7 ms·
Am I the only one that wants their browser to be 100% stateless? I always run in incognito mode, and I have an external password manager. I have no problems w
by hedora 7y ago
Am I the only one that wants their browser to be 100% stateless? I always run in incognito mode, and I have an external password manager. I have no problems with this setup except sites that detect and block incognito mode.
Other than caching, there is no legitimate benefit to allow pages to store local state beyond a session, and I can forgo caching at this point in the game. (I don’t care about offline web apps, to be clear)
Maintaining a whitelist of sites that can have session state would be trivial (the sites in my password manager are a great first cut). I don’t want to restart my browser periodically to clear everything else’s session state.
How hard would it be to build something like this?
- SimeVidas 7y agoWhat’s your motivation for doing this? Btw, I store my passwords in Firefox Sync. What would the benefit be of storing them in a third-party password manager, from a security and privacy perspective?
- hermanradtke 7y agoTo make the browser stateless and, thus, harder to track.
- SimeVidas 7y agoDo you use any form of tracking protection (either as a built-in browser feature or via browser extensions)?
- nsajko 7y ago> What’s your motivation for doing this? Maybe he, like me, just thinks there is no reason for history, form data, cookies and all that stuff to be saved after starting a new browser instance, except in rare circumstances. > What would the benefit be of storing them in a third-party password manager Decoupling, less dependance on a specific browser. "Unix philosphy".
- zrobotics 7y agoA concrete example of why a 3rd party pw manager is useful- git(hub/lab) credentials. On both sites, I can easily want to enter account credentials in a terminal as well as the browser. Not every password will exclusively be used in the browser, and 3rd party managers are handier outside the browser.
- nsajko 7y agoI, too, almost always use Chromium so it is basically stateless (except when I want bookmarks). My way is better than Incognito mode because you can have multiple sessions (example: one for Google's services that require a login, one for Stack Exchange, one for browsing); and of course because it can not be detected, unlike Incognito mode. Take a look at my comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20484845 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20484845
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoWhat do you do for sites that complain each session you're using an "unrecognized browser" and require additional forms of authentication? Just deal with it every single session?
- nsajko 7y agoI assume by additional forms of authentication you mean codes sent over either email or SMS? Email is not a bother to deal with, because one can just copy the code over from the email; while phone SMS is not an issue because I did not confirm my phone number to any Web services. (For example, I think Paypal asks me to "confirm" my phone number every time I log in, even though Paypal knows the number is mine it is probably bound by regulation or law not to force multi-factor-authentication on me. So, just say no when asked about confirming your phone number.) Do you have an example of a site that requires "additional forms of authentication"? I remember something like that happening to me before, but I can not remember which site it happened on.
- nine_k 7y agoMany sites ask for your phone just to simplify the "forgot my credentials, help me" customer support calls. Some, especially money-related, want to know your phone as a separate confirmation of your state-controlled identity, in countries where buying a SIM card required legal identification (which likely can be retrieved by a court order if need be). Yes, SMS can easily be diverted so it's not great for 2FA purposes; a voice call is often an option, and is harder to spoof. Sites that actually care about your security would go for things like TOTP, or SSH key, or a certificate. These forms do not map easily to your legal identity, but are more reliable proofs of knowing a secret.
- _underfl0w_ 7y agoDoesn't using Chromium in the first place kinda defeat the purpose? I mean, you'll thwart others' tracking with your methods (though you made no mention of blocking tracking scripts/images which is a huge piece) but you're still handing data directly to Google.
- nsajko 7y agoYou can turn that off in the settings.
- Kaiyou 7y agoThere's a setting, but it doesn't really prevent anything. You're still tracked.
- vunie 7y agoThis reminds me of firefox's telemetry for people who turn off telemetry [1]. None of the big three browsers respect your privacy enough to not track you in any way. Not a single one. Here's to hoping that a browser that truly respects its users appears soon. [1] https://www.ghacks.net/2018/09/21/mozilla-wants-to-estimate-firefoxs-telemetry-off-population/ https://www.ghacks.net/2018/09/21/mozilla-wants-to-estimate-...
- jammygit 7y agoBetter to use brave maybe? Or Firefox?
- torgard 7y agoYou could use ungoogled-chromium to circumvent the Google-parts.
- milofeynman 7y agoI'd like every single tab to be stateless which I believe Firefox has an end goal of with containers
- jammygit 7y agoIf you assume (big ask) that your browser is trustworthy and your computer won’t be compromised, it’s nice to have bookmarks, history, and a password manager built in.
- diminoten 7y agoI guess what benefits do you get out of that, and at what cost? I just don't see the amount of privacy I give up worth losing the convenience of the features.
- ShakataGaNai 7y agoOn HackerNews? You're probably not the only one. In the world of real users? You're probably the extreme minority. Most people want convenience, and will trade almost anything for it. Especially if they don't realize they are trading something like "privacy" or "trackability" for convenience.
- nsajko 7y agoWhy do you try to imply that a Web browser experience not built around making the user trackable most effectively, like it is by default with the big browsers, has to be inconvenient? The way I use Chromium [0], is very convenient to me. The downsides are almost nonexistent, and the upsides are not just in privacy: it is convenient (albeit perhaps of questionable morality?) to not have to worry about newspaper article quotas; likewise with having more control over cookies and other browser data in the "simultaneous multiple sessions" model. For example having more than one user logged in to some Web site does not take any extra effort compared to just one user being logged in. On the other hand there is a difference between "real users" and those willing to exploit the Unix programming environment/interface to its full potential, and that is required knowledge, or the willingness to get it. For example to use my script tb effectively one has to understand that "being logged in with a Web site" means temporarily storing appropriate data chunks gotten from the Web site (cookies) so that they are accessible to the browser and it could send them back to the server to authenticate. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20484845 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20484845
- elefanten 7y agoYou answered your own question. The vast majority of users are not "willing to exploit the Unix programming environment." For the vast majority of people who do not already have Unix skills (or whatever), it is convenient not to have to learn them.
- baybal2 7y ago> Most people want convenience, and will trade almost anything for it. No, this is what indoctrinated "UX" people think. I hear it every day from ordinary office workers how sick they are from dysfunctional, progressively dumbed down UIs. Ask just how many people keep MS Office 2003 just because they can't use the "ribbon" UI.
- nessunodoro 7y agoDo you use Firefox multi-account containers? https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/multi-account-containers/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/multi-account... It's the biggest reason I use Firefox. Intuitive, straightforward session partitioning. Every browser should have it.
- JaRail 7y agoDo you use two-factor authentication? Staying logged in with the same trusted browser/device is a big benefit for security. It makes it a lot easier for companies to spot suspicious login attempts.
- Shacklz 7y agoNot the only one - there are probably dozens of us :) I use Firefox for this purpose, not in private mode - I just let FF delete everything whenever I close it. It's not "100% stateless", as I still allow cookies and such while my browser is open (I use uBlock and Privacy-Badger to block out the worst), but whenever I close the browser I still have a "clean slate" whenever I reopen it. There are definitely a few downsides (as much as I love the GDPR, the compliance banners are annoying), but together with a password manager, it's definitely a setup that works for me.
- fghtr 7y ago>Am I the only one that wants their browser to be 100% stateless? I achieved it by using Disposable Virtual Machines in Qubes OS. Works flawlessly.
- ViViDboarder 7y agoThat definitely exists on mobile. I use FF Focus, which just clears the entire session as soon as you close the window. Also, on iOS Safari and Firefox can be defaulted to private browsing. On desktop, Firefox can be configured to clear all cookies and site data whenever it is closed.
- londons_explore 7y agoIf lots of people did this, websites would start saying "sorry, you can only enter this website if you have cookies that are at least a month old"