4 ms·
I'm starting to miss the days when people are buying votes with their own money instead of other people's money. /s I hope Congress also doubles all pour savin
by exabrial 7y ago
I'm starting to miss the days when people are buying votes with their own money instead of other people's money. /s
I hope Congress also doubles all pour savings as well, because the purchasing power of those is about to be diminished.
- rayiner 7y agoThe purchasing power angle makes no sense. Purchasing power will only be diminished if you increase the total money supply. Minimum wage won’t do that.
- rjf72 7y agoBloomberg ran a nice piece on what it's like to own a McDonald's franchise here [1]. The raw numbers sound nice - $2.7 million gross, $1.8 million in gross profit. But after your various expenses come into play, the honeymoon ends - you end up taking home about $150k for a mountain of work that's required to keep a franchise running in good shape. You're buying a job. The reason this matters is because those numbers are is pretty representative of many regular businesses; well outside 'our' world of VC driven mutual lotteries. You're taking home $150k yourself, but you're paying $540k in crew (non-managerial) payroll. And many of these guys are at or near minimum wage. Increase their wages just 30% (and going from $7.25 to $15 is a > 100% increase) would cost you $162k. And now you're losing money. And McDonalds are pretty primo in terms of profit. Life's often much harder for for the countless no-name businesses out there. It's the really counter intuitive nature of business. A company can make millions, yet have owner(s) that are, out of necessity, living relatively modestly. So imagine your labor costs skyrocket. What do you do? You really don't have any options. You increase prices or you go out of business. This seems likely to have a paradoxical effect. It means company with large profit margins are fine, but you squeeze the very low profit margin companies. And the low profit margins companies tend to have low profit margins because they're providing products at extremely cost to cost. E.g. company selling $50 steaks = no problem. Company selling $1 tacos = problem. So the very businesses who are doing to their most to cater to lower income people end up being the most negatively affected. Of course now their customers can afford to pay more, but that's precisely the definition of a reduction in a purchasing power per dollar. [1] - https://www.bloomberg.com/features/2015-mcdonalds-franchises/ https://www.bloomberg.com/features/2015-mcdonalds-franchises...
- clairity 7y agoyou make it sound so bad to own a mcd's franchise, but most people would be ecstatic at the chance. $150k roughly puts you in the top 10% by individual income. most people are quite happy working hard for that amount of money. and raising prices as a result would be fine since other minimum wage earners (i.e., customers) would now have more money to spend on fast food. (estimating based on your numbers, prices would have to increase about 10%)
- gwright 7y ago> and raising prices as a result would be fine since other minimum wage earners (i.e., customers) would now have more money to spend on fast food. (estimating based on your numbers, prices would have to increase about 10%) And what about the customers that aren't minimum wage earners and don't have more money to spend? And what about the formally minimum wage workers who no longer have a job or have fewer hours (reduced total wages) because the business cut head count and/or reduced hours? Just because the minimum wage is increased doesn't mean that it makes business sense to keep the same headcount/hours at the increased wage.
- clairity 7y agowhat small business owner really wastes money by carrying extra headcount though? if the business could have cut headcount before and still have done all the work needed, they would have done that already regardless of a change in minimum wage. small businesses just don't generally carry extra overhead the way a larger organization does.
- gwright 7y agoI think you are simplifying things quite a bit. For example, a grocery store might have minimum wage workers who help bag groceries to provide a better service to their customers. If the minimum wage goes up, then the store might decide to eliminate that service. My local Dairy Queen, for example, might decide that two people getting paid $15/hour will just have to do instead of three people getting paid $10/hour. Maybe that isn't for all shifts/times, but just on the margins. And of course it isn't just the lowest paid workers that are affected by this. Let's say there are two tiers of jobs at a particular business. One that pays $15/hour and one that is $10/hour. If the lowest tier must be paid $15, what happens to those workers at the next tier of $15/hour? Either their pay must be increased or they are going to be unhappy about having more responsibilities/skills for the same pay as the person that was just hired. Alternatively new hires will have little incentive to work harder to fill the next tier (since they won't get paid any more). So wages for the positions just above minimum wage also have to go up increasing total payroll costs. IMHO, Anyone who thinks that hourly wages can be increased by 50% ($10 to $15, for example), without having a significant impact on any business that depends on low-skilled labor isn't thinking very deeply about this sort of change. I'm being generous also since the federal change is almost a 100% increase.