3 ms·
That's probably true in isolation, but I have doubts about whether it scales. It's generally easier and less time consuming to produce a bad argument than it i
by tzs 7y ago
That's probably true in isolation, but I have doubts about whether it scales.
It's generally easier and less time consuming to produce a bad argument than it is to produce a good argument to refute the bad argument. For the targets of the arguments, it often is harder and more time consuming to follow the good argument, too.
Get too many independent sources of bad arguments in your society, and there simply won't be time and resources to counter them.
- ashton314 7y agoYou raise a good point. Sure, it can't match the scale. However, I think that if you can sway the intelligent and conscientious, you've won most of the battle. You don't need to (and really can't) counter every bad or false argument or idea. Maybe I'm too optimistic, though. Trying to scale effective debate is a hard problem. I've run across a few entities that are trying to make civil, open discourse more commonplace. Unfortunately I forget the name… Anyone got examples?
- pmarreck 7y agoThere are sites like procon.org that pit arguments 1-vs-1, but don't really make allowances for rebuttals, see this one on e-cigs for example: https://www.procon.org/headline.php?headlineID=005430 https://www.procon.org/headline.php?headlineID=005430
- pmarreck 7y ago> It's generally easier and less time consuming to produce a bad argument than it is to produce a good argument to refute the bad argument Yep, that's the main reason the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gish_gallop https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gish_gallop works. > Get too many independent sources of bad arguments in your society, and there simply won't be time and resources to counter them. You can find time and resources to counter the most damaging bad arguments, though. Many bad arguments just do things like sell pills or supplements that don't actually do anything measurable that beats placebo; not really harmful per se, even if based on bullshit. See: "Dr." Oz.
- joeblow9999 7y ago"It's generally easier and less time consuming to produce a bad argument than it is to produce a good argument to refute the bad argument. " im sorry but to me this seems counterintuitive. occams razor and all. do you have any supporting info for this? genuinely curious
- Gibbon1 7y agoYes. Interests that need to rely on bad arguments to push their agenda will spend a lot of effort polishing their propaganda and arguments to work with general ignorance, psychological biases, group think, and subtle fallacies.
- jhanschoo 7y agoMost of the doubt can be alleviated if it were enforced that such dialogue must be conducted in good faith by open minds. Bad arguments are so prevalent because their staunchest peddlers aren't arguing from ignorance alone, but arguing from deep-seated convictions or selfish interests. That is, they violate the criteria of good faith and open mind.