4 ms·
There are good—I would even say “great”—comment threads, that are just as worth reading as standalone articles are. Threads where all of the comments are good,
by derefr 7y ago
There are good—I would even say “great”—comment threads, that are just as worth reading as standalone articles are. Threads where all of the comments are good, and nobody dares ruin the “mood” of productive conversation by butting in with the usual argumentativeness†.
• threads where the authors of the post do a “post-article interview” to add extra information in response to questions;
• threads on posts that are stories about something historical, where in the comments, a person involved in the history itself (not the author) shows up and tells more such stories;
• threads on posts about some cool thing the author made, where commenters point out other cool things the author has made; or point out other cool things that are complements to the original cool thing (rather than getting into a debate about replacements for the cool thing.) Threads about new works by prolific hackers (e.g. DJB), or prolific academics (e.g. Scott Aaronson), are good for this.
• threads on posts about choosing tool/technology X and the anecdata of its advantages/disadvantages for the author’s use-case; where the comments are from other people who either made the same choice, or a choice of comparable technologies Y or Z instead; and, rather than just being a partisan argument for their technology, they give a compare-and-contrast of the products in the product-space X occupies, giving a clinical evaluation of the advantages and disadvantages of X, Y, and Z for the original author’s use-case, as if they were asynchronously collaborating with the author on a greater work.
As it turns out, all three of these, in one way or another, are “encores” to the post. Things that add value of the same kind that the post itself has.
...and then there are bad comment threads. Which is, IMHO, everything else. (Including this thread! I shouldn’t be in here!)
† I think it’s kind of like street art. Paint a beautiful mural on a wall, and nobody’s gonna deface it with boring old graffiti. Every graffito thinks themselves an artist, and so respects good art. Every HN debater thinks themselves a scholar, and so respects productive scholarship.
——
Honestly, I wish there was a meta-HN, with a lag-time of ~48hrs behind HN, that just linked to the ensuing discussions that turned out to have been worth people’s time to read, when judged by the same criteria that we use to upvote links (“gratifies intellectual curiosity”, etc.)
In combination with a “just the links” feed (as in this one, or just as in consuming HN via RSS), you’d both 1. get a really enjoyable experience, and 2. probably feel much less of a need to participate yourself. (I need this, honestly.)