6 ms·
Once as he leaves and once as he returns. I'll take it over being smushed. What drives me batshit is when there's a kid in the seat behind me who uses my seat b
by bitwize 7y ago
Once as he leaves and once as he returns. I'll take it over being smushed. What drives me batshit is when there's a kid in the seat behind me who uses my seat back as a punching bag and just goes all out on it with hands and feet.
- malthaus 7y agoFriendly remind the parent of parenting?
- _nalply 7y agoIt's impossible to force some children to be quiet. If I were the parent of my mildly autistic son I would answer that he is autistic and mute and that it's useless.
- jessaustin 7y agoMost people would understand this rare exception, but it is very rare. I've seen (and felt) lots of seats being kicked, and never once was the guilty child autistic.
- _nalply 7y agoIt's not a rare exception, it is only one of the possible motives of kicking seats. Suck it up or try to find an agreement with the person behind you. Talk directly with the child.
- jessaustin 7y agoI'd love to live in a world in which strangers on an airplane would welcome my chastisement of their unruly children. I don't live in that world, however. Your family situation certainly inspires my sympathy, but do you really want people to assume that all misbehaving children are probably autistic? That's not a good stereotype to foster.
- ycombobreaker 7y agoYou really can speak with children who aren't yours. Some parents will probably be upset or offended no matter how you approach, well tough luck for them. I think most parents will be shamed as an initial response but the key is your delivery. Don't be a jerk of adult. The child likely does not understand the consequences of kicking on a seat. Explain to the child that you can feel it and that it bothers or hurts you, it may make more impact than routing feedback through the parents. It may not work. It may take some reiteration. The parents may politely explain a learning disability in which you just engage with them. The parents may give you a stinkeye. Oh well, kids need to learn how to interact with the rest of their world, and the parents who you seem to be most worried about are probably the ones whose kids need it the most. Usually I find that parents are reasonable and appreciate other adults treating their children like small, learning humans rather than tiny monsters.
- magduf 7y ago>Usually I find that parents are reasonable and appreciate other adults treating their children like small, learning humans rather than tiny monsters. Maybe they should stop allowing their children to behave like tiny monsters. This just isn't a problem in many other cultures; you don't see children in Japan act like that. This is mostly an American phenomenon because people forgot how to be good parents in this society.
- sidlls 7y agoChildren from countries other than America exhibit poor behavior. That's what children do, because they lack the structures and connections in their brains that adults have that provide us the ability to comport ourselves the way we do.
- magduf 7y agoThey aren't as bad as American children, because in other cultures they're taught from an early age how to behave appropriately around other people. In America, parents think their kids are special snowflakes and should never be disciplined, so bad behavior is rampant. The culture in America really is different from other places, as much as you might refuse to believe this. As for "structures and connections", that's a ridiculous excuse. Sure, when children are infants you can make that excuse because they're really too young to learn almost anything. We're talking about kids that are 5-10 years old here. Differing upbringing doesn't somehow magically take effect only at age 18.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- stevekemp 7y agoYou can diagnose autism, that quickly? Wow.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sidlls 7y agoCertain ages and conditions of children make that irrelevant. Try getting a three year old to stop anything--you'll trade being a punching bag for deafness from shrieks and whining--or an autistic child to even be aware that he is doing it. It's rare that one knows more about how to handle children than their caregivers, and "reminders" from strangers are often wrong, besides being insulting.
- stevekemp 7y ago2-3 year olds probably don't have the arm-length to really reach too far forward. Older than that I'd hope they could be restrained - although not physically!
- braythwayt 7y agoI don't agree with that. When I purchase an airline ticket, my arrangement is with the airline, not with their other passengers. They owe me nothing. It is not a public space. I can no more shush their children (or such-by-proxy) than I can call up another customer of my internet provider and ask them to use less bandwidth so that I get more. I can ask the flight attendant to speak to the parents about the kid kicking the seat, but if the flight attendant declines to fix my problem, my ire is best directed at the airline declining to provide me with a comfortable environment. They could institute a no-children rule, or a "your children must behave or you will be banned from flying our airline" rule, just as Hacker News chooses what kind of behaviour to moderate and what to allow. But the airlines openly tolerate this behaviour for their own reasons, and I choose to do business with them. I strongly suspect that although they are tactful about it, what they would like to say if I complain is, "If you will just give me your credit card, Sir, I will upgrade your ticket to first class. Come this way, I will pour you a flute of champagne." We celebrate naked capitalism at the expense of customers here. It turns out, airlines do as well.
- rsfern 7y agoI don’t think US carriers can legally institute a no-children rule — i think this sort of policy would constitute age discrimination [0]. Not sure about other localities. Removing particularly disruptive/belligerent passengers seems to be fair game, but really that’s exceptional and doesn’t apply to most of the interactions being discussed here. I don’t think anyone in this thread is saying that travelers should be entitled to shush other people’s children, which would be incredibly rude. You’re perfectly entitled to go through the intermediary of the airline, but I think polite engagement along the lines of what GP suggested would be a positive feature of society. [0]: https://www.dol.gov/agencies/oasam/regulatory/statutes/age-discrimination-act https://www.dol.gov/agencies/oasam/regulatory/statutes/age-d...
- braythwayt 7y agoThey may not be able to, I certainly don't actually want them to. I'm fine with kids when I travel economy, and I'm fine with fewer distractions when I travel comfort economy.
- J-dawg 7y agoThe offset seats also look like they create extra gaps for kids to poke their hands through and annoy people in front. Or if you're really unlucky, someone's gross feet.
- cannonedhamster 7y agoIf your feet enter my space they become my property to do with as I please. In fact if anything enters my space unannounced I assume it's a gift from the flying gods and act appropriately. This includes people reclining their heads into my face. My heavily breathing onto your face while I stare at you sleeping because you jammed your seat into my knees is just rewards. It helps not being afraid of breaking social niceties in order to enforce them on others who can't be bothered to do them. In the same token poor new parents with screaming babies get my sympathy. It's hard enough trying to coo your child while feeling horrible about messing with everyone around because your family lives somewhere else. Adults and children old enough to know better... That's another story.
- braythwayt 7y agoI have always felt the same way. Flying with other people's children is infuriating. (So is dining with other people's children, or taking public transit with other people's children. Or a car-share pool with other people's children...) Conclusion: Sharing an environment with other people's children statistically sucks. We may win some victories here and there with tact, diplomacy, and/or luck, but that's the reality. And I am especially sensitive to this, as when I fly to Europe and am stuck in this cacophony for six to eight hours, I usually have a presentation or essay I'm working on and could really use a distraction-free environment. So I'm both irritated and feeling stressed that I can't work effectively. This is suboptimal personally and professionally. So what are my options? I chose to fly economy. I could have gotten rich and bought my own plane, but no. I could have spent money flying first class (which filters a LOT of families out). But no. I chose to fly economy, where the price of my ticket was low PRECISELY because families are also flying economy, subsidizing my ticket. If an airline offered an "Absolutely no kids allowed" flight for anything except a vacation charter, the seats would be more expensive. So instead, they offer first class, and "comfort economy," and if I want a seat not subsidized by unruly toddlers and crying infants, that's what I purchase. It's harsh, but the universe is no more "fair" to me than it is to people who want affordable housing in San Francisco.
- mikeash 7y agoSounds like your best option is to stop procrastinating so badly that you have to get work done in one of the least work-friendly environments out there.
- braythwayt 7y agoAlso true :-D
- stevekemp 7y agoEven on long flights without children it's hard to imagine them as being relaxing/productive hours. My personal bug-bear is neighbours spilling over my seat. Having wider seats would help but some people really do need to be using two seats not just one.
- 7y ago