3 ms·
> Did the Geiger counter click or did you hallucinate or did the counter misfire, etc. Doesn't matter. What matters is that objective observers listening to
by lisper 7y ago
> Did the Geiger counter click or did you hallucinate or did the counter misfire, etc.
Doesn't matter. What matters is that objective observers listening to the counter independently will all agree on how many clicks it made in a given period of time. It is this agreement that needs explaining. One possible explanation is that the counter did, in point of physical fact, click that many times. In fact, that seems like a very plausible explanation for the agreement to most people. That plausibility doesn't necessarily make it correct, but it does mean that you cannot dismiss it as "simply incorrect." If I hallucinated the clicks, why then do I agree with all the other observers, including inanimate ones like electronic counters? Are we all experiencing the same hallucination? If the counter "misfired" then why do geiger counters give the appearance of producing random clicks in response to radiation?
- mlthoughts2018 7y agoHuh? If the counter is broken, you’ll all agree on the wrong number, because of your mistaken brain state (believing the counter to be functioning correctly). You may use a lot of italics, but the statement doesn’t add up to anything.
- lisper 7y ago> If the counter is broken, you’ll all agree on the wrong number In what way will this number be "wrong"?