6 ms·
Steve Jobs may have been right when he said something to the effect of Dropbox isn't a product, it's a feature. If all you want is a folder that syncs, then don
by criddell 7y ago
Steve Jobs may have been right when he said something to the effect of Dropbox isn't a product, it's a feature. If all you want is a folder that syncs, then don't we get that from every commercial operating system?
- AstralStorm 7y agoThe remote storage and availability combined with the feature is the product. They sell this and it is important for it to be seamless as well. (Unlike say current iteration of Google Drive which sells both of the above but is not seamless.) Note that it is very easy to compete with them for any of the big players.
- bhouston 7y agoSoundBlaster sold sound cards as well, but then sound cards got integrated into the motherboards and now only <0.01% of people buy sound cards.
- speeder 7y agoWhat killed SBlaster was not motherboards having sound cards. It was movie studios convincing microsoft to ban from Windows the best featuresof SBlaster cards (those features are STILL banned by the way) because they were afraid of people using them to pirate movies. It is a reaaaaally long story, but to make it short: MS changed radically how windows drivers worked, and what a driver could do, during the transition to DVDs, it killed sound cards (because no more advanced 3D sound rendering that sound blaster could do), CRTs (no more funky resolutions, no more overlay mode, and other fancy CRT features), and initiated the slow death of VGA (that also happened for other reasons but this contributed a lot).
- koolba 7y agoWhere can I read more about this?
- thedaemon 7y agoDo you have a link to a source for this information? I personally stopped buying sound cards because they are now integrated on motherboards.
- criddell 7y agoSay you could run an experiment where in one universe motherboards were developed with integrated audio and Microsoft never cooperated with Hollywood and then in a second universe motherboards never included audio but Microsoft did cooperate with Hollywood. Clearly sound card makers have a big future in only one of those.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoI think it's safe to say CRTs were killed by their incredible bulk compared to LCD displays.
- stirfrykitty 7y agoBack in the early 2000s, our company phased out the huge 21" Sun boat anchor monitors for another smaller unit also with a 21" screen. They were put on the loading dock and we were told they were up for grabs. A colleague and I took several and the following weekend we took them to his private land where we proceeded to ascertain which handgun and rifle calibers were best at destroying them up close and at a distance. Up close .45 ACP was the winner. At a distance .308 was the winner. We also learned that a 6.5x55 Swedish will completely pass through one and lodge itself into a tree so deep we could not retrieve the projectile. Contrary to popular belief, monitors (at least these) did not explode when struck. Interestingly enough, the 6.5x55 will also handily pass through a HDD with no worries. All standard FMJ rounds.
- untog 7y agoThe vast majority of people didn't buy Sound Blaster cards for their advanced 3D sound rendering, though. They bought them to play sound at a level more advanced than a PC speaker, which is what most had at the time. Once motherboards integrated that there was no need for most people to buy a separate sound card. I know I didn't, especially when working out what you're spending your money on - video cards were far more important. But those, too, have become less important as integrated graphics have improved.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> Once motherboards integrated that there was no need for most people to buy a separate sound card. Sure, if you mean a strict majority of people, but what about gamers? There's no reason "most" people need to buy a separate videocard but it is still a huge market. For a time, a good soundcard was with advanced features for 3D sound rendering was looking like it was going to be just as important to PC gaming as good videocards.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoAlso because built-in cards had shitty Realtek chips. I remember fetching a Sound Blaster on my third PC just so that I could use custom drivers to bypass the Realtek chip and use a proper card with advanced DSP support.
- derefr 7y ago> They bought them to play sound at a level more advanced than a PC speaker, which is what most had at the time. Yes, but why were they buying Sound Blaster cards instead of the much cheaper audio cards that were also on the market at the same time, but just didn’t have the same advanced feature set? The SoundBlaster, when it came out, was the “premium, workstation-tier” product of the audio-card world! Are you suggesting the SoundBlaster’s rise was entirely down to 1. Brand recognition, or 2. even the top-of-market cards still being cheap enough that a strategy of “satisficing with the most expensive thing you can easily afford” would have led people to the SoundBlaster; and not at all to its differentiating feature-set from other audio cards?
- 7y ago
- theamk 7y agoI don't think this is the case. I remember seeing something about 3D sound in the card settings, thinking "that's not going to work with my 2.1 speaker system, must be just a useless gimmiky DSP" -- and never using it again. Most of my friends had the same experience. Later on, I got a new computer and a much better speakers, and spent some time getting digital output to work. I used my motherboard for that, because at this stage, I wanted soundcard to be just a simple, stupid data sender. No DSP, no "advanced 3D sound rendering" -- the ideal sound card takes data from input (DVD) and sends them to speakers, acting as a dumb data pipe. Same goes for "fancy CRT features" -- what is that exactly that CRTs can do that flat-screens can not? Other than duck hunt-style controllers, I don't think there is anything.
- barrkel 7y agoThe 3D sound rendering with Thief back in the day was amazing. Positional audio. Then that tech seemed to just disappear for a decade.
- plorkyeran 7y agoMicrosoft made dramatic changes to how sound drivers worked that caused problems for SoundBlaster's advanced features, but the explanation at the time was that SoundBlaster's garbage drivers were responsible for a sizeable portion of Windows' BSODs, and redesigning the driver model was a critical part of making the OS stable. I've never seen a reason to doubt that narrative. Overlay mode wasn't a CRT feature, and worked fine with flat panel displays with XP. The introduction of GPU compositing in Vista was what killed it, but it still continued to work in 7 if you turned compositing off. The death of funky resolutions was entirely a result of switching to hardware which has a native resolution, and not anything software side.
- jbverschoor 7y agoWow you are messing up timelines and your projecting your experience/reason/hobbies on the market. DVD drives weren’t even a thing when people stopped buying soundcards. Yeah a small selection wanted 3d sound for a gaming edge, and that was available on low cost cards pretty soon. Before that they a place, but all features were available through software. The mixer, sampler, channels.
- cat199 7y ago> DVD drives weren’t even a thing when people stopped buying soundcards. pretty sure these happened at around the same time. Single data point: my 486-era machine (92): - bolt on sb16+cdrom as part of 'multimedia upgrade' (MPC II) my pentium-I era machine (96): - came with sb16+cdrom (MPC III) my pentium-II era machine (98): - came with integrated DVD-ROM + ac97 audio none of these were particularly 'special' as far as 'what people were buying then'
- derefr 7y agoSo... modern audio drivers, used by a 3D game, can’t generate the same kind of environmental 8.1-channel signal that you’d find on a Blu-Ray? If so, I’m surprised nobody’s hacked around that by now by just e.g. using the GPU in GPGPU mode as an pseudo-FPGA, dropping audio DSP logic onto it, and generating their “HD 3D” audio using that.
- bhouston 7y agoSteve Jobs was right and Dropbox is having problems as a result. They are trying to differentiate but it hasn't been working out, it seems to be muddling in various different directions.
- aero142 7y agoThis feels like the “we’re all dead in the long run” version of right.
- EpicEng 7y agoI don't think so. He specifically called out the fact that their entire product is eventually going to be a single feature in every consumer OS. And now it is. That hardly applies to every product/service out there.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoThe problem here is that the biggest value of that product is that there is one of it. We have three major desktop OSes and two major phone OSes, people have multiple devices - usually at least one running a desktop OS and one running a mobile OS. File syncing as an OS feature has significantly less utility, because OS vendors can't get their shit together and agree on a standard, cross-platform solution. This is very much a "we're all dead in the end" observation. Any good enough product is gonna get killed by turning it into multiple instances of mutually incompatible features, in a war for market share that claims user's time and patience as collateral damage.
- EpicEng 7y ago>We have three major desktop OSes and two major phone OSes, people have multiple devices - usually at least one running a desktop OS and one running a mobile OS. Sure... Kinda. How many people spend a lot of time on desktop these days? I see two large camps; windows + Android and... Well, Mac (e.g. iPad + iPhone). Those combos already work (MS client runs on android.) How many people run android + iPad/MacBook, windows + iPhone, or Linux? I imagine not too many, which is perhaps why DB is so focused on Enterprise.
- wukerplank 7y agoIf it's part of the OS, it's probably not cross-platform... I still use Dropbox because it runs everywhere: NAS, Windows, Mac and my phone. (At work we use Google Drive, it it just sucks. File Stream is super buggy and the web UI lacks a lot of productivity features.)
- jgalentine007 7y agoDrive / File Stream is like the late 90's Norton antivirus of syncing apps. I can't believe how much it slowed down my wife's 3 year old laptop.
- Applejinx 7y agoI stopped using it because I run an old computer on Mac 10.6.8 for development purposes, and I'd been using Dropbox as my communications protocol. It stopped supporting 10.6 and I stopped supporting it. Mind you, it'd been losing favor with me for changing the interface around and adding annoying stuff: the github desktop app has been doing similar things after being acquired by Microsoft, so I anticipate one day moving to full terminal git no matter how cumbersome that might be, just to get away from the 'helpfulness'.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoSame here. I moved up to Mountain Lion about a year ago (yeah, I know, but I have good reasons for using old Apple operating systems) and then Dropbox stopped supporting Mountain Lion. Which does not mean that the product stops getting updated. It means THE PRODUCT STOPS WORKING. There was no good technical reason for this; it was just arbitrary Dropbox fuckery. Yet another reason I'm leaving.
- greenleafjacob 7y agoUnfortunately Dropbox recently dropped support for certain Linux file systems like XFS, BTRFS, etc. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17732912 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17732912
- 7y ago
- dunnevens 7y agoI think there’s a strong case to be made for companies that do one thing and do it extremely well. A feature can be cut. It can be abandoned. It can be the thing no one wants to work with because it gets the reputation of being the department where careers go to die. Whereas a feature as product means it’s more likely to stick around. They have nothing to do but build and maintain this feature. They have the luxury of working out the edgiest of edge cases. But I guess the pointless file manager shows the downside of features as product. One the product is complete and largely bug free, marketing and engineers get itchy in their unique ways.
- pandalicious 7y agoSpotify vs Google Play Music is the perfect showcase for this. They both get the job done but Spotify is better in so many small ways. Meanwhile, instead of being improved, GPM is in the process of being abandoned for the new shiny thing, Youtube Music.
- plopz 7y agoI've been looking for an alternative to Google Play Music. I only use it to sync my albums from my pc to my phone and play them offline in the car. Does Spotify have a feature like that? Edit: It looks like you have to pay for it and the music has to be in playlists. Not quite what I'd like.
- criddell 7y agoI believe Spotify allows you to upload 10,000 tracks.
- vageli 7y ago> Spotify vs Google Play Music is the perfect showcase for this. They both get the job done but Spotify is better in so many small ways. Meanwhile, instead of being improved, GPM is in the process of being abandoned for the new shiny thing, Youtube Music. What degredation have you noticed that makes you think it is being abandoned?
- fit2rule 7y agoBecause OS vendors care more about making money on the Internet than making operating systems with features that people want.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoYou get a semi-walled garden from every commercial OS.
- jbverschoor 7y agoiCloud Drive?
- mrlala 7y agoIf OneDrive was as good as dropbox then yes it would be awesome. But it's not.. as I've written in other posts here, onedrive just cannot handle tons of files. When you get over like 50-100k it just shits the bed and can't handle anything. So yeah for people that don't have much and just want to keep some data synced across some machines.. yup onedrive is great and there's no reason to use a third party service when you can just log into your windows with your live account and it's all synced. But if you've ever run into the problems with onedrive then it's a complete killer. You can't use a file syncing service that doesn't work perfectly all the time.