3 ms·
> why do people have issues with accepting the Born rule as an axiom Because it offends people's intuitions about what must be happening behind the scenes to m
by lisper 7y ago
> why do people have issues with accepting the Born rule as an axiom
Because it offends people's intuitions about what must be happening behind the scenes to make it true. Thermodynamics is mathematically complicated, but intuitively very straightforward: you've got a bunch of billiard balls bouncing around. People can visualize that. QM is fundamentally different. For starters, the wave function operates in configuration space rather than physical space, and is not always separable (which is what produces entangled states). Furthermore, in classical mechanics, the limitation on knowing the complete state of a system is merely technological. If we had accurate enough measuring equipment the state of any system could be known in principle. In QM this is no longer true. QM makes the true state of a system inaccessible even in principle.
BTW, with respect to the arrow time, you might enjoy this:
http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-arrow-of-time.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-ar...
- leiroigh 7y agoYeah, QM offends my aesthetic sensibilities as well. I cannot but shake my head in disgust at creation. But it does not get better by attempting to derive the Born rule. Of all things to get offended by, why do people single out the Born rule? For example, non-locality (e.g. Aharanov-Bohm) is imo much easier to understand and already disqualifies reality from "believable theory-building". I genuinely don't get it. Re your link: I don't understand why the linked post talks about QM at all. The arrow of time is a perfectly classical phenomenon; phrasing it in terms of QM only helps us understand the formalism of QM if we already understood the classical arrow of time. Or am I misunderstanding something?
- lisper 7y ago> it does not get better by attempting to derive the Born rule. Well, it would get better if you actually could derive the Born rule without begging the question. But you can't so it doesn't. > Of all things to get offended by, why do people single out the Born rule? I guess you'd have to ask someone who was actually offended by it. > am I misunderstanding something? Yes, I think so. The arrow of time is not a purely classical phenomenon. Perhaps it could be, i.e. if we were living in a purely classical universe there might still be an arrow of time, but this is a moot point because we are not living in a classical universe, so classical thermodynamics is not what creates the arrow of time in our universe. It's more fundamental than that. It impossible to extract a classical universe from quantum dynamics without establishing an arrow of time in the process.
- leiroigh 7y agoAh, ok, with "purely classical phenomenon" I meant "the classical limit h->0 also exhibits an arrow of time; observing the arrow of time and thermodynamics is not enough to distinguish between a classical and quantum universe". Therefore we gain no additional understanding of the phenomenon by looking at QM; at most, we gain understanding of the mathematical framework of QM by seeing how its formalism describes the classical arrow of time. The arrow of time is a phenomenon that is robust under changes of underlying theory; may as well discuss the simplest models that exhibit it, and these are classical. Just like you would explain chaos with simple models first, e.g. horseshoe, Lorentz, 3-body, before going into highly specific 1000 dimensional systems. edit: "Deriving the Born rule". An insightful "derivation" would be a pseudo-theorem "if you want QM to limit to classical mechanics + Liouville Axiom, then you must adopt the Born rule". But afaik this has been mostly done, so there is nothing to explain anymore?
- lisper 7y ago> the classical limit h->0 also exhibits an arrow of time That is certainly true empirically. But it is much more difficult to explain why this happens in classical terms without begging the question -- you can't just invoke the second law of thermodynamics here. You have to derive the second law from Newtonian mechanics. That is an unsolved problem.
- leiroigh 7y agoNo, deriving the second law from Newton+Liouville is easy (in the form of "mathematically plausible pseudo-theorem", that's late 19th century physics). If you don't adopt Liouville measure as axiom, then it is impossible by (more modern) counter-example: Thermodynamics looks different if you pre-suppose that god cares about weird measures; and it is unavoidable if you pre-suppose that god cares about Liouville measure.
- lisper 7y agoOK... but this seems to me simply like trading one assumption for another. Is there any reason why adopting the Liouville measure as axiom is any less arbitrary than just adopting the second law directly?