3 ms·
One of the most fundamental tensions in human society is this: 1. For a society to be just, we should be able to use the fruits of our labor to provide for our
by munificent 7y ago
One of the most fundamental tensions in human society is this:
1. For a society to be just, we should be able to use the fruits of our labor to provide for our own children.
2. For a society to be fair, no should have an unearned advantage over another by virtue of being born to rich parents.
Any society that picks one rule and discards the other leads to a hellhole. If you pick 1 you get game-of-thrones-style tyrannical dynasties who own all of the wealth and use the poor as their serfs. Pick 2 and you get a pseudo-socialist dystopia where children are separated from their parents and raised in government-funded creches.
You can look at the inheritance tax rate as essentially the point the government picks on the continuum between those two extremes. Given the many many loopholes the wealthy have to avoid taxes on inheritance, I think the current rate is actually too low.
If you look at this from the perspective of the beneficiaries, sure, "losing" $600 million sucks. But they never earned it in the first place. It's not like the had to work hard to choose their family.
They still get something like half a billion dollars. That should be enough for them to scrape by. Meanwhile, think of all of the services that tax bill can provide for. College education for thousands of students. Healthcare for poor children. Environmental protection.