5 ms·
Until recently, everyone has lived near the border of starvation, and not had an opportunity to get obese. Since the agricultural revolution, carbs are what we
by BurningFrog 7y ago
Until recently, everyone has lived near the border of starvation, and not had an opportunity to get obese.
Since the agricultural revolution, carbs are what we have been able to mass produce, and therefore breed ourselves to greater numbers on. That it probably hasn't been the ideal diet for us is a distant secondary concern.
Now that we're finally overproducing food, we actually are getting obese on the carb diet. Coincidence? Maybe.
- twic 7y agoI think the Venus of Willendorf and her equally thicc cousins are, if you'll excuse the expression, ample proof that some people had an opportunity to get obese long before the agricultural revolution.
- BurningFrog 7y agoSure. When I said "everybody" I really meant "almost everybody". Of course, in preindustrial times, obesity was a sign of wealth, and that statue might be an ideal to strive for, made by paper thin worshippers.
- chrisco255 7y agoThe Venus is a fictional character. In the same era you would see statues of men with phalluses as big as their bodies. Obesity was probably rare before the agricultural revolution.
- blaser-waffle 7y agoDidn't someone put a theory out that the Venus of Willendorf was not venerating the Fat Goddess, but rather what someone sees when they look straight down at their body? (cuz cave people didn't have good mirrors and all) Deeper explanation: https://steemit.com/science/@deeallen/self-portraits-of-fertility-symbols-venus-figurines-of-upper-paleolithic-eurasia-nudity https://steemit.com/science/@deeallen/self-portraits-of-fert...
- twic 7y agoThere are all sorts of theories! Olga Soffer points out that the woven clothing on the figurines is often incredibly detailed, and suggests they may have been some kind of fashion doll [1]. Mandy Weston speculates that they may be bobbins used for weaving [2]! [1] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/235979951_The_Venus_Figurines_Textiles_Basketry_Gender_and_Status_in_the_Upper_Paleolithic https://www.researchgate.net/publication/235979951_The_Venus... [2] https://www.academia.edu/31112020/Venus_Figurines_-_Evidence_of_Womens_Work https://www.academia.edu/31112020/Venus_Figurines_-_Evidence...
- spraak 7y agoI believe that you're missing the point. We aren't getting obese on the carb diet. We are getting obese from excess calories and dietary fat. De novo lipogenesis (producing fat from only carbs) is inefficient and uncommon. Storing carbs as body fat via de novo lipogenesis is inefficient; storing dietary fat in body fat reserves is easy and efficient.
- weddpros 7y agostoring dietary fat works best when you eat carbs, because then your body will run on carbs and carbs will spike your insuline to signal the body to store the fat. Also the insuline spikes and drops make you crave more carbs...
- spraak 7y agoThat sounds like a very keto perspective. Meat can "spike" insulin, too. > "In fact meat protein causes as much insulin release as pure sugar." and "Some of the protein-rich foods (beef, cheese, eggs) had larger insulin responses per gram than did many of the foods consisting predominately of carbohydrate." and "A low-fat diet based on less-refined, carbohydrate-rich foods with relatively low insulin scores may help enhance satiety and aid weight loss as well as improve blood glucose and lipid control" [1] If you're not eating excess calories and are limiting fat intake, you won't get fat. [1] http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/66/5/1264.full.pdf http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/66/5/1264.full.pdf
- teroszsegv 7y ago"The results of this study are preliminary but we hope they stimulate discussion and further research. Additional studies are needed to determine whether the IS concept is useful, reproducible around the world, predictable in a mixed-meal context, and cliii ically useful in the treatment of diabetes mellitus, hyperlipidemia, and overweight" Interesting but ultimately a flawed concept. Since i was born and for 45 years i was eating a typical mediterranean diet (i live in these parts) very high in complex carbs and fibers from legumes, whole grain breads, beans. what exactly did that to my health? Gradualy from my early teens years i become overweight and later on obese, my cholesterol levels skyrocket and from the age of 20 i became pre-diabetic Since i started a low carb diet 3 years ago (48 yo now) not only i lost all that extra weght, but i'm no longer pre diabetic and the cholesterol levels went down to normal levels. most importantly, i feel and i'm as healthy as i've never felt in my whole life so far. and all this by eating mostly meat, fish, eggs, full fat dairy and a bit of vegetables/fruits I know very well what these 45 years of eating low-fat high complex carbs actualy did to my health and how much i suffered all these years, and i'm not intend to return back to these eating habits, Ever!
- cageface 7y agoThe rise of obesity in the US tracks very closely with the massive increase in cheese & chicken consumption. Sugar consumption actually plateaued years earlier.
- RomanBob 7y agoSo if i switch to tofu and beef, i won't get fat?
- cageface 7y agoI doubt you’d be able to stomach enough tofu to gain weight eating that alone. You’d have to eat 10 cups a day just to hit a maintenance level of about 2000 calories. It would be a lot easier on fatty cuts of beef at 330 calories for 100g.