4 ms·
Webvan's main problem was they expanded before they had their model figured out. They invested tens of millions in warehouses they didn't need with their curre
by rmason 7y ago
Webvan's main problem was they expanded before they had their model figured out. They invested tens of millions in warehouses they didn't need with their current volume as well.
If they had spent time on their model they'd have figured out that it only made sense to target the upper middle class neighborhoods at the time profitably. With that realization they'd never have built all the warehouses and with a lower burn they'd have survived only to eventually own the market.
The founder was a really smart guy who had already created a very successful startup. But he was under an imperative from his investors to ramp up fast.
A lot of the hard learned wisdom from that time would create a different outcome possibly today. I know that I'd have done a lot differently with my own startup back then if only I knew what is common wisdom today ;<).
- Gabriel_Martin 7y agosuch an important insight, that the investors were the ones pressuring him to structure it in this way.
- mmazing 7y agoTrue, but not blameless - he was the one to attempt to execute the plan that way.
- rmason 7y agoBack in that time everyone placed an over importance on being first and then locking up the market quickly. Sometimes like maybe Uber that's important. Reid Hoffman is still a proponent of this tactic with what he calls blitzscaling. Course nowadays he's a VC ;<). But as Google demonstrated you can enter after the market is mature with both a better product as well as a better business model and dominate.
- robocat 7y ago> But as Google demonstrated you can enter after the market is mature [] and dominate. I don't think Google (founded 20 years ago) is a good example of entering a mature market. I think a better example is Facebook (founded 15 years ago) which won against MySpace. I thought Salesforce (founded 20 years ago) should be a good example, but their market cap is still well below SAP's.
- davidjnelson 7y agoSearch was “mature” and “solved” prior to google. Altavista, webcrawler, infoseek, etc. Obviously it wasn’t actually solved ;-)
- ethbro 7y ago> I thought Salesforce (founded 20 years ago) should be a good example, but their market cap is still well below SAP's. Wouldn't chalk that up as a counter example. Just on how slow Enterprise migrations are.
- ethbro 7y agoIt wasn't an obviously wrong call. At a time when a sock puppet attracted millions in VC, it wasn't unreasonable to worry about better capitalized competitors overtaking you.
- mattrp 7y agoTwo things I remember from the webvan era- 1) how benchmark navigated / debated their investment (chronicled in https://www.amazon.com/eBoys-Inside-Account-Venture-Capitalists/dp/0812930959 https://www.amazon.com/eBoys-Inside-Account-Venture-Capitali...), 2) at the precise time that webvan was failing, fresh direct was succeeding but no one outside of NYC heard about their success because webvan failed so spectacularly.