4 ms·
Sounds insurmountable. That said, in the context of the 50th anniversary of Apollo 11, this feels like there are far more knowns than unknowns. Think of it thi
by chiefalchemist 7y ago
Sounds insurmountable. That said, in the context of the 50th anniversary of Apollo 11, this feels like there are far more knowns than unknowns.
Think of it this way. JFK laid out a challenge that in retrospect amounted to "Here's a iPhone. Go put us on the moon. Soon!"
THAT was madness. Redistribution of some water* - even at this scale - is more Mercury than Apollo. It seems it might be us who now knows too much to be crazy enough to try. That's a shame.
* On a daily basis we redistribute a massive amount of oil. So there is a reference point in terms of volume / scale.
- Retric 7y agoThe are talking about moving over 100x times as much water per year as we move oil. Further, it’s only going to freeze during winter adding even more time constraints. Just desalination of this much water would cost ~5 trillion dollars in the US. Doing this in the Antarctic winter would probably double that if not more.
- chiefalchemist 7y ago"The are talking about moving over 100x times as much water per year as we move oil." > Fair enough. But 100x still isn't a moon shot. "Just desalination of this much water would cost ~5 trillion dollars in the US." > Perhaps. But what is the cost of NOT doing it? 2x? 3x? 5x? 10x? Long to short. if it were easy we would have done it already. Therefore, I have to believe the next steps are going to be hard, harder, and perhaps hardest (i.e., greater than going to the moon on the back of an iPhone).
- Retric 7y agoThe only impact of not doing this is less sea level rise. The ocean is still going to rise significantly, thus the savings is likely less than the 10++ trillion this would cost. Remember, this is also not a long term solution, it would need to be repeated over time.
- trehalose 7y agoHow do you figure that not doing this would cause less sea level rise? The article states that proceeding with this plan might slow sea level rise to nearly one-third of its current rate: > To put that into context, removing that much seawater from the ocean would lower global sea level by about 2 millimeters per year. Current total sea level rise is a little over 3 millimeters per year, so it would be like nearly halting sea level rise… by bailing water out of the ocean. We can call that a bonus positive. On what grounds do you dispute this? I'm not saying you're wrong (I'm too uneducated in the relevant fields to know that), I'd just like to know your rationale?
- Retric 7y agoPoor use of double negative. I mean you are not going actually fix global temperate, weather patterns, ocean acidification etc. It’s benefits are simply going to be limited to stuff very near the ocean, and when you start talking trillions of dollars that builds a lot of structures.