4 ms·
The people behind this service should beware of copyright violations - just because a video has been made accessible to the general public by their authors does
by kleiba 16y ago
The people behind this service should beware of copyright violations - just because a video has been made accessible to the general public by their authors does not necessarily mean that others have the right to translate the contents of that video.
I remember that a co-worker of mine started translating his favorite math book into his native language, at first just for his private use. But then he thought that others might benefit from his effort, too, so he contacted the publisher of the original book. He was only half-way through with the translations and had kept everything to himself, but the publisher was not amused at all and fired back at him in classic cease-and-desist manner. He stopped translating right away.
Such an attitude sucks, but from a business perspective I can sort of understand that the copyright holders want to keep the option to offer a translated version themselves. And in that case, it's certainly their right to pick the (certified) translator of their choice.
I don't know if the above scenario translates (no pun intended) very well to web videos, especially those that are made available without commercial interest by their authors. But the question of copyrights is ever so present these days.
- beoba 16y agoYour co-worker was creating a direct translated copy of the original material, whereas in this case it's a caption which is only really usable in conjunction with the original. I think the problem would be if you were actually distributing the original video along with the caption, but in this case only the user-created caption is changing hands. See eg Rifftrax
- drdaeman 16y agoIt's somehow fun and weird at the same time, how RMS lectures cannot be legally translated in this way. This's because RMS asks to license videos under CC-ND, which, along with obvious misuse (out-of-context cuts, gluing unrelated fragments together to create fakes etc), forbids proper transcripts and translations.