4 ms·
Stuff like this makes me glad to live in NYC, but it does kind of depress me that it has to come to an explicit law, and moreover even more annoyed that it was
by tombert 7y ago
Stuff like this makes me glad to live in NYC, but it does kind of depress me that it has to come to an explicit law, and moreover even more annoyed that it was ever legal to do that in the first place.
- save_ferris 7y agoTrying to beat/get ahead of regulation is a fairly significant aspect of many businesses. So many startups exist that either outright break laws (Uber, Airbnb) or try to find gray areas that are difficult to enforce from a regulatory standpoint. We don't like to think of businesses as behaving this way, and certainly many don't, but this is feature of capitalism, not a bug.
- frutiger 7y agoYou’re surprised it needs a law but wasn’t illegal already? How could it be illegal without a law?
- tombert 7y agoI said "explicit" law, since I would have hoped it was covered under previous law. Clearly I didn't word this correctly, so I apologize for any confusion.
- raverbashing 7y agoIt might have been as it's an invasion of privacy. Barring that, Civil Law 101
- josephorjoe 7y agoHonestly without laws and regulations capitalist organizations would eventually just straight out rob and/or blackmail people and claim that doing anything less would be unfair to their shareholders. I hate bad and onerous regulations as much as the next person, but I'm always amazed by how ingrained the `regulations == bad` sentiment has become in society. Regulations are the rules that make systems stable. Without them we'd just cycle between abuse and violent revolution...
- wccrawford 7y agoThey're also the rope that strangles innovation and progress. There's a balance to be struck here, and we're always working on finding it. The US seems to tend to come down on the side of "legal until proven it shouldn't be" and the EU seems to lean a little more towards "prevent bad things" than the US. Personally, I prefer the US version, and I'm glad I live in the US.
- kerkeslager 7y ago> They're also the rope that strangles innovation and progress. I'd love to understand why you think allowing people to do bad things is necessary for innovation and progress.
- haasteagle 7y agoI think you're being uncharitable here. He was clearly referring to the effect regulations generally have (reduced innovation). This is generally accepted by most people.
- wccrawford 7y agoBecause in order to prevent all bad things, you need to prevent many good things, too. Those good things are necessary for innovation and progress.
- kerkeslager 7y ago> Because in order to prevent all bad things, you need to prevent many good things, too. That's nonsense. Please explain, for example, how you think making it illegal to sell people's telco data in the 80s when we already knew this was happening would have prevented some good thing. Preventing selling data would have only prevented a few rich sociopaths from getting a bit richer. They knew it was wrong, we knew it was wrong, the only reason it happened (and is still happening) was because people like you refuse to ever allow regulation, and people will likely prevent any regulation that does happen from having any teeth or a broad enough scope, so it will just keep happening. The "innovation" your ideology is incentivizing is just finding new loopholes to crawl through and screw people over. I get it, the concept that regulation might have side effects makes sense if you talk about it only in general terms. But whenever I find myself arguing against this ideology, it's in a specific situation where your ideology is just being used to let sociopaths profit off of amoral behavior. Your ideology makes sense in theory, but over and over again it simply doesn't play out in practice.
- cabaalis 7y agoIANAL but what could be the US-equivalent of a GDPR? A conglomeration of local laws? Federal? Can our government pass a sweeping regulation like GDPR without being unconstitutional? (Meaning, can it be argued that businesses/individuals have a right to enter into the kinds of contracts they create to sell personal data?)
- vonmoltke 7y ago> Can our government pass a sweeping regulation like GDPR without being unconstitutional? Depends on how much will and political support there is for contorting the Commerce Clause to cover it.
- lidHanteyk 7y agoSuch legislation is coming to California next year: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Consumer_Privacy_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Consumer_Privacy_Ac...
- driverdan 7y ago> Stuff like this makes me glad to live in NYC This is the same place that has E-ZPass trackers and automated license plate readers all over the city tracking vehicle movement, that has an untold number of CCTV cameras, and corrupt cops that get away with murder. I'm not saying we shouldn't commend them for this, just that there are many other major related issues that should be equally concerning.