3 ms·
You're right about the need for hard evidence to back up unsubstantiated medical claims. Sometimes crooked doctors actually make fake diagnoses of bone spurs as
by DonHopkins 7y ago
You're right about the need for hard evidence to back up unsubstantiated medical claims. Sometimes crooked doctors actually make fake diagnoses of bone spurs as favors to their draft-dodging patients.
https://eu.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/onpolitics/2018/12/27/trump-vietnam-war-bone-spur-diagnosis/2420475002/ https://eu.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/onpolitics/2018/...
- wizzairflyer 7y agoTwo things puzzle me each time a public figure is shamed for draft dodging the Vietnam war: 1. In the end the guy didn't do less for the country that every women who "draft dodged" thanks to their sex. In those times of equality, I feel like this should be taken into account before shaming someone who basically just lost the dice roll. 2. The Vietnam war seems to be widely disliked by the left, yet Democrats are quick to forget their disapproval of the war when it comes to shaming Trump.
- sfkdjf9j3j 7y agoThe criticism doesn't come from avoiding the draft, it comes from avoiding the draft and then filling his administration with hawks.
- mgkimsal 7y agoor perhaps from avoiding the draft, then making regular public criticism of the military service of opponents.
- DonHopkins 7y agoAnd perhaps also from abusing their privilege as extremely rich real estate owners who wouldn't let black people (who can't afford to dodge the draft) live in their buildings. And also for lying about having bone spurs, when the women who "dodged" the draft weren't actually lying about their gender, but were actually just following the law of the land. And for having a long track record and infamous career of discriminating against blacks and women; and for relentlessly questioning which country a black president was born in, as well as his very legitimacy; and for unceasingly criticizing, even after his death, a war hero who actually did fight for his country and spent a great deal of time as a prisoner of war.
- wizzairflyer 7y agoI'm just focusing on the draft dodger treatment here, the rest of Trump character can be criticized very well without relying on the draft dodging card. See my response to danso for why I think draft dodging should get this kind of treatment. And again, I'm not blaming the women for following the law of the land, I'm merely highlighting the disputable fairness of the law of the land of the time and how it might be used as a way to justify dodging, especially given the context of the war.
- danso 7y agoWomen didn’t dodge the draft. They were never eligible for it. And maybe your recall of American history differs from mine, but women weren’t calling the shots in U.S. government 50 years ago.
- wizzairflyer 7y agoI am not blaming the women for not having served. What I wanted to highlight with the "draft dodge" between quotes is that the reason they weren't drafted is as void as pretending that you had bone spurs, from a modern progressive standpoint. I'll concede that women didn't have a lot of representation back in the day, but so did a lot of the men required to serve. And they nonetheless did have the right to vote, so they do share part of the collective responsibility for the behaviour of elected politicians. From a modern, progressive point of view, it seems obvious that if you are going to require people to serve then everyone should serve, regardless of race, gender or social status. This was not the case during the Vietnam era, and I think that draft dodging should thus be seen more as civil disobedience than something shameful. However, the framing it is given when used to shame politicians by progressive outlets such as the NYT is far from that, I think it is hypocritical to fight for equality yet fail to recognize how young men, and young men alone, were buried under this obligation.
- danso 7y ago> the reason they weren't drafted is as void as pretending that you had bone spurs Women weren't drafted because the government didn't mandate it. Trump avoided the draft by receiving a questionable diagnosis from a doctor. > and I think that draft dodging should thus be seen more as civil disobedience than something shameful And yet, they are not the same thing, because civil disobedience is a protest against the government, and ultimately accepting the consequences. President Trump does not claim his efforts at getting deferred and exempted were an act of protest against the war. Furthermore, he goes on to mock those who he deems to have performed inadequately during the Vietnam War, notably Senators McCain [0] and Blumenthal. It's possible for people to hate the Vietnam War, support equality, and condemn the hypocrisy of a jingoistic commander-in-chief. It's really amazing how you see these stances as mutually exclusive, even within an overly simplistic worldview. [0] https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2016-election/hes-not-war-hero-donald-trump-mocks-john-mccains-service-n394391 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2016-election/hes-not-war-h... [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/27/trump-berates-da-nang-dick-blumenthal-for-vietnam-military-record.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/27/trump-berates-da-nang-dick-b...
- chachachoney 7y ago>> Two things puzzle me each time a public figure is shamed for draft dodging the Vietnam war What exactly does this have to do with the article or the discussion at hand?
- dang 7y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20490344 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20490344 and marked it off-topic.