6 ms·
A Chapter from the FBI's History with OpenBSD and an OpenSSH Vuln
- sverige 7y agoSo, nothing about the 2010 claims, but something maybe, not sure what, back in 2002? Only two remote holes in a heck of a long time!
- Fnoord 7y agoIndeed, IPsec isn't mentioned. (You can use WireGuard on OpenBSD nowadays.) If you remember the OpenSSH Challenge Response vulnerability was found by ISS in 2002. OpenBSD's advisory can be found here [1] This was the first remote vulnerability found in OpenBSD's default installation (which they used to advertise with). Back then, it was very normal to have all kind of bloated daemons enabled by default and vulnerabilities were found in C code and were easily exploited (no ASLR, on x86-32 for example). Of particular interest is "section 6. Release Process" because it has details about how the OpenBSD team dealt with the situation at that time. Also, the patches are from 26 june 2002. Now, if you look at [2] (source of FOIA documents), you can notice the date is 14 august 2002. This indicates the FBI's document is made after the vulnerability was known to the public. What are the indications that the FBI knew about this beforehand? Is that the part listed on the bottom where they say contact X has administrative control over the internet host cvs.openbsd.org and Y has administrative control over the internet host ftp.openbsd.org? We don't know who these people were, who they worked for. I remember there being some kind of feud between OpenBSD team and Grsecurity/PaX team (Brad Spengler aka Spender and a Hungarian I suppose by the nickname pipops). I always wondered about the relation of these, and the blackhat community. Who were these people with the gobble gobble memes, and the "Theo why is syslog running on port 514 I want to see SSH and nothing else"? [1] https://www.openssh.com/txt/preauth.adv https://www.openssh.com/txt/preauth.adv [2] https://cdn.muckrock.com/foia_files/2019/07/19/Ecd74aeb090e009e1ede26e1a0fe860c184bb6797_Q52218_R348013_D2256726.pdf https://cdn.muckrock.com/foia_files/2019/07/19/Ecd74aeb090e0...
- sverige 7y agoProbably Contact X is Theo, and Contact Y is Bob Beck. Or vice versa. There's no reason to think otherwise, unless of course we're going to revisit conspiracy theories like the bullshit claims about NSA backdoors from 2010. But OpenBSD has always been a magnet for trolls.
- ryacko 7y agoIsn’t it in the government’s best interests to have a non-adversarial relationship with a community? The government does have plenty of tools for writing correct code. OpenSSH was written with available tools, if available tools to write correct code weren’t used, there’d be very little burden for anyone to make an accusation. >Currently, most Commercial Off-the-Shelf (COTS) software contains about one to five bugs per thousand lines of code. >DARPA created the Crowd Sourced Formal Verification (CSFV) program to overcome these challenges. (The above was a project that led to formal verifications that wasn’t open sourced)
- fmajid 7y agoThe government is not a monolithic entity, but a nexus of competing agendas, and not only does the right hand not know what the left hand is doing, but they may well be working at cross-purposes. This is true of any organization beyond a few dozen people.
- ryacko 7y agoYes, inaction is only evidence of nonfeasance when a person fails to perform an action aligned with their duties or stated interests. The government does have competing duties and stated interests, so there is no evidence of nonfeasance or malfeasance on the part of OpenBSD or on the part of the government in this case.
- sverige 7y agoOpenBSD is based in Canada. It ships with cryptography. It does not accept contributions to its cryptography code from Americans, specifically because of the ridiculous cryptography export ban the U.S. had in place in the 90s. https://www.openbsd.org/crypto.html https://www.openbsd.org/crypto.html Of course, if that sort of thing is what you're looking for, there's always SELinux. https://selinuxproject.org/page/Main_Page https://selinuxproject.org/page/Main_Page
- wil421 7y agoThe link in the tweet is worth a read[1]. >My NDA with the FBI has recently expired, and I wanted to make you aware of the fact that the FBI implemented a number of backdoors and side channel key leaking mechanisms into the OCF, for the express purpose of monitoring the site to site VPN encryption system implemented by EOUSA, the parent organization to the FBI. Jason Wright and several other developers were responsible for those backdoors, and you would be well advised to review any and all code commits by Wright as well as the other developers he worked with originating from NETSEC. [1]https://marc.info/?l=openbsd-tech&m=129236621626462 https://marc.info/?l=openbsd-tech&m=129236621626462
- ProCicero 7y agoNitpicking here, but the parent agency of the FBI is the Department of Justice. The EOUSA is the Executive Office of United States Attorneys, and is basically the back office support for the 93 US Attorney offices. It's parent organization is also the Department of Justice. Basically, he is saying the DOJ planted a back door so that it could spy on its own internal network.
- wil421 7y agoI was confused by this and it’s the first time I’ve heard of EOUSA. What’s the real story here?
- equalunique 7y agoFactions in government are sometimes caught spying on gov organizations that have oversight/control athority over them. That was the real scandal of Edward Snowden's bombshell (that was quickly covered up).
- tinus_hn 7y agoThat’s almost 10 years ago. Was the backdoor ever found?
- tptacek 7y ago
- Rastarbar 7y ago‘one former FBI computer security agent has confirmed parts of Perry’s story. .. "I was one of the few FBI cyber agents when the coding supposedly happened. Experiment yes. Success No,"’ E J Hilbert FBI https://web.archive.org/web/20170823064610/https://www.v3.co.uk/v3-uk/news/1989462/contractor-claims-fbi-installed-backdoors-openbsd-crypto https://web.archive.org/web/20170823064610/https://www.v3.co...
- sslalready 7y agoThere’s nothing that suggests that those experiments had anything to do with OpenBSD.