3 ms·
As the chaos monkey dials up speculating on food becomes more profitable too, mitigating at least some of the risk. If I expect harvests to fail on a significan
by wongarsu 7y ago
As the chaos monkey dials up speculating on food becomes more profitable too, mitigating at least some of the risk. If I expect harvests to fail on a significant scale, buying up huge warehouses of grain (or other storable food) and selling it when prices soar is a great investment strategy.
As climate change makes disruptions more frequent I wouldn't be surprised if some investment fonds started launching their own cubesats to feed their prediction models to spot such opportunities before everyone else.
- krastanov 7y agoRelying on the free market and speculators to fix this problem sounds both realistic and incredibly dystopian to me. Sure, the market is efficient, but that does not mean it works for everyone. An imaginary efficient benevolent government would use the same prediction models to provision for extra food for the downtrodden instead of trying to exploit the demand they will create for profit. The free market solution really hurts the people that do not have the disposable income to "invest" in the market.
- wongarsu 7y agoThis is something a government should absolutely do, it's basically disaster prevention. However I don't think democracies are well equipped to handle such tasks in general: decisions are made by people who are either part of a body of hundreds of people or frequently have term limits that prevent them from seeing the consequences of decisions on disaster prevention. This creates a lack of consequences and personal responsibility. In comparison a dictator-for-life is easy to blame for all problems, he just may not care. Ideally we would find a better form of government. I don't have any particularly good ideas though.
- jacobush 7y agoThe other forms of government yet invented and tried, seem to be doing even worse at disaster prevention.
- dalbasal 7y agoIn theory... In practice, if you think harvests will fail, futures contracts make the whole warehousing thing moot. Arbitrage and clever tradable (or even non tradable) contracts (eg contract for difference) give you an opportunity to speculate on the price of grain without you (or anyone) actually holding any wheat. In practice, you just bet someone else that the price will go up, and they pay you the difference if you're right. No wheat has to be stored. There is very little relationship between derivative markets and the quantity of commodities siloed. If you want an emergency "buffer stock," you need to buy and hold actual commodities.
- mrfredward 7y agoIf enough people bet on wheat prices to rise, futures contracts get expensive compared to the current price of wheat. This opens the opportunity for someone to rent a warehouse, fill it with wheat, and then take the opposite side of the futures contract (i.e. lock in a high future selling price for your wheat), yielding a guaranteed profit. So if futures prices ever show a price increase greater than the cost of storage, people will start filling warehouses with wheat everywhere. It's just that normally commodities don't increase in price at a rate that exceeds the cost of storage.
- dalbasal 7y agoThe warehouse is a theoretical construct, in practice. Whatever the market does and whatever investors want their position to be (long, short..), they can take that position without any physical wheat actually entering or leaving a silo.
- dragontamer 7y agoBut the arbitrage is settled physically. When oil-storage was filling up, oil-futures drop in response (because the market knows that physical space was running out). That's the thing about the world: people exist in it, and can change the world. Increasing the number of warehouses (to make more money) is a good strategy, and the futures contracts provide a means for allocating these investments more efficiently.