5 ms·
VLSI Basics
- CalChris 7y agoBardeen, Brattain & Schockly invented transistor in 1948 (23rd dec. 1946). No. Lilienfeld invented and patented it in 1926. BBS invented an improved and practical transistor. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transistor https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transistor
- mikeash 7y agoIs it fair to say he invented it if it couldn’t be built?
- CalChris 7y agoYeah, I think it is. An objective measure for invention is the fact that the USPTO granted a patent. That is a relatively high bar. Subject matter eligible, novel, useful, non-obvious. A reduction to practice model isn't required. Practicality isn't required. Conversely, is it fair to say Shockley et al invented the transistor if someone else came up with the idea first? What they did was impressive and important. They deserve their fame. Hell, they won the freakin' Nobel Prize. But they didn't invent it. They improved it by leaps and bounds.
- adwn 7y ago> An objective measure for invention is the fact that the USPTO granted a patent. That is a relatively high bar. Subject matter eligible, novel, useful, non-obvious. No, this does not reflect reality at all. That's how it ought to be, and maybe it was more like this in 1926, but it's very different from how patents are granted today.
- mikeash 7y agoBy that standard, the space elevator was invented about twenty years ago by Robert Boyd and Dimitri Thomas. I don’t see this being a good way to determine inventorship (if that’s a word).
- close04 7y agoOr that they invented the manufacturing process. I know patenting process looks at a working device but I think the spirit of invention is creativity and if they were only creative at fabricating then this is their real invention.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mdonahoe 7y agoI wish it were easier to get into this stuff. Seems like a fun visual puzzle to do vlsi design, but fabricating the chips is hard, so I just stick with programming.
- rasz 7y ago>visual puzzle it was in the nineties, nowadays pretty much nobody routes manually, its all libraries of ready parts.