice patches all over, and have the cars around you using ad-hoc lanes or traffic patterns due to obstruction or severe conditions? SMH indeed.
- simion314 7y ago>with fewer accidents per mile than humans. any actual public data? Because if you mean Tesla then you are wrong because autopilot is not self driving, the driver is supposed to be 100% involved, so from Tesla stats(that are not public) you can only conclude that driver+driver assist could be better then only driver.
- hnaccy 7y ago>They're already safer than human drivers, with fewer accidents per mile than humans. There's no way you have enough good data to make this claim. But yes if we exclude Tesla, ignore non-pax deaths, and vaguely extrapolate from the data released by current players they must be safer!