3 ms·

You turn the author's argument around and then make a statement even more pretentious and wrong. Neither piano nor voice nor even orchestra are ‘ultimate instru

by aasasd 7y ago

You turn the author's argument around and then make a statement even more pretentious and wrong. Neither piano nor voice nor even orchestra are ‘ultimate instruments,’ for the simple reason that timbre- and rhythm-oriented music exist. Saying that any particular instruments or styles are the measures of ‘musical substance’ is equal to asking that there be less of different music—which is the ultimate arrogance that you can apply to music.

maceurt 7y ago
The human voice is the original musical instrument, and humans have evolved to specifically listen to the human voice. I love the piano, but I don't think it is a stretch to say that for humans, the human voice is the ultimate instrument. I don't mean to sound pretentious, but if you just look at the popularity of different instruments, voice is the runaway favorite. The majority of the world listens to mostly voice as the primary instrument. To call it the ultimate instrument is not a stretch at all since it is the oldest and most popular instrument in human history.