4 ms·
> not to our benefit That remains to be seen, IMHO because it would be very lucky that the current global climate is the optimum for human activities. For exa
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
> not to our benefit
That remains to be seen, IMHO because it would be very lucky that the current global climate is the optimum for human activities.
For example, with a bit more CO2 in the atmosphere plants grow bigger. Warming might also open more land to agriculture than is lost. Etc.
- abraae 7y agoYeah, possibly, or more likely it's incredibly dangerous making rapid changes to the chaotic but balanced system that we live within. The plants might grow bigger - until a voracious pest migrates into the newly available area and destroys them, or wildfires raging in the newly warmed area burn them to the ground. The current global climate is probably not the optimum for human activities - perhaps that was some time ago, before the extreme weather events that we are ushering in started wreaking havoc. There's no reason to believe that fucking up the planet is somehow leading us towards a better, more optimum situation.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoMy point is that a warmer climate does not imply a worse climate for human activities overall. Currently the narrative is change = bad.
- polotics 7y agoWhat narrative? There are extensive models! More climate chaos = bad!
- mytailorisrich 7y agoUsing the term "climate chaos" in a discussion about changing climate is indeed pushing a narrative.
- mikeash 7y agoCO2 levels have increased by 50% over the past couple of centuries. Are plants growing bigger as a result?
- mytailorisrich 7y agoYes. Although this can be countered by other factors (e.g. less water, excessive heat, etc).
- jellicle 7y agoYou know this has been studied, right? The conclusion is that it's a big net negative for humanity.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoHaven't seen so definitive results... For example, it is projected that wheat yield would decrease in India. Fine. But how much more wheat would we be able to grow in, e.g., Russia?
- polotics 7y agoYou find out! Soil doesn't magically turn productive you know, it takes an ecosystem to make topsoil.
- jellicle 7y ago"It should be noted that the overall yield of grain crops in Russia is expected to drop by as much as 17 per cent by 2050. At the same time, in the Central, Volga, and Ural Federal districts the plunge in crop yield is described as ‘catastrophic’ at 14, 30, and 38 per cent by 2050, respectively." "Without adequate measures to adapt agriculture to climate change, the annual economic loss from a decrease in climate-determined crop yield in Russia is estimated at RUB 108bn (approximately $3.5bn) by 2020 and over RUB 120bn (approximately $3.9bn) by 2050."
- mytailorisrich 7y agoLogically this can only come from reduced precipitation, which can be countered. And of course, more adapted crops can be grown. There is a lot of potential in Russia to benefit from warmer conditions.