3 ms·
"Its very expensive to fill a rental. A landlord usually needs at least a month to find another tenant. That's a month of foregone rent" If a month of foregone
by pmoriarty 7y ago
"Its very expensive to fill a rental. A landlord usually needs at least a month to find another tenant. That's a month of foregone rent"
If a month of foregone rent was such a huge burden to landlords then it wouldn't be so common for them to keep their properties vacant.
Just recently, Los Angeles lawmakers have proposed a vacancy tax on the 111,000 vacant homes in the area.[1]
[1] - https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-vacant-housing-tax-rental-homeless-crisis-20190611-story.html https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-vacant-housing-...
- graeme 7y agoThat doesn’t establish how common vacancy rates are. You need to look at the rate, not the number. And politicians passing a law means nothing about the fundamentals: you’d need to know if the law is well targeted, or instead perverse. Do you have any data on how long properties are vacant? And if they’re vacant, are they vacant for a reason like renovations or construction? Every landlord I’ve ever had has wanted to rent their place quickly. They hate missing a month.
- LargeWu 7y agoWe had to rent our former home for 4 years after we moved, but couldn't sell because the market value was too low after the real estate crash. It's really hard to find tenants that aren't total deadbeats. Raise your rent and it's almost impossible to fill the vacancy. Lower the rent and get nothing but unqualified applicants with terrible credit and criminal records. So sure, maybe I could lower the rent to get someone in there, but that means there's a high chance they'll either a) not pay their rent, b) damage the property, or c) both.
- sdenton4 7y agoGreat! If you can't fill the spot to your liking, you should get out of the game. Sell to someone who needs a place to live, or is comfortable lowering rents and dealing with the work load.
- jiminy_john 7y agospoken like a real champ! You show'em! to those fat cats!!!
- toomuchtodo 7y agoThe other option is to simply default and walk away from the property if you can't find a tenant, and you can't afford to eat the loss of selling it.
- coredog64 7y agoNot every US state is a non-recourse state.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoSpeaking from experience, you can still default in a recourse state with little consequence.
- LargeWu 7y ago"Sell to someone who needs a place to live" This would have required me to take a huge loss on the property, which I would have had to pay out of pocket, to the tune of tens of thousands of dollars, which I did not have. I would have preferred to never rent at all.
- bko 7y agoI think vacancy rates in some metropolitan areas increased primarily due to rent control, rent stabilization, tenant rights or the risk of future legislation. If you can't raise rents, you'd be less likely to react to lower market rents. So prices stay sticky on the way down. Even if the laws are not in place now, there is a risk of them being in place in the near future and you'll be stuck at below market rents. Also if you can't remove tenants then you'd be more selective and naturally that would increase vacancy rates. A high vacancy rate doesn't prove that its not expensive to fill a rental. In fact higher vacancy rates means losing a tenant is even greater than if there were low vacancy rates. That means that an empty apartment is going to stay on the market even longer. And most landlords have some debt arrangement, are paying interest, taxes and insurance in addition to forgoing rental income.
- BeetleB 7y ago>If a month of foregone rent was such a huge burden to landlords then it wouldn't be so common for them to keep their properties vacant. Landlords estimate a vacancy rate and keep that amount in reserves. However, they all earn more money if it's not vacant. It's almost never the case that they can make more money by keeping the rent high and units vacant. Also, is they are using a property management company (which surprisingly many do), then turnovers are likely more expensive for the landlord than the tenant's cost to move - they usually charge 50% of one month's rent to find a new tenant for you. If they're too optimistic in that vacancy rate, they will lose money. For anyone thinking landlords have all the power, hang out on real estate forums. After all expenses (including vacancy), most RE investors target $100-200/month per unit. Now often, over several years, if rents shoot up in the city, they'll make good money from the increased rent. But they don't rely on that - their usual hope is the property's value will go up so they can sell it one day. The landlords who make huge piles of money are outliers. The vast majority of landlords do not make anything close to a SV SW developer and are not aiming to (of course, though, whatever they do make is almost "free", which makes the difference to them). The top skill for a landlord is to estimate costs. At $100-200/unit, if they underestimate a lot, they are out of business. Surprisingly, most do not carry vandalism insurance. So if a disgruntled tenant trashes a place, they could easily lose the property. If they do not reserve money for evictions, they could easily lose the property.
- pmoriarty 7y ago"It's almost never the case that they can make more money by keeping the rent high and units vacant." Unless they can hold out until property values rise and they can sell for a profit.
- BeetleB 7y ago>Unless they can hold out until property values rise and they can sell for a profit. Sure, if they've got piles of cash sitting around to pay for the loan, insurance and real estate taxes. Here's another tidbit people don't understand. If the property has more than 4 units, the value of the property is determined almost entirely by the revenue it generates.[1][2] The bank who will provide the loan to the buyer will look at those numbers, and the buyer will look at those numbers. In particular, what people will not look at are the comps (the value of nearby properties). So a "Let's lose money until the property values go up" strategy won't work there. [1] https://theresabradleybanta.com/value-a-multi-unit-property/ https://theresabradleybanta.com/value-a-multi-unit-property/ [2] https://www.biggerpockets.com/blog/2016-07-06-multifamily-real-estate-value https://www.biggerpockets.com/blog/2016-07-06-multifamily-re...
- RHSeeger 7y agoThere's a difference between landlords in places with extreme property value inflation... and the rest of the world.