4 ms·
It is worth pointing out that most anthropologists disagree with Jared Diamond's thesis. Notably, the consensus view is that Greenland, Easter Island, and Mayan
by jcranmer 7y ago
It is worth pointing out that most anthropologists disagree with Jared Diamond's thesis. Notably, the consensus view is that Greenland, Easter Island, and Mayan city states were not driven to collapse primarily because of ecological effects.
Greenland's collapse was largely driven by a shift in northern trade routes and Greenland lost its cash crop export (ivory). Easter Island does not appear to have undergone any sort of collapse until after European contact. And the Mayan collapse is actually completely backwards from how it should progress if climate was the major factor: there was a shift in power from the more fertile highlands region to what was previously the relatively backwards arid Yucatan region (Cichen Itza, in the northern Yucatan, didn't start thriving until after the southern regions were in dramatic collapse).