4 ms·
Do nerds remember back in the day when many were calling out for Microsoft to be broken up? Into two parts: OS division, and Apps division. The idea was that t
by igravious 7y ago
Do nerds remember back in the day when many were calling out for Microsoft to be broken up? Into two parts: OS division, and Apps division.
The idea was that time and again Microsoft's OS division would anti-competitvely design internal APIs in DOS and Windows that its App division would leverage. There were also instances where Microsoft subtley broke DOS (and maybe even Windows, but definitely DOS) for competing applications. People used to talk about "undocumented" API calls.
In the end Microsoft's OS gained proper competition through the paradigm shift of FOSS, specifically with Linux. Microsoft helped a key competitor (Apple) off its knees and look where we are now – Apple has a mobile OS, Microsoft has none. Microsoft didn't board the internet/web train quick enough, didn't forsee how big search and social media would become (in fairness, a vanishingly small number of people did) and so now they have Google and Facebook to compete with. Amazon parlaying their experience from a building an at-scale marketplace to a cloud-computing platform took everyone by surprise.
Back in the day I lamented Microsoft's stranglehold on the software industry. They are still a behemoth but they no longer have the stranglehold they once had. Amazon has competition. Does Amazon unfairly leverage its marketplace monopoly to crush competitors? If they do, prosecute them. If they don't, out innovate and out compete them!
Will Google's stranglehold on search ever be broken? Maybe we'll have to think laterally. Like distributed open-source search. Will Facebook's hegemony over social media (FB, FB messenger, WhatsApp, Instagram) ever be challenged? Do we have the luxury of finding out in a decade or two like we did with Microsoft? Microsoft never amassed the data on their "customers" that Google and Facebook and every Tom, Dick, and Harry do now.
Of all these companies I intuitively feel that Facebook should be broken up. Into its constituent social media parts, that is. Either that or legally mandate interoperability so that we can move to a federated social media landscape to encourage genuine innovation and competition. We need the global equivalent of the ITU but for social media.
Amazon are scary but that's only because they are bad-ass. If they break the law, fine. If it turns out in a decade that it hasn't been possible to unseat or challenge the enormous tech incumbents with FOSS challenges then maybe we ought to take a serious look at the economics, social dynamics, and network effects involved.
edit: clarity
edit ii: could people who have downvoted my comment explain why please?
- s_Hogg 7y agoThere's an implicit assumption in this argument that the law as it stands is fine and not in need of changes itself.
- igravious 7y agoThere are interesting differences between US, Chinese, and European anti-trust/anti-monopoly laws. You make a very good point that we should consider if the current legal need changing. Definitely something is broken if Facebook can acquire not just Instagram but WhatsApp as well. One or both of those deals should have been blocked by regulators on at least one side of the Atlantic. And there's an argument to be made that Microsoft should not have been allowed to buy Skype.
- pgcj_poster 7y ago> In the end Microsoft's OS gained proper competition through the paradigm shift of FOSS, specifically with Linux. Are you sure? Microsoft's monopoly was mostly on desktop PC operating systems, and almost all desktops are still running Windows. Most people have never heard of Gnu/Linux and wouldn't want or even know how to install it if they had. MacOS is exclusive to one luxury brand, and I really don't see it much outside of developers and college students.
- igravious 7y agoAt least there's genuine-ish choice now. Chromebooks, Apple desktops and laptops, Linux desktops and laptops. Not to mention that Windows has stiff competition in the server space. But I take your point.
- basch 7y agoI think its a correct statement if you see Android/Chrome as having displaced Windows/IE as the way the majority of the word consumes the Internet/Web.
- pgcj_poster 7y agoSure, but the fact that the desktop became less important compared with mobile/web doesn't actually solve the problem of Microsoft having a monopoly on PC operating systems. Gnu/Linux is almost unusable for non-techies, not because it's deficient, but because almost all third-party software and hardware is built with Windows in mind, because that's what people get when they buy a computer. In a well-functioning market, all you would have to do to beat Microsoft would be to make a better operating system. In the current market, to beat Microsoft, you have to make a better operating system, target a new category of device, and own one of the biggest companies and several of the biggest websites in the world.