3 ms·
Whenever I’ve used AV I have found it to be worse than useless. Only detections are false positives, uses tons of systems resources, breaks commonly used apps.
by AlexandrB 7y ago
Whenever I’ve used AV I have found it to be worse than useless. Only detections are false positives, uses tons of systems resources, breaks commonly used apps.
I generally agree with Tavis Ormandy[1] that AV products often just increase the attack surface. Especially for applications that already have a high security focus (e.g. browsers). I’m somewhat surprised to see so many AV believers in the HN comments section.
[1] http://blog.cmpxchg8b.com/2016/03/security-software-certification.html?m=1 http://blog.cmpxchg8b.com/2016/03/security-software-certific...
- self_awareness 7y agoNeither you nor Tavis are taking into account non-technical people. Nobody forces you to use AV -- if you feel you have the skill to defend yourself, do yourself a favor (and us), and remove AV from your boxes. But leave non-technical people alone.
- michaelmrose 7y agoHerein lies the challenge. The user that is so ill trained that AV is a great idea actually needs an environment locked down sufficiently that he can't ruin his own day not a tool to analyze in real time whether he is doing so right now. Those more skilled would be better off just using their wits. The set between is empty.
- self_awareness 7y agoYou mean the user should not have access to computers? Because that is what you're implying. If the user can send and receive emails, this user is susceptible to attack.
- badrabbit 7y agoNeither you nor Mr. Ormandy is taking into account realistic threat models. I also suspect you're lumping traditional AVs with modern EDRs. If you anticipate targeted attacks you need an EDR solution of some sort (even if that meand cooking up your own with sysmon or auditd). If you anticipate crimeware, depending on your technical sophistication you need an EDR. If you're confident in yourself,consider the financial and data loss risks and you might be well off with only hardening your system and being careful. If the security company is considered a possible threat,try and come up with at lesst some sort of aggressive behavioral log monitoring. I have no idea why your comment is #1 on HN. Does no one here at least occadionally stumble upon malware and threat intelligence write ups? I thought I saw the post of krebsonsecurity on here last week or so where he exposed a member of Gandcrab after they retired the affiiate network ransomware after supposedly raking in $2B? You think EDRs can't catch that easily? I suspect you and even possibly Mr. Ormandy might be suffering from availability bias. Just because you don't see the prevalance and dynamic nature of the threat landscape,your threat model(or lack of one) might not be well informed. Patches and keeping up to date prevents vulnerabilities. Malware and hackers alike do not depend on software vulnerabilities,even if they did you can't defend against a zero by hardening against exploits alone(at least on windows)