3 ms·
* Github being closed-source doesn't really matter. Restrictive software licensing hurts the user of the software which in this case is Github Inc. and only Git
by Spivak 7y ago
* Github being closed-source doesn't really matter. Restrictive software licensing hurts the user of the software which in this case is Github Inc. and only Github Inc. As long as the protocol is open (which it is) whether hosted services that speak that protocol are open or closed source is immaterial. [1]
* Git isn't distributed. It's decentralized -- big difference. Distributed means there (usually) aren't any single points of failure. Decentralized means these are many single points of failure but failures are localized. Combine that with the reality that in most markets a "best option for most people" emerges and we get bigger and bigger points of failure.
* Microsoft has been trying to get into the socal networking game for a while now and found their match made in heaven with one based on software. Time will tell if the recent Microsoft will be a good steward -- so far it's been pretty good.
* Definitely a victory. The dominant VCS is open. More people than ever are contributing to OSS. It's easier than ever to share code.
[1] Github's on-prem offering is a completely different story and is very much a problem that it isn't OSS.