3 ms·
Meta-Analysis of Relation of Skipping Breakfast with Heart Disease
- piker 7y agoWhat? Where did this theory come from? Haven't we learned recently that periodic fasting is better for you? And if you use skipping breakfast as a method of caloric restriction?
- jmpman 7y agoMaybe periodic fasting is also associated with heart disease.
- Xcelerate 7y agoYeah, first I heard breakfast was good for you, so I always ate breakfast, then I read it’s better not to eat breakfast because of some fasting effects, so I stopped eating breakfast. Now this article says it’s related to heart disease. I give up on these food studies; the findings never seem to be consistent. I think I’m just going to eat whenever I’m hungry (which isn’t that often).
- TheGRS 7y agoThe whole premise is flawed. We know certain people are more prone to heart disease or need more of this or that. If that's the case I can't see how some sort of conclusion can be made about when to eat. Some people are going to work better with breakfast and others are going to work better without.
- aldur 7y agoThis study [1] might relate to it: Intermittent Fasting in Cardiovascular Disorders—An Overview. In section 7 the authors expose pros and cons of intermittent fasting, specifying that for elderly individuals it might be associated with an increased risk of cardiovascular disease, while for the rest of the population it is generally associated with a decreased risk. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6471315/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6471315/
- pgt 7y ago"Skipping breakfast is associated with the increased risk of heart disease." Can we think of any bias for why people with heart disease might skip breakfast, e.g. older people don't eat breakfast for some reason?
- ryandvm 7y agoI suspect people with a lot of shit to do (i.e. stress) don't really make time for breakfast.
- shooner 7y agoThis was my thought process as well. First "Crap, I should start eating breakfast" then quickly to "or maybe I should restructure my life so I have the spare time and mindfulness to sit down for 15 minutes and eat breakfast."
- new_realist 7y agoDiabetics may not be hungry in the morning.
- b_tterc_p 7y agoSkipping breakfast comfortably implies you ate enough to cover the gap at dinner, which is probably too much in a time when your body is using minimal energy?
- hirundo 7y ago"meta-analysis of currently available epidemiological studies" A.k.a., not capable of determining causality. May be a bit closer to a Ouija board than a randomized controlled trial. This conforms to my bias as I'm a breakfast person; it's my largest meal of the day. But this kind of evidence is not a good basis on which to change your behavior. It's done because the data for it is available, not because it's probative. Like looking for your keys under the streetlight because that's where the light is.
- rscho 7y agoRandomized trials would be difficult...
- maxerickson 7y agoMeanwhile, statistics is a real discipline that works. It can of course be poorly used.
- ses1984 7y agoHow would you construct a randomized controlled trial that tests this? What are the ethics of putting people in an experimental group that you hypothesize has higher morbidity?