A piano rendition of a song previously only sung can still be recognized as that same song. However if you sing a song previously only heard on piano, recogni

A piano rendition of a song previously only sung can still be recognized as that same song. However if you sing a song previously only heard on piano, recognizing that song might not be so easy. Although now that I think about it, the only instrument that can really compete with throat singing is the Jew's harp. So in that limited respect I think you might be right.