4 ms·
The rule is "Don't directly or indirectly tell people to click on your ads." The reason for this is that loyal audiences will, if you tell them to click on ads
by patio11 16y ago
The rule is "Don't directly or indirectly tell people to click on your ads." The reason for this is that loyal audiences will, if you tell them to click on ads, click on ads to support you. This is exactly what happened. The CTR goes through the roof, the advertisers get billed lots of money, and no commerce takes place.
- dhimes 16y agoDid you read the Mea Culpa? Unless Mr. Winter is lying, Zak's question still stands. It seems like there is a potential for injustice when the reviews are held in secret like they were. All Google put forth was that there was a risk of generating invalid [click] activity. As one who, like you, pays for that invalid activity I am glad to see Google do what they can to stem it. But it gets very serious in my mind when they can also take the cash from the account. They should be required to show explicitly their justification. If that means that their business has to change because their algorithms are exposed, so be it. What they are doing does not seem to be a fair business practice to me, and I worry about the precedent they are being allowed to set.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- epoxyhockey 16y agoIt is obvious to you and me that a 6% CTR is supernaturally high, at least in my experience. If Google's algorithms are so great as to detect AdSense "cheaters," why don't they just throttle down the CPC for "cheaters" down to 1 cent (or less)? I think we're basically discovering that Google is defending their immature AdSense algorithms by banning users rather than adapting to different behaviors.
- il 16y agoThey actually have been doing this for some time with Smart Pricing. It wasn't working too well.
- nikster 16y agoIt's not that simple. Real cheaters will react, and devise counter strategies to whatever you are tying to do. I can understand that Google is strict about this, that's their core business, CPC and conversion rate are what makes them the best advertising platform in the world. They have to protect that fiercely, even if some unfortunate users are thrown under the bus along the way. Is it possible in the AdSense scheme to set up multiple accounts? It seems if he'd had an account for the YouTube site, and another one for his sailing stuff, he'd at least have kept his money maker.
- vacri 16y agoheh, "immature algorithms" These are the algorithms that every man and his dog want the key to, the holy grail of net commerce. I was going to write something more sarcastic but instead I'll ask: Who has better algorithms and how are they doing with them?
- aznnico 16y agoThat's not necessarily true. Google sends out different emails depending on the method in which it banned you. The message that was sent out rules out a few automated systems, but doesn't tell the cause. Having high ctr doesn't mean its bad. There are accounts with 20% ctr which are fine. -Ex Google Spam
- mcantor 16y agoPerhaps I did not read carefully enough, but I didn't read anything that made it seem like he directly or indirectly asked anything. He simply makes a point of being 100% transparent in how he runs his business; part of that was explaining that ad clicks improve his revenue. Did Google expect him to lie?
- kelnos 16y agoEffectively, yes, if you consider keeping secrets to be lying. Saying "clicking on these adds gets me money," could easily be considered indirectly encouraging people to click on ads. And that's against Google's rules... and for good reason. I don't particularly like Google's lack of transparency, but all this stuff is in the terms you're required to agree to before you start using an AdSense account. Yes, it's a big scary legal document, but you can't say they didn't warn you.
- rbanffy 16y ago> Saying "clicking on these adds gets me money," could easily be considered indirectly encouraging people to click on ads How many people believe otherwise? If you cater to any audience with a 3-digit IQ, they know you get paid when they click. On my current arrangement I have payments on conversion (it's working well enough) but it requires a bit more work than AdSense did.
- FiddlerClamp 16y agoThey may think you only get paid if a) they click and b) they buy...
- disappoirnt 16y agoSome ads pay upon display. Some ads pay upon click. Some ads pay upon purchase. Most people (even those with 3-digit IQs) consider this stuff inside baseball, and don't investigate how different ad networks pay. Pointing out to your audience that the ads pay upon click will inspire a non-zero group of them to click a few ads to help you out. And frankly, even if they know that the ads are pay per click, mentioning that fact is a reasonably effective call to action.
- bambax 16y agoMaybe, but this happened on his site, and Google withheld the money from the Youtube ads, which constituted the bulk of his revenue. That's just not fair. And they continue to run ads next to his Youtube videos; they simply stopped giving him his share. That is even less fair. Maybe the lesson is: have multiple accounts with Adsense so that if one has a problem then the others are unaffected.
- dennisgorelik 16y agoIsn't it against Google policy to have multiple AdSense accounts?
- CoryMathews 16y agoyes
- shashank261 16y agoExactly. Also, why isn't he trying out with different keywords. Placing all the eggs in a single basket wont get you much. If he diversifies ad campaign across different categories, he will see better results. If he not happy with cost per click mode, he can switch to CPM advertising where ther are lesser chances of fraud.