8 ms·
> Unfortunately, rent control will have the opposite effect of what Oregon thinks, and only make housing scarcity worse. It depends on the kind of rent control
by wpietri 7y ago
> Unfortunately, rent control will have the opposite effect of what Oregon thinks, and only make housing scarcity worse.
It depends on the kind of rent control. Housing has important asymmetries it's reasonable to address through legislation. One is asymmetry in scale: you have one unit; landlords have many more. This gives them stronger negotiating power. Another is cost of change. It's much more expensive for me in time and money to move than it is for a landlord turn over a new unit. That means a landlord can extract money well above a true market rate. A third is of interest. Individuals and the community have a interest in healthy social bonds, while absentee lords mainly want to extract cash.
I understand free-market fundamentalists hate all rent control, but Oregon's rent control laws are designed to preserve incentives to construct new housing: https://www.npr.org/2019/02/27/698509957/oregon-set-to-pass-the-first-statewide-rent-control-bill https://www.npr.org/2019/02/27/698509957/oregon-set-to-pass-...
The first 15 years of a new building are free from rent control, and after that they can increase rent at 7% above CPI, meaning in real terms rents can still double circa every 10 years. And if a tenant moves out, landlords can raise rents as much as they like.
For this to affect construction today, a builder would have to be betting on a very tight market continuing unabated during the 2035-2045 period. But that's a ridiculous bet to make, rent control laws or not. Anybody building new housing will want to be sure the economics work if rent increases return to their long-term average, which is well below 7% above CPI: https://www.apartmentlist.com/rentonomics/rent-growth-since-1960/ https://www.apartmentlist.com/rentonomics/rent-growth-since-...
- bko 7y ago> It depends on the kind of rent control. Housing has important asymmetries it's reasonable to address through legislation. One is asymmetry in scale: you have one unit; landlords have many more. Not necessarily true. Sure , the landlord knows more about the apartment but you know more about yourself as a tenant. Landlord takes a huge risk in terms of allowing someone rent, especially given protections afforded to that individual. Most experienced landlord will cite tenant selection as very important and a huge risk. One tenant that refuses to pay rent or damages property can wipe out the return of 9 other units. > This gives them stronger negotiating power. I have more options as to where to move. The landlord owns a very expensive illiquid property. He can't just sell it tomorrow but I could easily choose another rental. > Another is cost of change. It's much more expensive for me in time and money to move than it is for a landlord turn over a new unit. Its very expensive to fill a rental. A landlord usually needs at least a month to find another tenant. That's a month of foregone rent > That means a landlord can extract money well above a true market rate. Market rate is the rate the landlord can get. If a transaction happens at that rate, that's the market rate. > A third is of interest. Individuals and the community have a interest in healthy social bonds, while absentee lords mainly want to extract cash. Not sure what "absentee lords mainly want to extract cash" means. Yes, most landlords manage properties as an investment. Landlords also have an interest in the community as they own equity in that community that would appreciate if the neighborhood gets nicer. I don't see your point.
- pmoriarty 7y ago"Its very expensive to fill a rental. A landlord usually needs at least a month to find another tenant. That's a month of foregone rent" If a month of foregone rent was such a huge burden to landlords then it wouldn't be so common for them to keep their properties vacant. Just recently, Los Angeles lawmakers have proposed a vacancy tax on the 111,000 vacant homes in the area.[1] [1] - https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-vacant-housing-tax-rental-homeless-crisis-20190611-story.html https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-vacant-housing-...
- graeme 7y agoThat doesn’t establish how common vacancy rates are. You need to look at the rate, not the number. And politicians passing a law means nothing about the fundamentals: you’d need to know if the law is well targeted, or instead perverse. Do you have any data on how long properties are vacant? And if they’re vacant, are they vacant for a reason like renovations or construction? Every landlord I’ve ever had has wanted to rent their place quickly. They hate missing a month.
- LargeWu 7y agoWe had to rent our former home for 4 years after we moved, but couldn't sell because the market value was too low after the real estate crash. It's really hard to find tenants that aren't total deadbeats. Raise your rent and it's almost impossible to fill the vacancy. Lower the rent and get nothing but unqualified applicants with terrible credit and criminal records. So sure, maybe I could lower the rent to get someone in there, but that means there's a high chance they'll either a) not pay their rent, b) damage the property, or c) both.
- sdenton4 7y agoGreat! If you can't fill the spot to your liking, you should get out of the game. Sell to someone who needs a place to live, or is comfortable lowering rents and dealing with the work load.
- 7y ago
- BurningFrog 7y ago> One is asymmetry in scale: you have one unit; landlords have many more. This gives them stronger negotiating power. This is one of those theoretical arguments that sounds good but have no empirical foundation at all. If it was true the gigantic Walmart could completely dick me around when buying socks and toilet paper. In reality prices are very competitive. It also completely ignores that fact that most landlords are small operations, and often the tenants are richer than their landlords.
- verall 7y agoWhat? Landlords do dick around with prices on small business owners, and Walmart has the scale to not get dicked around with. This is just another thing that helps them to be exceptionally competitive in pricing their goods. The GP was talking about real estate and it doesn't have much to do with how competitive socks and toilet paper are.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoIt’s not theoretical at all, and Walmart does dick you around, albeit indirectly. They dick around the supplier and force them to make cuts in quality to meet the price. And if Target/Amazon/Dollar General weren’t around, there’s no reason they wouldn’t increase prices and pad their margins. In a landlord situation, their cost of goods is so small that they can afford to sit on an empty apartment while prospective renters need to put a roof over their family or business.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> It’s not theoretical at all, and Walmart does dick you around, albeit indirectly. They dick around the supplier and force them to make cuts in quality to meet the price. People are aware of this, and purposely choose products that are 80% as good for 20% of the cost. Other people shop at Whole Foods and Apple. None of them is ripping you off. They all provide options that you knowingly and willfully choose over your other options. > And if Target/Amazon/Dollar General weren’t around, there’s no reason they wouldn’t increase prices and pad their margins. The comparison to landlords being that if one of them had a monopoly on local housing they could charge really high prices. But that seems pretty fantastical considering that a local housing monopoly hasn't happened basically anywhere and would presumably yield antitrust scrutiny besides. > In a landlord situation, their cost of goods is so small that they can afford to sit on an empty apartment while prospective renters need to put a roof over their family or business. The cost of goods is the cost to buy housing (and the opportunity cost of the interest you could have had on that money), plus that of maintaining the property. If that is so cheap then why is anybody renting?
- Simon_says 7y ago> you have one unit; landlords have many more You're comparing the wrong things. Negotiating power ultimately only comes from having other options. I could choose other apartments or the landlord could choose other tenants. The balance obviously depends on the individual market, but I think it's much closer to parity. > It's much more expensive for me in time and money to move than it is for a landlord turn over a new unit. I'm not so sure about this, either. It's a pain for landlords to move new tenants in, too. Most would prefer to keep good tenants around as long as possible.
- kelnos 7y agoOne of those other options for the landlord is to leave the property vacant for a time instead of renting it to you. If the landlord has only the one unit, doing so is probably a risky, undesirable option. Probably not so if they have 100 units, though.
- bassman9000 7y agoThat means a landlord can extract money well above a true market rate. The market rate IS what the landlord extracts from it, which is what the market, you, is willing to pay.
- lukejduncan 7y agoWhy is this being downvoted?
- justapassenger 7y agoBecause a lot of people lack basic financial education
- wpietri 7y agoBecause it's too simple. Market distortions shift the price people pay away from what the true market price would be in a competitive market. As an example, I live in one of the US's few competitive ISP markets. I pay $40/month for gigabit fiber, no limits. Comcast, which is often a monopoly or a duopoly, charges $90-140/month [1] for gigabit service, and they have assorted restrictions that I don't have to deal with, like data caps and limited upload speeds. So what's the true market price for full gigabit? The person you're responding to, bassman9000 would apparently say it's $140, because tautologically that's what people pay. I'd say it's much lower. Further evidence to support my position is that when you measure actual speeds delivered on gigabit, many of the ISPs are local providers, not the big nationals. [2] Customer satisfaction with my ISP is hugely higher than Comcast as well [3], with Comcast's Net Promoter Score actually being negative. [4] Those are not signs of a competitive market, and if the market isn't competitive, I think it's a 101-level mistake to say that the price people pay is the true market price. [1] https://www.cnet.com/news/comcast-offering-1-gigabit-per-second-service-to-its-entire-territory/ https://www.cnet.com/news/comcast-offering-1-gigabit-per-sec... [2] https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/7xgne9/locally-run-isps-offer-the-fastest-broadband-in-america https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/7xgne9/locally-run-isps-o... [3] https://www.sonic.com/care https://www.sonic.com/care [4] https://npsbenchmarks.com/blog/best-internet-service-providers-by-net-promoter-score https://npsbenchmarks.com/blog/best-internet-service-provide...
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> The first 15 years of a new building are free from rent control, and after that they can increase rent at 7% above CPI, meaning in real terms rents can still double circa every 10 years. And if a tenant moves out, landlords can raise rents as much as they like. There are two possibilities here. One is that the maximum rent control rate is above the market rate of housing cost increases, in which case those rent control laws do nothing. This is better than most other rent control, but still no better than no rent control. The other option is that it isn't, and then the rent control laws do something bad, i.e. reduce the incentive to build more housing to fight the expanding market rate rents, and screw new renters a lot to benefit older renters a little. There is still no circumstance where they cause good. Also, since which possibility happens isn't known ahead of time, they reduce the incentive to build housing today by landlords who expect rents to increase by a lot in the future, even if they turn out to be wrong.
- shkkmo 7y agoThat is not just wrong, but the opposite of what this law does. Since new properties have no rent control for 15 years, during any periods where market rates might reasonably be predicted to rise that much faster than the PCI, new property would be a more valuable investment than existing property (and churn in the rental market would increase as more evictions become profitable.)
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoRent control for existing properties raises market rents by encouraging existing tenants to stay even if their apartment is bigger than they need anymore and they might otherwise move to a smaller one or e.g. retire to Florida or Arizona, thereby keeping those units off the market and requiring the remaining demand to be satisfied by fewer units. Moreover, the relative value of investing in old vs. new apartments is not particularly relevant, because what really matters is the value of investing in building new housing as compared with all other alternative investments, including real estate in other cities or stocks or anything else. And the prospect of rent control at any point in the future lowers the net present value of those investments by the corresponding amount, causing reduced investment in building new housing. Worse, if the old buildings have rent control and the new ones don't, the tenants will prefer a rent controlled apartment, driving rents up in the old buildings and down in the new buildings (because, unlike investors, tenants do specifically need housing in that city so the relative difference matters), which both increases rents on existing buildings and reducing the incentive to build new buildings.
- novok 7y agoAll of this really depends on the scale of the landlord. There are many retiree types that are renting out their in-law suite or have an extra rental property and definitely cannot afford bad tenant behavior. They are probably in a worse negotiation position compared to a squatting bad tenant in those cases and very much care about their neighborhood, probably more than the renter. --- OTOH, rent control doesn't matter too much if the max percentage cap is high enough and tenants can't squat in eviction court for months as they destroy the old person's inlaw suite and their home.
- tempsy 7y agoIf you’re renting to young person or couple, there’s a better chance than not that they will voluntarily move out in a few years. And pro-construction legislation means the cap on rent will likely not mean much if you’re starting at a market rate rent today.
- monocularvision 7y agoWhile I appreciate your viewpoint, you did nothing to address the argument being made: putting restrictions on rent prices will result in less rentals available. You instead put forward a moral argument as to why we should have rent control, ignoring the real world effect the GP was claiming such a move would mean.