4 ms·
Lockheed enlarged their original concept, reducing the power density (counting the volume of the reactor, not just the plasma) by a factor of 100. It's now abo
by pfdietz 7y ago
Lockheed enlarged their original concept, reducing the power density (counting the volume of the reactor, not just the plasma) by a factor of 100. It's now about 0.5 MW/m^3, about the same as MIT's ARC concept.
In contrast, the power density of a PWR primary reactor vessel is 20 MW/m^3 (and of the core alone, 100 MW/m^3). How exactly is fusion supposed to be cheaper than this, when the reactors are both so much larger and so much more complex? Saving on fuel is irrelevant, as fuel is only a small part of the cost of running a fission reactor.
- pcl 7y agoWhat’s meaningful about power density as a metric for reactors?
- pfdietz 7y agoPower density determines size (for a given power output), which is strongly correlated with cost. Simply put, larger machines are more expensive than smaller ones. And cost is the showstopper for fusion, not the comparatively shallower issues of plasma physics.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- IanCal 7y agoCost also rapidly translates iteration time too. The bigger you get, the more expensive it is and the more you need larger groups or collaborations, which means more politics. If you can shrink the reactor enough you can go from requiring governments to work together to just needing a single company.
- evancox100 7y agoI'd assume it's a decent proxy for cost. It would also be an important metric for mobile reactor usage
- hanniabu 7y agoYou're not just saving on fuel, you're saving on waste
- tlb 7y agoAnd safety. Fusion has the enormous advantage that you can just switch it off, without the core continuing to generate heat and causing a meltdown if the cooling system fails. 0.5 MW capacity costs around $1M with solar, so if 0.5 MW of fusion power takes up a cubic meter that doesn't seem like a deal breaker.
- pfdietz 7y agoThe argument involves the comparison with fission. The low power density means it's going to be more expensive than fission, and fission already fails economically. The difference between fission and solar is that solar lacks many systems (like, turbines and generators) that fission and fusion would need. More fundamentally, solar is distributed (even on a large solar farm), so there's a lack of coupling between elements that makes everything easy to assemble and very fault tolerant. In fission and fusion plants, the intricate dependencies mean everything has to be highly reliable. Safety (for fission) and the extreme difficulty of repair of activated structures (for fusion) also drive this very expensive reliability.
- bassman9000 7y agoThe argument involves the comparison with fission. With the current LWR/HWR fission reactors, where core is solid.
- nine_k 7y ago> switch it off, without the core continuing to generate heat and causing a meltdown A number of fission designs have this property, too. Most operational fission reactors are from 1960s to 1980s, and indeed are capable of a meltdown.
- pfdietz 7y ago