9 ms·
Maybe it's because I live in Silicon Valley, but my repair experience with Apple has been quite different. I took my six year old laptop in for a recall on the
by jedberg 7y ago
Maybe it's because I live in Silicon Valley, but my repair experience with Apple has been quite different. I took my six year old laptop in for a recall on the video card, which required a logic board replacement. They did that at no charge. In the process, they broke the power unit, so they replaced that and my six year old battery, both at no charge. They also replaced the top case at no charge while doing the second repair because they said they damaged it during repair. I never even saw the damage or had to complain.
It took three weeks, but in the end I basically had a new laptop, except the screen.
- reustle 7y ago3 weeks without my income source is rough
- aardvark291 7y agoIf it's that vital, you should have a spare, or perhaps rent or borrow one.
- nostalgk 7y agoTo be fair, it is a bit tougher when Macs are so expensive. When my PC breaks, I have 4 other options I can count off the top of my head. When my Mac breaks, I only can afford to have one spare, and even that is more of a matter of lucky circumstance.
- vinceguidry 7y agoBefore I could afford MacBooks, I bought old ThinkPads off Craigslist and put Ubuntu on them. I could find ways to do most things. Nowadays it's a lot easier.
- StavrosK 7y agoHell, a Raspberry Pi will do in a pinch... I mostly just need a terminal, I can spin up a beefy Hetzner server to work on for a few days for $1.
- jplayer01 7y agoI think this is one of the benefits of being a programmer. Our tools and materials can be easily stored in an online-accessible way, such that a git clone can recreate your entire environment and all the code you were working on. I don't know if any non-programmers who primarily rely on their laptops do (or can do) the same, much less people who work with music or videos or photos, who often have (hundreds of) gigabytes they need to work on with no real version control, and require much more effort and financial investment to be able to backup, duplicate and restore.
- StavrosK 7y agoYeah, it's interesting how, when your job is making things, you manage to make things to make making other things easier, so your ability improves exponentially. Musicians make music, so they have to rely on other people making tools for them, whereas toolmakers can just make better tools for themselves. That is, if you can avoid reinventing the wheel, which we aren't great at.
- avgDev 7y agoOr you could just get a dell and get next day in home service :|
- ihuman 7y ago[Deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- penagwin 7y agoSerious question: Have the XPS QC issues been addressed? This isn't any kind of attack on them, it's just that when I was searching for a laptop they seemed to be having some issues and even the warranty replacements had issues. Which really sucks because the XPS lineup do look enticing for me.
- avgDev 7y agoI have 2017 model XPS. I honestly don't have any issues. I would buy one at costco and see for yourself, you would have 3 months to return.
- _Understated_ 7y agoI talk to a lot of small business people and a question I usually ask when they bring up the subject of new laptops and such is "how long can you be without your laptop if if breaks?" Usually the answer is that they can't be without it at all. So I never recommend Apple laptops for business owners unless they have a spare... a spare "anything" will possibly suffice especially if everything they do is online. I only tend to buy Dell business laptops: great build quality and a 3-year next business day onsite warranty are worth every penny imo: Not as flashy and fancy as the XPS stuff but they have/had quality issues (as the commenter below mentioned).
- conwaytwitty 7y ago
- jedberg 7y agoAgreed. Luckily I had a spare.
- forgivemyQs 7y agoHow much did the computer cost at purchase
- jedberg 7y ago$MAX. It was the top of line fully maxed Macbook Pro at the time of purchase. So maybe that too had something to do with it.
- pier25 7y agoYeah, it's because you live in SV. Apple is not so great in other parts of the world.
- LeonM 7y ago> Maybe it's because I live in Silicon Valley That may be the reason. I live in the Netherlands and I have had consistent terrible experience with Apple store repair service. > It took three weeks, but in the end I basically had a new laptop, except the screen. For professional use, that is just unacceptable. If you rely on your computer for income, you can't wait that long. That is the reason why any Apple product will never be 'pro'. Regardless of how nice the hardware is, if it breaks I need a repair or replacement device immediately. IFAIK Apple does not offer such service (unless you have >50 devices). Other brands (HP, Dell, Lenovo) offer on-site same day repair service. They send someone to your location and if they can't fix it on site, they'll give you a replacement/loaner. For me, that service is well worth the cost. If only Apple would offer that.
- atomi 7y agoThe on-site same day repair I've gotten from Dell has been a godsend. I can't even imagine being out for 3 weeks.
- n_u_l_l 7y agoWhich store? I had multiple bad experiences with the Apple Store in The Hague but the experience with the Apple Store in Amsterdam was great.
- LeonM 7y agoThe Hague. Asked them to replace the battery on my MBP (out of warranty), got it back with non-functioning USB ports. Had to return it 3 times, every time I got it back I tested the USB ports inside the store only to demonstrate that the problem still wasn't fixed. Eventually they even tried to convince me that this was a software bug. After 6 weeks without working USB ports I got really angry and they finally agreed to replace the broken motherboard. When I got it back my laptop worked but it had a different keyboard installed (Dutch, instead of US intl). I complained about that and they told me that I was lying (even though a had the purchase receipt with the US keyboard option). After that I gave up and bought a Lenovo, haven't looked back since. The service in Amsterdam may be better, but traveling to the city center of Amsterdam twice just to get my laptop repaired is not acceptable.
- Brajeshwar 7y agoThat is nice. I live in India and we don't even have an Apple Store. One of their Reseller replaced pretty much everything with my 2nd Gen Macbook (Apple care expired) because the keyboard had the "quality issue".
- burlesona 7y agoJust FWIW re: 3 week repair. 3 weeks sounds rough to me. I once had a screen issue, I took the laptop in and they replaced the screen with no questions asked and at no charge. However it took a week and I couldn’t go a week without my computer. The Apple store rep pointed me at their return policy on laptops, specifically no questions asked 30-day returns, and told me that while he couldn’t rent me a computer that I could buy a backup and get 100% refund if I brought it back in 30 days. So that’s what I did: “purchased” an alternate with a credit card, used it for 8 days, brought it back when my laptop was fixed, and they refunded the charge. I was never out any money. Psychologically, I’d like it better if they offered that more readily and with a lower deposit to put down - so I’m not trying to argue that this policy is just great and has no issues. But, if you ever find yourself in that situation and can’t go without a computer, maybe that option will help you get by.
- dingo_bat 7y agoOnly apple users can justify a 3 week motherboard replacement! It's a 10 minute operation on a well designed laptop.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoThey did the same with my phone and gave me a loaner in the meantime.
- rhacker 7y agoI had a similar experience, except it was Portland OR - came in because a key was stuck, the tech said he saw some smudging on my screen and asked if they should just go ahead and replace that too since it's covered - the "bill" which was all free to me was something like $800. Turned around in a day. I wonder if these out of country operations are being denied the cash required to the repairs or if they just have problems getting parts so they end up being much more stingy about replacement?
- danpalmer 7y agoI live in the UK and 10 years ago would have had similar experiences to this, but in the last few years my experience has been much closer to that of the author on Reddit. Our Apple Stores generally have long wait times and do as much as they can to get out of repairs, all the while being incredibly patronising and unsympathetic to personal or business concerns. It's overall pretty terrible service – I've seen far better from Dell.
- christophilus 7y agoI live in the middle of nowhere South Carolina, and have had only fantastic experiences with our local Apple stores. It sounds like maybe they have a consistency problem across stores?
- EpicEng 7y ago>I took my six year old laptop in for a recall on the video card, which required a logic board replacement. They did that at no charge Well sure, it was a recall. >In the process, they broke the power unit, so they replaced that and my six year old battery, both at no charge. They also replaced the top case at no charge while doing the second repair because they said they damaged it during repair. >It took three weeks... So... they busted up your machine while performing the repair, extending the time to 3 WEEKS. not sure how this is an endorsement of Apple's repair services.
- gambiting 7y agoI guess it's just a gamble. I took mine in to an Apple Store in Newcastle UK with a minor problem - the case was creaking when pressed down. The staff were super friendly, they examined the laptop and decided the the entire bottom case and the battery has to be replaced - under warranty. I had to wait 3 days for the new case to arrive, brought my laptop in, it was ready the next day. Absolutely no issues and miles and miles above any service I have ever experienced from other brands.
- egorfine 7y ago> Maybe it's because I live in Silicon Valley, but my repair experience with Apple has been quite different. This is absolutely the case. I've been in Apple services both in US and in many other countries in Europe and Eastern Europe. The farther from US, the worse.
- smacktoward 7y agoService will always be great in the location where the executives who can fire the service people live.
- perfopt 7y agoWait, what kind of service engineers do they have if they damaged so many things as they were fixing your laptop?
- rasz 7y agolook up CSAT Solutions https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ATxsy9otVzs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ATxsy9otVzs
- rasz 7y ago>I took my six year old laptop in for a recall on the video card, which required a logic board replacement. They did that at no charge. They replaced your defective design motherboard(whether it was Nvidia GPU or C9560) with ... another defective design motherboard, plus some shoe rubber to prop badly soldered parts(dead serious, Apple refurb outfit glues rubber to bga chips in order to wedge them against outer case because its easier/faster/cheaper than replacing bad solder). >in the end I basically had a new laptop build using same factory defective parts, with life expectancy of at most couple years IF they actually replaced GPU with new one, there were plenty cases of Apple refurb motherboard dying almost instantly leading even Apple technicians to suspect foul play http://advancedreworks.com/forum/archive/index.php/t-2692.html http://advancedreworks.com/forum/archive/index.php/t-2692.ht...