19 ms·
I can’t imagine a train leaving every 10 minutes could ever be cost effective. There just aren’t that many people who want to do that trip (8 hours?) when you
by refurb 7y ago
I can’t imagine a train leaving every 10 minutes could ever be cost effective. There just aren’t that many people who want to do that trip (8 hours?) when you could do it in 2 hours by plane.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bobthepanda 7y agoAs the crow flies, Chicago to New York is similar to Beijing to Shanghai, which is a long-ish high-speed-rail journey of 4.5 hours. If you have to fight lots of traffic to get to the airport that's not too bad. Probably not enough to drive demand for every ten minutes. The real value of such a network would be an intermediate trip. If Cleveland or Pittsburgh are both two hours away from New York and Chicago and the trip is downtown to downtown, demand for air travel from these mid-size cities to the larger ones would pretty much dry up save for connecting flights. And the strength of rail is that you could have some trains stop multiple times within a metropolitan area, so that you don't have to drive to a centrally located transportation hub the way you have to do with an airport. And if you add rail stops to the airport you don't even need the connecting flights anymore. You probably wouldn't get the high-speed rail to Bradford OH directly though. The closest you'd get is Dayton OH, but thankfully that's a more doable 30+ mile Lyft ride.
- rayiner 7y agoLGA to ORD is 3 million passengers per year. Beijing to Shanghai is 7 million by air, plus 180 million by train (including intermediate stops). Total US air travel between all destinations is only 750 million per year. The ability of the Chinese to recoup their capital investment through ridership is massive compared to what you could expect in the US.
- bobthepanda 7y agoIt's worth noting that at least some of that 180 million is travel induced by the availability of the train in the first place. There are plenty of city pairs that people don't travel between because * plane travel is too much of a hassle for such a short trip, and usually expensive * roads (bus & car) are too congested
- dredmorbius 7y agoRail passengers to Denver, CO, in 1869, numbered nil. Construction of the 100 mile Denver Pacific spur line to the transcontinental railroad route in Cheyenne not only increased that somewhat, but saw Denver's population grow from 4,700 th over 35,000 within ten years. Induced demand is a thing.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoYou can only induce as much travel demand as there are people to potentially travel. No amount of induced demand will let US travel infrastructure transport the number of people that Chinese travel infrastructure does.
- dredmorbius 7y agothe number of people that Chinese travel infrastructure does ... and that's not my argument. But lowered real costs -- not merely price, but time, convenience, flexibility, time-sharing (work/eat/sleep in transit), predictability, safety, baggage allownce, efficiency gains, and more -- should increase effective utility and utilisation. The biggest pitfalls of rail have been right-of-way acquisition in mature economic regimes (high induced land values, themselves a result in large part of improved transport, impede further transport development), transfers and mode-transitions (especially rail-to-local endpoint travel), and technological lock-in and stagnation. China has the benefits of late adoption, relatively low economic development, and critically, a regime of weak real (land) property rights. All enable it to adopt recent and advanced technologies, and to plan and acquire rights of way at low cost. Even in parts of the United States where China's other, and more usually noted advantage, exceedingly high population density, is more closely matched, the US is hugely hampered by built rail infrastructure and extant technologies, high land values, and an increasingly oppressive private land ownership tradition.
- rayiner 7y ago> The biggest pitfalls of rail have been right-of-way acquisition in mature economic regimes (high induced land values, themselves a result in large part of improved transport, impede further transport development), transfers and mode-transitions (especially rail-to-local endpoint travel), and technological lock-in and stagnation. Rail is more expensive than roads in the US even where the right of way already exists. The Silver Line was built along an existing right of way and still cost $250 million per mile. (There is tons of excess freeway median in the US that could cost rail.) The problem is actually the high cost of skilled labor in the US. I don’t suppose you’d consider US labor rights to be “oppressive.”
- gok 7y agoNote that even with that exceptional HSR, most fly between Beijing and Shanghai. And that's with the ridiculous Chinese rules that prevent you from using your phone during all flights. And Chicago/New York would be more like 5.5 hours.
- p2t2p 7y agoIt is not two hours. The flight time from my home town to Moscow is 50 minutes. Whole trip is about 6 hours. Get to the airport, takes about 1 hour (drive 60k or 40 miles). If you don’t have a car - even longer. You arrive in advance, security, luggage check in then boarding, then runway. It’s been around 3 hours so far. Now you fly for 50 to 70 minutes and it doesn’t include the plane driving through airport after landing. Get off, grab you luggage - another 40 minutes easily. 15 if you’re lucky. Now you need to get to the city, so it is 2 hours by car through Moscow traffic or 1 hour using “aero express” train. The thing is, once you get off this “aero express” train, chances are it is still about one hour trip on subway to the office/apartment. I used to fly like that, I was leaving my parents apartment at about 4-30am to arrive by 10/11am. Compare it to train - it takes 13 hours but it leaves from the city centre, no security check in’s no nothing, you take 30 minutes to arrive there. It leaves at 6-30pm, you have supper and sleep. 7-30am BOOM you’re in the center of Moscow right next to subway station. Brush you’re teeth during approach, have your breakfast and off you pop. It feels muuuuch better on the train. Air travel overhead is just too big - 5 hours or something for hour of the flight time. With train you have about two hours of overhead. The only thing it is almost twice as expensive compared to air travel
- hinkley 7y agoFrom an article last year about new train prototypes in Tokyo: > Chris Jackson, the editor-in-chief of Railway Gazette International, based in London, said JR East wanted to raise their maximum train speed to 224 miles per hour to achieve a journey time between Tokyo to Sapporo that rivals flying. > Currently, the world’s fastest trains in regular service run between Beijing and Shanghai, in China, at speeds up to 217 miles an hour, he said. Sapporo is over 500 miles from Tokyo, and the trains might be faster than a 600mph plane ride...
- mikekchar 7y agoBut you can only get to Hakodate... The shinkansen tracks to Sapporo aren't finished yet (unless I've missed something). It takes nearly as long to go from Hakodate to Sapporo as it does to go from Tokyo to Hakodate :-) I wonder if they are really serious about that...
- mlang23 7y agoNo, that is not realistic. With all the fucked up security nonsense and checkin times, and the time you need to get to the airport(s), its likely more like 5 or 6 hours vs 8. And considering the environmental footprint of a flight, I would happily take the train route, thank you.
- whywhywhywhy 7y ago> when you could do it in 2 hours by plane a 2 hour flight isn't 2 hours, there is also the 1-2 hours getting into the plane itself and the 1-2 hours getting off it and this is before we get into having to drive out to the deep outskirts of the city to even begin that process.