4 ms·
It depends on how success is measured. Let's suppose that the UK repair operation is manage separately. Let's call that exec Joe. And suppose further that the
by wpietri 7y ago
It depends on how success is measured.
Let's suppose that the UK repair operation is manage separately. Let's call that exec Joe. And suppose further that the person in charge measured by metrics like "doesn't spend any more on repairs per sale than the US operation does", implying that spending less is better.
Joe making a rule something like "refuse any warranty repairs if a moisture sensor trips, even if the damage is unrelated" is a pretty easy way to keep repairs down. Some people may sue, sure, but probably not many.
And let's assume further, as is common, that Apple's lawyers are all on staff and under their General Counsel. That means they're a fixed cost, and not directly on the budget of the repair operation. That is not one of the metrics Joe is evaluated by. Maybe they won't need to add any new lawyers to handle the extra load; maybe they will. Further, any relationship between repair rules and legal costs will be hard to spot, given that it's delayed by time and filtered through many people.
So at worst, Joe might down the road have to face some sort of complicated analysis from the head of legal complaining about increased costs. But he can point to repair cost savings, so it'll be difficult to say whether on net he's making or costing Apple money.
I would guess the bigger risk for Joe is not legal expenses but the PR problem from writeups like this or an eventual decline in something like a Net Promoter Score metric as more people feel put off by Apple. Those, however, are also pretty long feedback loops. So Joe gets an immediate reduction in repair costs versus the possibility of a problem a year or three down the road. Many ambitious execs are perfectly fine with that; they're hoping to be in a new position anyway in a couple of years, so it may be the next guy's problem.
And really, Joe may not have a problem at all; as this article makes clear, having to sue the company wasn't enough to keep the guy from buying another Apple laptop. That's not a great incentive for anybody to change behavior.
- Gravityloss 7y agoWell that's not a good way to run a company - it's basically designed to be customer hostile.
- WrtCdEvrydy 7y agoCapitalism!
- Latty 7y agoTell that to ISPs and, from what I hear, cable companies in the US—I’m sure there are other examples too. “Customer hostile” seems to be a perfectly “good” way to run a business if you goal is raw profit. Doubly so in the US with essentially non-existent consumer protection law.
- Gravityloss 7y agoThat's an incentive for the customer to select another company.
- wpietri 7y agoOnly if they can. In the US, people generally have at most a couple of ISP choices, and the general pattern of duopolies is to offer basically the same thing with minor differentiators (e.g., one will be 10% cheaper and 10% worse). Many airline routes are minimally competitive. This is not getting better with ecosystem lock-in effects. As TFA mentions, this guy had such a bad experience that he sued Apple, and he still bought another laptop from them. That's because Apple intentionally killed off the companies that built MacOS compatible hardware, and never allowed anybody else to build IOS phones or tablets.
- Latty 7y agoSure, in a simple textbook supply-and-demand model, but we all know that in the real world that isn't how it works. Most people have very limited choices, and all those choices engage in essentially the same user-hostile practices anyway. The only “choice” is to leave it altogether, which is visibly happening now there is an alternative to cable TV, but not having an internet connection isn't an option for most people.
- wpietri 7y agoAgain, it depends on your metric for "good". It's clearly good for Joe, and in the semi-feudal power structure of the modern corporation, that's sufficient. It's also often a profitable way to run a company. Take a look at the Net Promoter Score for the Fortune 500: https://customer.guru/net-promoter-score/fortune-500 https://customer.guru/net-promoter-score/fortune-500 The number in theory ranges from 100 (everybody would enthusiastically promote to friends) to -100 (the opposite). Some well-liked companies include Apple at 47, Starbucks at 77, and Costco at 79. In contrast, Comcast is -3, Time Warner is -5, United is -8. There are definitely some places loved by customers in the Fortune 500, but as you look down the list it's far from universal. Comcast's profit was something like $11 billion last year. Are they customer hostile? Notoriously. Do they care? Not really!
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoNot just a fixed cost for staff lawyers - a fixed low cost. Routine cases like these will be managed with boilerplate briefs and filings, standard arguments, and form letters. Claims may be checked very briefly to make sure there's nothing unusual or legally dangerous about them. If there isn't, the process will likely be handled by standard templated paperwork, and might as well be automated.
- dkarl 7y agoThis is why it's such bullshit to have metrics and incentives "aligned" in an organization. Somebody's boss needs to call bullshit and say, "You gamed this metric in a bad way and harmed the company," but that would be counter to their own incentives, so everybody joins in on the game.
- thenaturalist 7y agoFunnily I happen to work in the area of metrics and KPIs and for anyone reading this, the scenario you describe is one of reaaaally bad metrics/ KPIs. Nominal numbers = bad KPI Ratios = good KPI "Repair spend / (lost) court filings" is a way better ratio than plain "Repair spend".
- wpietri 7y agoJust to be clear, I was suggesting that the metric was "repair spend / sales volume". Also a bad metric, of course. But yes, it's perfectly possible that a company would use a bad nominal metric like "repair spend". It need not even be explicit. Typical budgeting processes encourage that sort of thing because it's seen as good to be under budget and bad to be over it.