5 ms·
Could the Apollo 11 moon landing be duplicated today? ‘Lots of luck with that’
- Causality1 7y ago>He is overseeing a plan to return to the moon by 2024 Problem being there's no more reason to do it now than there was then. Everything you can do on the moon you can do better in earth orbit. Every reason I get quoted for building a permanent presence on the moon requires technology that's decades away at best. The moon is just a distraction from the real challenge: Mars. We're too unmotivated and uncommitted to shoot for Mars so we're going to go jump around on the dead rock next door and pretend that means anything at all.
- baggy_trough 7y agoIs there any more reason to go to Mars than to go to the Moon?
- duckymcduckface 7y agoIt's easier to settle: more gravity, more atmospheric pressure, more resources and we haven't been there yet. Plenty of reasons to go to the moon as well but nothing that could inspire a generation like a Mars mission could.
- BurningFrog 7y agoI think the Moon is vastly easier to settle since Earth is just a few days away, as opposed to 1-2 years. That beats every other consideration, ease-wise.
- kart23 7y agoMeteorites will be a serious problem. Theres no atmosphere on the moon, which means everything gets through.
- BurningFrog 7y agoDoes the super this Martian atmosphere do a much better job? I suppose it handles the sand grain sized ones at least, and they might be 99% of the problem. IDK. Either way, I think any full time habitats will have to be underground ob both Moon and Mars because of the radiation.
- redis_mlc 7y agoThere's no reason to send manned missions to either. Well, except for the infantile HNer dream to get a free ride, someday, somehow.
- hazz99 7y agoWhy is it infantile to want to experience life on another planet/moon?
- BurningFrog 7y agoI think both have the Everest reason: They're there!!
- MahlerFive 7y agoHere's a great answer to that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j2Mu8qfVb5I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j2Mu8qfVb5I
- Ancalagon 7y agoExcellent excellent excellent speech. Thank you so much for sharing that video!
- JabavuAdams 7y agoYou don't think we'll learn anything useful by having an ISS-ish human settlement on the moon?
- Causality1 7y agoNothing worth the cost of supplying it. 1.8 million dollars per kilogram. We could cut that maybe in half with modern rockets. Still not worth it. There's just not enough in the gap between "things we can do in orbit" and "things we can do with robots".
- JabavuAdams 7y agoI dunno, robotics requires so much planning, and technology development. If we have humans at a site, we can be like "Hey, take this pick-axe and go dig over there". To get a robot to do that requires up-front design, development, funding, and the inevitable turf-wars and politics. Imagine going out to weed your garden vs. convincing a committee with various unaligned priorities to fund a project to build a system to weed your garden. Four years later, it's cancelled due to new President / shifting priorities. Humans are just generally capable at a level that robots are not -- it allows for less pre-planning, and all the pre-planning is what kills NASA's ability to do anything in a timely and efficient manner. EDIT> I am in awe of the work done to e.g. put Curiosity on Mars, but the longer we drag out the planning and dev phase, the greater the chance the political and bureaucratic effects will derail the engineering.
- Causality1 7y agoYou think a frigging moon base won't be subject to every single one of those problems and a hundred more besides?
- jimmaswell 7y agoSpace telescope on the moon seems like a good idea.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoWait for the baby boomers to die off. I'll be towards the tail end. :) Then humanity can go to the Moon, Mars, toroidal space stations, build high speed rail, maglev, and whatever else might be in the pipeline. Ignoring that everyone sold off the pipeline. With luck, my children's generation can rediscover government that isn't quite so comic book in its generation selfishness. With both left and right remembering to occasionally doing the things that are right and helps everyone. Like build housing, create and support public services, develop infrastructure and big national vanity (Apollo, Concorde, Bullet trains etc) and science projects.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoI agree that the boomers didn't do a good job but I am not sure the next generation will do any better. It seems the best and brightest of this generation are busy building total surveillance infrastructure to sell ads. I don't see much movement towards more community oriented thinking.
- jahewson 7y agoPeople respond to incentives. If we as a society incentivised community projects then we’d see more of them.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoThat's correct. I don't think we do though. Maybe there is some talk but the real money is in selling ads and other stuff.
- shoo 7y agoindividuals in government and society in turn responds to advertising, lobbying, influence, bribery from vested interests... So you can ask the question: if it would be rational for society to do $THING in its own collective self-interest, e.g. incentivize more community projects, then why doesn't it do that? And perhaps the answer is, within the current context, moving to that new state is no longer reachable...
- Chris_Chambers 7y agoAre there seriously still people who think we ever went to the moon? LOL.
- armada651 7y agoUnlike in the 60s these days it's far easier to just stage the moon landing rather than actually going there.
- kabdib 7y agoMaybe -- but you'd have a lot of people trying to listen in on radio communications (voice, telemetry) and those signals had better come from a plausible direction. That's for starters. I also wonder how common privately held telescopes and radar equipment is, stuff that could detect a spacecraft on the way to the moon. It seems practically impossible to spot an actual landing with a telescope, but you could probably determine if something about the right size had acclerated out of Earth orbit and was heading to the moon. Window of hours, probably. It'd be expensive to fake all this with enough fidelity to foil analysis tools that exist today (much less tools that will be available over the next few decades). It's probably cheaper to actually land on the moon again :-)
- simonh 7y agoI didn’t my see how it could have been faked back then, for the same reasons. Three radio telescopes were officially assigned to receive the video transmissions for the mission, but it was an unencrypted signal on a published frequency. The Russians could certainly track the vehicle on radar, at least on the boost there and return trajectory, and pick up any of its signals. Jodderal Bank in the UK certainly did. There’s no way they could reasonably have fooled the entire global optical and radio astronomy community plus the Russians. That’s all aside from the fact the limitations of video technology at the time would have made faking the video impossible because the tape tech to record a transmission that long didn’t exist for almost another decade. Or the fact thousands of people would have had to be in on the scam, many of them not even American. Also since then, multiple Lunar observation missions have photographed the equipment and even the dust trails left by the lunar rovers. The Chinese would also certainly know by now, with their recent high resolution surveys and landings on the moon.
- kaendfinger 7y ago
- neonate 7y agohttp://archive.is/zNgFb http://archive.is/zNgFb
- broth 7y agoIt's interesting to ponder the feats in technological advancement that were made in short periods of time in the 20th century. For example, in 1948 when the transistor was first revealed by Bell Labs to 1969 when mankind landed on the moon. Around 20 years. That's pretty amazing.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoI think that’s the case with most new technology. The first steps are very fast but then innovation goes much slower. You can see that for example in computing. PCs made a lot of fast progress until sometime in the 90s and then things stagnated. The same probably for cell phones. The last five years or more saw only incremental improvement. Nothing revolutionary.
- gervase 7y ago> PCs made a lot of fast progress until sometime in the 90s and then things stagnated. Transistor densities increased 2 orders of magnitude (~100x) between 1995 and 2005. Integer operations were a little less, maybe 1.5 oom, over the same period. When you say that PCs stagnated over that period, in what context did you mean?
- Ididntdothis 7y agoThey didn’t become much more useful. I mean that in the same sense that a car from 1950 and a car from today are not that much different. Yes the modern car is much better but the big jump was to be able to move from one point to another quickly which was achieved with cars from 1950 or earlier. Same for cell phones. Having a 3G connection and GPS was a huge step but since then I don’t see much revolutionary change.
- rlabrecque 7y agoAgreed, though I think there were 2 jumps with cell phones, the original mass produced ones circa the late 1990s, and then smart phones circa 2007-2008. Also this: https://www.tnhh.net/posts/google-maps-insane-backward-compatibility.html https://www.tnhh.net/posts/google-maps-insane-backward-compa...
- fortran77 7y agoI, too, wonder if you could build a high-quality team where you're free to choose the best people available, solely on proven ability to pilot, solve problems under pressure, and general engineering skills. (Collins was West Point and Harvard, Buzz Aldrin has a Sci.D. from MIT, Neil Armstrong was an experienced pilot and degrees from Purdue and USC). And that doesn't begin to show the skills of the leadership of the ground crew....
- Svekax 7y ago"Picture a man or woman of the late 19th century, perhaps your own great-grandfather or great-great-grandmother, sitting in an ordinary American home of 1890. And now pitch him forward in an H G Wells machine, not to our time but about halfway – to that same ordinary American home, circa 1950. Why, the poor gentleman of 1890 would be astonished. His old home is full of mechanical contraptions. There is a huge machine in the corner of the kitchen, full of food and keeping the milk fresh and cold! There is another shiny device whirring away and seemingly washing milady's bloomers with no human assistance whatsoever! Even more amazingly, there is a full orchestra playing somewhere within his very house. No, wait, it's coming from a tiny box on the countertop! The music is briefly disturbed by a low rumble from the front yard, and our time-traveler glances through the window: A metal conveyance is coming up the street at an incredible speed – with not a horse in sight. It's enclosed with doors and windows, like a house on wheels, and it turns into the yard, and the doors open all at once, and two grown-ups and four children all get out - just like that, as if it's the most natural thing in the world! He notices there is snow on the ground, and yet the house is toasty warm, even though no fire is lit and there appears to be no stove. A bell jingles from a small black instrument on the hall table. Good heavens! Is this a "telephone"? He'd heard about such things, and that the important people in the big cities had them. But to think one would be here in his very own home! He picks up the speaking tube. A voice at the other end says there is a call from across the country - and immediately there she is, a lady from California talking as if she were standing next to him, without having to shout, or even raise her voice! And she says she'll see him tomorrow! Oh, very funny. They've got horseless carriages in the sky now, have they? What marvels! In a mere 60 years! But then he espies his Victorian time machine sitting invitingly in the corner of the parlor. Suppose he were to climb on and ride even further into the future. After all, if this is what an ordinary American home looks like in 1950, imagine the wonders he will see if he pushes on another six decades! So on he gets, and sets the dial for our own time. And when he dismounts he wonders if he's made a mistake. Because, aside from a few design adjustments, everything looks pretty much as it did in 1950: The layout of the kitchen, the washer, the telephone... Oh, wait. It's got buttons instead of a dial. And the station wagon in the front yard has dropped the woody look and seems boxier than it did. And the folks getting out seem ...larger, and dressed like overgrown children. And the refrigerator has a magnet on it holding up an endless list from a municipal agency detailing what trash you have to put in which colored boxes on what collection days. But other than that, and a few cosmetic changes, he might as well have stayed in 1950. Let's pause and acknowledge the one exception to the above scenario: The computer. Instead of having to watch Milton Berle on that commode-like thing in the corner, as one would in 1950, you can now watch Uncle Miltie on YouTube clips from your iPhone. But be honest, aside from that, what's new? Your horseless carriage operates on the same principles it did a century ago. It's added a CD player and a few cup holders, but you can't go any faster than you could 50 years back. As for that great metal bird in the sky, commercial flight hasn't advanced since the introduction of the 707 in the 1950s. Air travel went from Wilbur and Orville to bi-planes to flying boats to jetliners in its first half-century, and then for the next half-century it just sat there, like a commuter twin-prop parked at Gate 27B at LaGuardia waiting for the mysteriously absent gate agent to turn up and unlock the jetway. ... 'I suggest the real reason we have not been to the moon since 1972 is that we cannot any longer do it. Humans have lost the capability. 'Of course, the standard line is that humans stopped going to the moon only because we no longer wanted to go to the moon, or could not afford to, or something... But I am suggesting that all this is BS... I suspect that human capability reached its peak or plateau around 1965-75 – at the time of the Apollo moon landings – and has been declining ever since.' Can that be true? Charlton is a controversialist gadfly in British academe, but, comparing 1950 to the early 21st century, our time traveler from 1890 might well agree with him. And, if you think about it, isn't it kind of hard even to imagine America pulling off a moon mission now? The countdown, the takeoff, a camera transmitting real-time footage of a young American standing in a dusty crater beyond our planet... It half-lingers in collective consciousness as a memory of faded grandeur, the way a 19th century date farmer in Nasiriyah might be dimly aware that the Great Ziggurat of Ur used to be around here someplace." --From Mark Steyn's "After America"
- tus88 7y agoPersonally I would rather see more advanced probes/rovers go to Mars and others than another moon landing.
- fuzzfactor 7y ago"I'll take Lunar Landings for a thousand, Alex" Alex: "The answer is; 'First Word Spoken From The Surface Of The Moon'"