5 ms·
Yes, more guns is always the solution !!! https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2e/2010_homicide_suicide_rates_high-income_countries.png https://upl
by lm28469 7y ago
Yes, more guns is always the solution !!!
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2e/2010_homicide_suicide_rates_high-income_countries.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2e/2010_hom...
- MadSudaca 7y agocorrelation != causation
- AmericanChopper 7y agoRegardless of what you think of 2A, this is exactly the sort of situation it was designed to address. In Hong Kong, you have a completely unarmed population demanding democracy. Being oppressed by an (in the particular case, arguably foreign) government, with a long history of slaughtering unarmed populations who demand democracy.
- lm28469 7y agoWhat if the 60% of US citizens who don't approve of Trump want to overthrow his government ? Would that be part of the 2nd amendment ? Where do you draw the line ?
- AmericanChopper 7y agoNothing about those situations are comparable. The president of the USA is democratically elected. The USA is ruled by its own government, not the government of a foreign country (which a huge amount of Hong Kong citizens view China as), the citizens of Hong Kong don’t want to overthrow their government, they want to protect themselves from clearly oppressive regime, the USA has a rather impressive set of constitutionally guaranteed rights, citizens of the USA have access to a robust legal system. There is nothing about the situation in Hong Kong that compares to any level of dissatisfaction you believe may exist with a democratically elected government.
- cgriswald 7y agoGenerally speaking: "There are four boxes to be used in the defense of liberty: soap, ballot, jury and ammo. Please use in that order."[0] Where to draw that line is a personal choice. There are no simple answers. "You can never make that choice" is just as extreme and absolute an answer as "any time you are unhappy about anything the government does, start shooting." [0]-https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_boxes_of_liberty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_boxes_of_liberty
- briandear 7y agoNorth Korea has very few gun deaths. I am pretty sure people would trade a slightly higher gun death rate for actual freedom.
- homonculus1 7y agoI would describe this line of reasoning as tautological. A proper analysis would compare total violence and eliminate other factors like income inequality and education. The preoccupation with "gun violence" is like fixating on, say, truck collisions-- it provides no actual insight into what variable is driving traffic fatalities, but trucks sure are big and scary!
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoIt's a hell of a lot harder (or at least more costly) to violently impose your will on people who can violently defend themselves.
- Drakim 7y agoA civilian population armed with guns to the teeth will still not be able to stand up even a little to a real well organized military with gear. Maybe it would be more costly, but the escalation would also provide the justification to strike down the population completely and simply murder all the protesters. Instead of reading about peaceful protesters being attacked you'd read about the military taking out insurgents.
- novok 7y agoAfghanistan and iraq would like to talk to you
- simonh 7y agoBoth are very good examples of the point. Both are dominated not by free armed civilians protecting their rights, but by organised well armed militias that completely suppress the rights and freedoms of the general population in their areas of control. Yes ordinary people in much of Afghanistan and parts of Iraq can get hold of firearms if the want to. It doesn't help them at all. They are utterly dominated by either the local militias in Iraq (Sunni and Shiia depending on their area), or by the Taliban in much of Afghanistan. If arming everybody worked to promote freedom, then Iraq and Afghanistan would be free associations of local communities joining together to protect their liberties. That is clearly not the case, and it isn't the case in any country with weak government and pervasive access to arms. Guns everywhere make the weak weaker and the strong stronger. Guns do not even the playing field. In practice they dramatically tilt the playing field even more in favour of those with a willingness and propensity to use violence.
- cgriswald 7y ago> Instead of reading about peaceful protesters being attacked you'd read about the military taking out insurgents. In both cases, you'd read what the oppressor wants you to read.
- cgriswald 7y agoVoting and protesting are resulting in oppression and physical assault. Your argument, such as it is, is equivalent to saying people should not be allowed to defend themselves, because someone might get hurt. It rests on the hidden assumption that guns cause violence, which isn't supported by the evidence you offer; and flies in the face of the actual violence in HK.
- salawat 7y agoToo add on to your point, there is also another hidden assumption: That violence is never the answer. In civil society, we like to preach that, but as soon as the basic pillars of civility disappear, violence is unfortunately the only answer. Worrisome times indeed.
- simonh 7y agoNobody was killed in the recent violence. Are you seriously suggesting that the commuters would have been safer, and less likely to get killed, if both sides had been armed with guns?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- austhrow743 7y agoIt's better that a thousand individuals get to kill each other than one person be oppressed by a government.
- noonespecial 7y agoChange "one person" to "all persons" and you have the heart of the second amendment argument. You may disagree, but it is not an unreasonable position.
- austhrow743 7y agoOh absolutely but when you phrase it like that you risk getting bogged down in the minutiae of irrelevant details like the exact impact removing/adding more guns would have on a society's homicide rate, like that's at all relevant to what is at it's core a disagreement on principles. Best to express your stance in the most extreme way possible so you don't get stuck in detail quibbles. A disarmed society is an enslaved society.
- noonespecial 7y agoThat's the tough part isn't it? It's just a cost benefit analysis. There's no "one true way". The Americans chose one end of the spectrum, the English the other. Both approaches worked out reasonably well. That's not something either side really wants to hear these days.