4 ms·
How ancient Rome's concrete has survived that long can probably be attributed to one main factor: no inclusion of steel rebar.
by kazinator 7y ago
How ancient Rome's concrete has survived that long can probably be attributed to one main factor: no inclusion of steel rebar.
- jbay808 7y agoIn case anyone mistakes this for a summary of the article, here's what it actually says: > Modern cement mixtures tend to erode, particularly in the presence of seawater, but the Roman recipe of volcanic ash, lime, seawater and a mineral called aluminium tobermorite actually reinforces the concrete and prevents cracks from expanding, researchers found.
- aswanson 7y agoRaises an interesting question: how long can modern bridges last, given they consist mostly of steel?
- jacobush 7y agoThe worst is when you combine materials who age differently or respond to temperature swings differently. If that steel bridge can be kept from rusting, it can keep a long time.
- petre 7y agoAlso steel has an endurance limit where material fatigue plateaus.
- sokoloff 7y agoWhat’s way stranger to me is that aluminum does not have an endurance limit (for non-Mech E’s, this is worse for aluminum even though it sounds like it might be better).
- namibj 7y agoBasically, there is no deformation so miniscule that it lasts forever. It just affects how many cycles/how long it takes. Steel however, if you deform it only very little, lasts practically forever. You just need to design it to not deform too much at normal operation. Incidentally, this fatigue vs. approaching the strength limit issue is why airplanes have limited flights. The fuselage/hull is made to last long enough, but not necessarily do well longer than that.
- aswanson 7y agoOver hundreds of years...it can't. The question remains, how long does that time span extend? 200 years? 300? A millenia? Could the Brooklyn or Ben Franklin Bridge last that long? Even the next 70 or so?
- wil421 7y agoIn my part of the country there are mostly concrete bridges. My father in law started his construction career at a bridge building company. A lot of concrete bridge spans are hollow with styrofoam inside. It would be too heavy if it was solid.
- gitgud 7y agoThat's probably true, steel rebar has the issue of rusting and cracking the concrete. But the advantage rebar gives you is a gradual failure mode, where the steel holds the block together while the concrete cracks. Without rebar, the failure of concrete is usually catastrophic (instant).
- darkpuma 7y agoThe alternative to rebar is making sure your structure is under compression with negligible tension.
- njarboe 7y agoIf your building site never has earthquakes, that can work well. Otherwise an earthquake might put some part of the structure under tension and cause it to fail.
- darkpuma 7y agoThe solution to that is to build it bigger with a wider footprint. Obviously this is an expensive way to build, but if you engineer it right (and throw enough concrete at it) you can create structures with nearly arbitrary shake resistance. (Think of how hard you'd have to shake the Great Pyramid of Giza to make it collapse. That's not concrete obviously, but it too is under compression almost entirely, except for the corbel and lintel ceilings. The proper arches used in Roman concrete construction show that with the right engineering you can push unreinforced concrete pretty damn far. The Pantheon is probably the most impressive example of it. Compare how well it's withstood earthquakes with the Colosseum.)
- primis 7y agoThe Pyramids actually did experience earthquakes, knocked off the limestone facades that eventually ended up being moved and used to build mosques in the area. https://www.thevintagenews.com/2016/09/06/the-great-pyramid-of-giza-was-once-covered-in-highly-polished-white-limestone-before-it-was-removed-to-build-mosques-and-fortresses/ https://www.thevintagenews.com/2016/09/06/the-great-pyramid-...
- bsder 7y agoThe Romans used lead(Pb) for rebar. The reason why the Collosseum fell is that everybody removed it's lead rebar because it was worth money when Rome fell--without that lead rebar in the joints, every earthquake knocked a bit more off the building. The Romans lived in an active fault zone and understood building to survive earthquakes.
- true_tuna 7y agoAlso a self-healing saltwater friendly reaction. But keeping the rebar out is necessary as well.