4 ms·
Is there even a "pure" browser anymore? By that, I mean one which by default will do this: if I enter a URL in the address bar, it will fetch that page and its
by userbinator 7y ago
Is there even a "pure" browser anymore? By that, I mean one which by default will do this: if I enter a URL in the address bar, it will fetch that page and its associated resources. If I click a link on a page, it will fetch its destination (this is obviously a simplified view, ignoring things like JS on the page etc.) No other network activity, no "recommendations", no other attempts to be "smart" or "helping" by doing anything beyond "pure" browsing.
I see a lot of this extra functionality being justified in the name of "security", but I don't think the gradual erosion of personal responsibility and agency that results is something which should continue.
"The road to hell is paved with good intentions."
- tga 7y agoSomewhat related, I recently realized that Microsoft Outlook on Android fetches _all mail_ on Microsoft servers, then sends it over to the app. If this is mentioned anywhere when setting up the account, I totally missed it. This led me to look for a "pure" email client that would _only_ contact my server. Popular apps like Blue Mail and myMail did not work at all behind a firewall that blocked random internet access. I am happy to report that K-9 mail (open source) was what I was looking for: it never tried to access anything other than my mail server. I wholeheartedly recommend using NoRoot firewall (or similar) to see just how many random servers your (flashlight) apps talk to (and watch them fail miserably when you block that).
- dontbenebby 7y agoFirefox might not meet your definition but with a few extensions (Containers, NoScript, uBlock origin) it's quite good at protecting your privacy.
- gottam 7y agoThe only thing is they integrate things like pocket and they're putting some other things in soon.
- ubercow13 7y agoPocket is part of Mozilla
- Aissen 7y agoAnd it still is not open-sourced, two years and five months after the acquisition: https://github.com/Pocket/extension-save-to-pocket/issues/75 https://github.com/Pocket/extension-save-to-pocket/issues/75 For comparison, it took Red Hat less than two years to open source Ansible Tower.
- LeoPanthera 7y agoI believe that Gnome's Epiphany (now confusingly called "Web") and KDE's Falkon are still "pure" browsers. Epiphany can integrate with a Firefox account, I think? But it's not on by default. Epiphany only works on Linux but Falkon is available for Windows as well. Neither works on Macs but Macs have Safari which probably counts as "pure" if you aren't signed into iCloud. iCloud is pretty inoffensive even if you are.
- l_t 7y agosurf [0] does that. "It is able to display websites and follow links." [0]: https://surf.suckless.org/ https://surf.suckless.org/
- agumonkey 7y agodillo is my weapon of choice
- dredmorbius 7y agoDillo has all the modern-web functionality of lynx, all the keyboard-driven capacity of Safari, and all the UI/UX appeal of an abandoned brutalist shopping mall. Sure is fast though. Other than quick site previews, I rarely use it.
- jzelinskie 7y agoBrave?
- LeoPanthera 7y agoDid you even read what he wanted? Brave is a crytocurrency wallet and advertising platform that just happens to be able to browse the web.
- skarz 7y agoFor anyone who's wondering, Firefox handles Safe Browsing a lot differently. There's an overview here: https://feeding.cloud.geek.nz/posts/how-safe-browsing-works-in-firefox/ https://feeding.cloud.geek.nz/posts/how-safe-browsing-works-... It's possible that this is outdated though. The tl;dr is that 1. Firefox downloads a list of partial hashes every 30 minutes from Google. It's only the first 32 bits of each hash. This can easily be turned off in about:preferences. 2. When you visit a website, Firefox checks the beginning of the URL against the partial hashes stored locally. 3. If the partial hash matches the beginning of the URL, Firefox downloads a list of all of the hashes beginning with the partial hash it matched. 4. Firefox checks the full hash of the URL against the new list of full hashes. If it matches, the site is blocked. If not, you continue on browsing. When I first found out how it worked a while ago, I was pretty amazed. It goes to great lengths to not know what sites you're visiting.
- aawc 7y ago[Disclaimer: I'm the TL of Safe Browsing in Chrome, and I worked directly with the author of the linked article for Firefox v4 support.] FWIW, Google Chrome does the same because both Google Chrome and Firefox use the same Safe Browsing protocol v4. The linked post was written a while ago when Firefox still used the protocol v2 but the post is still largely accurate.
- ryankrage77 7y agoI think Waterfox meets your requirements. The only telemetry it sends is the version number so it can self-update (I haven't personally verified this).