3 ms·
The app is closed source? Hard pass. Unless you know the data is being securely encrypted client-side, there is no way someone in a sensitive targeted group sho
by nerdponx 7y ago
The app is closed source? Hard pass. Unless you know the data is being securely encrypted client-side, there is no way someone in a sensitive targeted group should make it known that they have this app, let alone upload personal contact information to a server somewhere.
The organization behind it looks legit enough, but that doesn't stop one guy with a USB stick from exfiltrating the whole database.
- cyphar 7y agoEven if the app encrypts everything client-side and does everything over Tor, just having the app installed on your phone (which both Google Play and the Apple App Store track) is sufficient to make you look suspicious from that point of view. Really, what you'd need is a very popular app to add a feature like this so that the percentage of users of the app that are potentially undocumented immigrants is the same as their proportion of the population. Then you do all the other crypto and hopefully don't store whether individual users have the feature enabled.
- nerdponx 7y agoI also feel like "contact these 5 people in case I get detained" is a more general use case that could dilute the "target pool" more. Journalists, sex workers, hackers, etc.