4 ms·
I like how the headlines explicitly states humans. For yet another study in ... mice. There are other options like dogs and pigs which are much better models
by olliej 7y ago
I like how the headlines explicitly states humans.
For yet another study in ... mice.
There are other options like dogs and pigs which are much better models for human biology, so if you really want to make a claim about subtle effects of human genetics you need to be as close to a human model as possible.
This is entirely ignoring the someone generous leap they make that one single gene mutation is responsible for an increased rate of heart disease. It also doesn’t touch on what the benefits for that gene were (to spread through the gene pool completely it must have some benefit that outweighs the cost)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rjzotti 7y agoFurther down in the study it says that removing the gene likely occurred because it made humans more resistant to malaria, and somehow it also enhanced the ability to run long distances.
- AlexCoventry 7y agoIf this withstands scrutiny a chimpanzee study can't be far off, though.
- buntsai 7y agoNah. Primate studies are too expensive, impractical and ethically difficult to justify. Think about the number of subjects you would need for statistical significance ...
- pier25 7y agoAt this point this is only a hypothesis. This is clear when they say "may help explain", "may have resulted", and "believe".
- segfaultbuserr 7y ago#JustSayInMice! https://twitter.com/justsaysinmice https://twitter.com/justsaysinmice * Hyped-up science is a problem. One clever Twitter account is pushing back. https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/6/15/18679138/nutrition-health-science-mice-news https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/6/15/18679138/nutrit... Just for some background for those who weren't aware what is the OP all about. But to be fair, I think this article is actually well-written and doesn't contain sensationalized framing.
- fifnir 7y agoOh another couch biologist,there's one in every thread.. thanks for all the observations, we really hadn't thought of any of that, you single-handedly salvaged modern biological research !!
- dang 7y agoHey, could you please not break the site guidelines like this? Internet forums are certainly full of comments that don't necessarily know about things. If you know more, the thing to do is to share some of what you know so we all can learn—not degrade the quality of the site even further. If you'd take the spirit of this site more to heart, we'd appreciate it. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- fifnir 7y agoFair enough. But this happens in every biologically relevant discussion.. Every time results are reported on mice, someone will criticize that it wasn't done on humans, as if biologists are complete ignoramuses and not intimately familiar with the strengths and limitations of their own science. If an engineer presented a model of a bridge and someone jumped in to say "buh, but you didn't ACTUALLY BUILD the bridge so this is worthless", people would rightly tell him off, wouldn't they? Why is this low-effort criticism of biology allowed ?
- dang 7y agoIt's allowed in the sense that people are allowed to be wrong and/or ignorant because that's what most of us are on most topics. We can't stop that any more than King Canute could stop the waves. The important question is, what's the best way to handle it if we want to have an internet forum that doesn't suck? Experience teaches that the answer is: the patient supply of correct information by people who do know about a topic. I don't mean to minimize how infuriating it is to be surrounded by a flood of ignorance and wrongness. But that's the situation you're in if you're knowledgeable. Railing against it only makes things worse. Being able to contain the annoyance, so that it doesn't drive your communication, is a hard prereq for doing something good about it.