5 ms·
> Unfortunately, rent control will have the opposite effect of what Oregon thinks, and only make housing scarcity worse. I always found it odd that rent contro
by throw0101a 7y ago
> Unfortunately, rent control will have the opposite effect of what Oregon thinks, and only make housing scarcity worse.
I always found it odd that rent control always seems to be an all-or-nothing policy: either things are tamped down on, or it's a laissez faire system.
Does any locality have a "hybrid" approached. Something like:
* buildings 0-5 years old, allow up to 3x inflation rent increases
* buildings 5-10 years old, allow up to 2x inflation
* 10+ years old, allow only at inflation
This would (in theory?) encourage the construction of new rental units by allowing investors to recoup their costs sooner and counter the risk of any unforeseen expenses. But as the buildings get older, and costs (theoretically) become more predictable, stabilize prices for renters.
- wiremaus 7y agoA tiered system much like you describe is exactly what Oregon passed. New developments are largely unrestricted.
- yardie 7y agoI can imagine this can have a domino effect. Older buildings require more maintenance. A landlord who plans poorly may find themselves squeezed at the bottom from deferred maintenance and from the top due to rent restrictions.
- spoonie 7y agoThose landlords should go out of business in a free market. Not properly accounting for maintenance costs is a business failure, not the tenant’s fault. If property prices are higher than rents that’s a market failure, not a cost to be passed onto tenants.
- briandear 7y agoSo a landlord should be subject to the free market, but tenants shouldn’t be? Tenants should be protected from rent increases, but property owners shouldn’t be protected against cost increases? That isn’t the free market.
- jdavis703 7y agoOne way to look at this is, land owners are generally wealthier than renters. According to the Federal Reserve Survey of Consumer Finances landowners are 44 times wealthier. It makes sense that the government protects people who are less able to deal with financial instability.
- roenxi 7y agoIt makes sense, but it is also a bad idea. If someone can't afford the cost of living, they should relocate to somewhere else where they can. Western civilisation has had phenomenal results with the principle that when there isn't enough of something then the owner of that thing gets to decide who goes without. Housing is not so special that it deserves an exemption. Squeezing landlords is one of several ways to lock a housing shortage in for the long term. It has been established that letting people make big profits doing something is a great way to get more of the something - and that applies to renting out houses too. The only role for the government in making sure it is easy to build more houses and that everyone sticks to what they signed when it comes to contracts.
- spoonie 7y agoI agree, except that housing right now isn’t a free market precisely because of zoning rules that artificially limit what can be built and where. Until existing land owners lose the right to rig the market, markets should be rigged in favour of tenants who have less power. Where it’s easy to build new housing supply I’m in favour of looser rent control or removing rent control because it’ll be redundant.
- spoonie 7y agoYup it’s a combination of protecting those who are less powerful and I would argue a way to avoid perverse incentives. If a landlord can arbitrarily raise rent, they have no incentive to perform ongoing (inexpensive maintenance). They can wait until the problems become critical and much more expensive and then pass those costs onto the tenant. With rent control the landlord knows they have to control costs and has more incentive to perform the cheaper preventative maintenance.
- ISL 7y agoThis would encourage tearing down old rental units in order to build new rental units in their place.
- s_Hogg 7y agoAre you saying that because you think it's a good thing or a bad thing? Seems to me like either (or both) of these could be the case.
- jessaustin 7y agoIn most situations it would be good for rich renters and bad for poor renters, for an older building with apartment sizes and amenities that are typical of older buildings to be replaced by a new building with apartment sizes and amenities that are typical of new buildings.
- sampo 7y agoIt would be bad for those poor renters who already had apartment. But good for those poor renters who are just entering the market and looking for a home.
- jessaustin 7y agoPoor tenants are not renting new apartments. In general, you could say that new apartments are added to the overall stock so that's good for all renters. ITT however we're specifically talking about the kind of apartments that are rented by the poor being replaced on the same site by the kind of apartments that are rented by wealthier tenants. That is actually good for one group and bad for another group. Widely anticipated wonderful new laws are usually chock-full of this kind of crap. Lobbyists don't try to step in front of oncoming political trains. They do successfully redirect those trains to their own purposes.
- jdavis703 7y agoIn California there are tough demolition protections in the highest demand cities. Proposed state-wide legislation (SB 50) designed to spur homebuilding will actually make it illegal to demolish any home where a no-fault eviction has occurred. So at least in California I'm not too concerned about this particular side-effect.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoOlder buildings have all kinds of maintenance issues. Even if predictable, they're still an added expense, especially for major systems. Without allowing rental unit owners to pass those costs along to the renters, either the units will be taken off the rental market or they will be allowed to disintegrate over time until they're no longer habitable.
- shams93 7y agoYeah my la landlord just sat on my problems until my place was so bad it was unlivable then I lost my job and was forced into the street.
- spoonie 7y agoThat assumes that the market is able to bear those costs. What do landlords do in stable markets where rents are flat or track inflation? Are all rentals dilapidated in those markets?
- thepangolino 7y agoIn most of Europe building maintenance costs are counted outside of rent. This makes it difficult to hunt and compare flats as those costs can greatly vary.
- boomlinde 7y agoCombine it with laws that protect a decent standard for apartments and make it much harder to kick tenants out without a good reason. I.e. enforce basic tenants' protection instead of worrying about what incentives landlords have. It shouldn't matter whether the landlord wants to take a unit off the market if the tenants aren't willing or can't move. Then it lies on the landlord to create an incentive for tenants to move out, for example by extracting less rent from uncontrolled units to make them more affordable. Another good idea is for tenants to unionize and share the legal costs of e.g. questioning the legitimacy of a lease termination or challenging sub-standard living conditions.
- gamblor956 7y agoYou've literally just described LAs renters protections and tenants rights organisations in a nutshell...
- ajross 7y ago> I always found it odd that rent control always seems to be an all-or-nothing policy: either things are tamped down on, or it's a laissez faire system. It's not. Rent control argument on the internet looks like that because it's always a bunch of strawman arguments about political philosophy. In fact the Oregon laws in question have features exactly like what you're talking about.
- throw0101a 7y agoWhat are some other jurisdictions that have this tiered approach?
- ethbro 7y agoHow would you avoid only high-rent housing being built in place of any torn down units? This seems like it would still be rent-inflationary in nature, you just end up with younger average housing stock.
- briandear 7y agoOut of curiosity, have you ever owned a building? I might suggest that your opinions might change once you have. Owning rental property isn’t a tidy math problem. Newer buildings have more predictable costs, definitely not older buildings. It’s pretty much the opposite of what you said in the real world. Newer buildings can lease to higher quality tenants at higher rates with lower eviction/non-payment/damage risk. Older buildings can run the gamut. You can have an older building filled with stable senior citizens that runs perfectly for decades or you can have an older building filled with tenants who constantly break things, are late on rent, run meth labs, or simply trash a place and vacate in the middle of the night. You might have to evict someone and the process could take a year. Air conditioners fail randomly and expensively. Roof leaks develop and tenants might not even report it for months (yes, that sort of thing happens all the time. As a building gets older, the risks increase, but the rent you can charge decreases compared to a new building. My suggestion is to actually ask people who have owned building exactly why they oppose rent control so fiercely and the answers aren’t going to be about greed but about increased financial risk.
- jdavis703 7y agoIf we can agree that profit is essentially what we call "greed," any financial risk means deceased profits, in other words less opportunity for greed. I'm not a communist so I'm not against profit, but in Marxist theory this kind of profit is seen as the problem with capitalism.
- roenxi 7y agoYou might want to re-read your Marx; one of his more famous and less controversial observations was that the rate of profit tends to decrease over time in a healthy market. High rates of profit wasn't the problem, it was the negative effects that were theorised to occur when the rate of profits, inevitably, fell too low.
- throw0101a 7y ago> Owning rental property isn’t a tidy math problem. I'm not talking about owning, but about encouragement of building. If income is limited to CPI, regardless market characteristics, what incentive is there to take a risk and build?